Breaking the Ice

Chapter 58: The First Anniversary

The diner hadn't changed, which was somehow the strangest part.

Same cracked vinyl booths. Same laminated menus with the corners curling. Same smell of coffee that had been sitting on the burner since before either of them was born. Megan slid into the booth by the window, the one they'd taken that first night, and Luke sat across from her like he'd been doing it his whole life.

"A year," he said.

"A year since you spilled a milkshake on my case files."

"I did not spill it. It wobbled. The table's uneven."

Megan pointed at the table. "It's the same table."

"Exactly. Still uneven." He picked up the menu even though they both knew what he was ordering. "You know, most people celebrate anniversaries at restaurants with tablecloths."

"Most people didn't meet over a hip flexion assessment."

"You were wearing a lab coat."

"It was a cardigan."

"It was a lab coat, and you know it."

The waitress came by, older, hair pinned up, and didn't bother writing anything down. Luke ordered the patty melt and a black coffee. Megan ordered the same thing she'd ordered the first time, which she hadn't even planned, and only realized after the words left her mouth.

"Two patty melts," the waitress said, and walked off.

"Sentimental," Luke said.

"Practical. It's the only thing here I trust."

He reached across the table and took her hand. She let him, which still felt like a decision some mornings and like breathing on others. A year ago she'd had a seven-year-old, a mountain of surgical debt, and a job she was afraid to lose. Now she had the same kid, the same job, the same house with the same rattling furnace. But the debt was gone, and her name was cleared, and the man across from her had stood in front of a room full of lawyers and told the truth about his own team.

Some things you don't get to plan. You just get to notice them.

"How's Ethan?" Luke asked. He asked every time, even when he'd seen Ethan that morning at practice.

"He asked me last night if you were going to be at the game Saturday."

"I'm coaching the game Saturday."

"That's what I told him."

Luke's mouth did the thing it did when he was trying not to smile. "What'd he say?"

"He said, 'Good, because otherwise he'd have to watch from the stands like a regular dad.'"

Luke went quiet for a second. Megan watched him decide not to say the obvious thing, which she appreciated, because they had a whole set of unspoken rules about the obvious thing and neither of them had found the right moment to break them.

The patty melts arrived. They ate. Luke told her a story about a rookie who'd taped his own stick wrong and refused to admit it for three practices. Megan told him about a high school pitcher with a shoulder she was ninety percent sure had been misdiagnosed by the same clinic Warren's people used to consult with.

"Ninety percent," Luke said.

"Eighty. I need the MRI."

"Tell me when you know."

"I will."

That was another thing that had changed. A year ago she'd have handled it alone and mentioned it three weeks later, if at all. Now she said it out loud at a diner table and he just nodded like it was information he was supposed to have.

When the plates were cleared, Luke didn't ask for the check. He pulled something out of his jacket pocket instead. Small. A key on a plain brass ring, no fob, nothing fancy. He set it on the table between them and didn't say anything.

Megan looked at it.

"Luke."

"It's just a key."

"It's not just a key."

"No," he said. "It's not."

She didn't pick it up. The waitress drifted by with the coffee pot and topped off Luke's cup and gave Megan a look that said she'd seen worse things happen at this table, then moved on.

"I'm not asking you to give up your house," Luke said. "I'm not asking you to do anything. It's a key. You can put it in a drawer. You can throw it in the lake. But I want you to have it, because every time you leave my place at eleven at night because Ethan has school in the morning, I stand at the window like an idiot and watch your car until it turns."

Megan looked at the key. Then at him.

"Eleven at night," she said. "Try ten-forty."

"I rounded."

"You always round."

"Megan."

She picked it up. It was cold. Heavier than it looked, the way keys always are.

"There's a thing I have to say first," she said.

"Okay."

"Ethan's not going to understand what this means. He's seven. He's going to think it means you're there when he wakes up, and if you're not there when he wakes up, he's going to think something's wrong. That's how he's built. He doesn't do ambiguity."

"I know."

"And I don't do ambiguity either, so I need you to hear me say this out loud. If I take this, I'm not taking it as a spare key for the nights the weather's bad. I'm taking it because I've been standing at my own kitchen window doing the same thing you just described, and I'm tired of pretending I haven't."

Luke didn't say anything for a second. Then he said, "You've been doing that?"

"Every time."

He laughed, low, mostly to himself. "A year. A whole year of us both standing at windows."

"We're slow learners."

"We're cautious," he said. "There's a difference."

Megan turned the key over in her fingers. There were logistics in her head already, the way there always were, because she was a person who did logistics whether she wanted to or not. Two houses. Ethan's school. Luke's practice schedule. Where the dog would go, if there was a dog, which there wasn't, but she'd already gotten that far in her head before she caught herself.

"I have conditions," she said.

"Of course you do."

"I'm serious. If this is going to happen, I want to do it properly. Not a drawer key. Not an overnight bag that lives in your trunk. Either we're doing this or we're not."

Luke leaned back. "Then let's do it."

"That's not a plan."

"It's a start."

Megan put the key in her pocket. It sat there the whole drive home, and she kept checking that it was still there with her thumb, the way she used to check Ethan's car seat straps when he was small.

They got back to her house around ten. The porch light was on, and through the front window she could see the shape of the living room, and the shape of Ethan's backpack on the couch where he'd thrown it, and the whole ordinary architecture of a life she'd built by herself because she hadn't had another option.

Luke walked her to the door. He didn't try to come in.

"So," he said.

"So," Megan said. "You want to move in here, or me there, or what?"

He blinked. "You're asking now?"

"I'm asking now, because if I wait until morning I'll spend the whole night running numbers on napkins and by morning I'll have talked myself into something sensible and wrong."

Luke laughed. "Here. Your house."

"Why?"

"Because it's Ethan's house. His room, his school, his street. And because you've got the better kitchen."

"I have a terrible kitchen."

"You have a kitchen. I have a countertop with a microwave on it."

Megan looked back through the window at the backpack on the couch. His life was already in there, in every scratched baseboard and pencil mark on the doorframe. Moving him would be a bigger thing than moving her. And she'd already moved him once, when he was three, and it had taken him a year to stop asking about the old apartment.

"Here," she said. "But we do it slow. And I mean slow, Luke. He needs to know before anything changes."

"He will."

"And you need to talk to your landlord."

"I will."

"And I need to talk to Ethan tonight, because if he hears it from someone else he'll never trust either of us about anything again."

Luke nodded. He looked at her for a long moment, and then he kissed her, brief, on the porch, under the light, like they were in a commercial and neither of them cared.

When he drove off, Megan stood on the porch with the key in her pocket and her hand on the door, not going in yet.

Because there was one thing she hadn't said to him, and it had been sitting in her chest the whole drive home. The interview had run Sunday. It had gone wide. And yesterday, buried in her inbox under six forwarded press requests and a scheduling email from the ethics committee chair, there was a message from the league auditing office's general counsel with a subject line that read only: *Colleen Ruiz — reopened.*

Nobody had touched that file in two years. Until she'd put her name on it.

Megan unlocked the door. Inside, Ethan was asleep on the couch with his mouth open and the game puck balanced on his chest. She turned off the TV, carried him up the stairs, and stood in the hallway for a minute afterward, listening to the house.

One key. One conversation. One file coming back to life.

She went to bed and didn't sleep much.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 58: The First Anniversary · Breaking the Ice · Lumen Reads