Counterpoint

Chapter 55: The Board Reads the Transcript

The envelope was still in his coat pocket when he reached the Philharmonie at eight forty. Snow had come in overnight, thin and grey, and the wind off the Spree cut along the Herbert-von-Karajan-Straße with nothing to stop it. The stage door was unlocked. Herr Wolter sat behind his desk with a thermos and the morning paper, and when he saw Jonas he folded the paper over like a man covering something.

"They're already in the small hall."

"Already."

"Half past seven, Herr Kessler came. Then Doktor Brandt. Then Frau Zemlinsky." Wolter looked at the envelope in Jonas's hand. "You'll want to read that before you go in. But you haven't much time for it."

Jonas read it standing against the wall in the corridor, under the poster for the spring programme, his own name in it twice. The document was four pages. The first page was procedure. The second was the transcript of the interview, timestamped, with his own call-in bracketed in square quotes, his voice rendered into flat type: *I didn't contribute to that record. Not to any part of it.* The third page was questions for his written response, seven of them, the seventh asking whether he wished to be represented by counsel at the hearing. The fourth page was blank except for the date line, and the date was the fifth of March, eleven days out.

He had not written a word in response. The deadline was nine.

The small hall seated sixty. Twelve chairs were arranged in a semicircle around a table, and only four were occupied. Kessler sat at the end with his reading glasses on and a folder squared in front of him. Brandt, the orchestra's lawyer, sat to his right, a phone face-down by his hand, recording. Zemlinsky, who played second oboe and had been on the works council for six years, sat to the left with a notebook. The fourth chair held a pot of coffee and a stack of cups nobody had touched.

"Sit, Herr Frei," Kessler said. "You have the document."

"I have it."

"Then you know what we're doing and you know I'm not going to ask you whether any of it is true." Kessler opened the folder and turned it a hundred and eighty degrees so Jonas could see the transcript on top. "This is not a trial. This is a suspension pending a hearing, and the hearing is where you argue. Today is about the orchestra, and the orchestra is on the front page of three papers. In this country, a concertmaster who is on the front page for being in a club record is a concertmaster who has stopped being a concertmaster."

"I'm the substitute. I was never the concertmaster."

"You understand my point."

Zemlinsky cleared her throat. "Herr Frei, I want to say this before we go further. The works council pushed back on the timing. I said nine in the morning on one day's notice is not how we treat anyone, particularly not someone who has played here four seasons without a complaint on his file. I was overruled."

"Thank you," Jonas said.

"You won't thank me when you hear the rest," she said, and looked at Kessler, and Kessler nodded.

"Suspension," he said, "with immediate effect, pending the March fifth hearing. Full pay. You will not perform with the orchestra. You will not rehearse with the orchestra. You will not enter the building except by written invitation for the hearing itself, and you will not contact members of the ensemble about this matter, in any form, in any medium. If you do any of those things, the hearing becomes a termination hearing. Is that clear?"

"Clear."

"Second. The solo."

The coffee pot ticked, cooling.

"The Prokofiev on the eleventh of April," Kessler went on. "The programme goes to press at the end of February. I cannot send a substitute soloist to press when that soloist is on the front page. We're replacing you. Weber is available and has played it with the Konzerthaus."

"Ruth Weber."

"Yes."

Jonas heard himself say, "She'll do it well," which was true and cost him something, and Kessler's face did not change at all, and that was the worst of it, how much it cost and how little it registered.

"Third," Kessler said. "Your seat. Your filing status is suspended along with everything else, but I want it said in front of Doktor Brandt: if the hearing goes badly, we will not merely decline to renew. We have grounds to terminate. You should prepare accordingly and you should prepare with someone who is not emotionally invested."

Brandt slid a card across the table without looking up. "This is the number for the orchestra's insurer's legal line. Free consultation, two hours. After that it's your business."

"Fourth," Kessler said. "The rest of your correspondence regarding the record and the DJ. If it's discoverable, hand it over before the hearing. All of it. The night is not going to get shorter."

Jonas picked up the card, and inside the two seconds it took to reach for it, he made a decision he would think about for months: he did not mention the rosin cake in his pocket. He did not mention that Milo had been at the stage door last night. He did not mention the messages, the eleven calls, the ones he had declined with the phone face-down on the kitchen table and watched light up the ceiling.

"There's nothing discoverable," he said.

Zemlinsky wrote something in her notebook. She wrote it slowly and the pen was loud.

"You have until nine to give us your written response," Kessler said. "There's a notepad."

"I'll bring it to the hearing."

"No. You'll bring it to me now. The process needs something on paper. Even one sentence."

Jonas sat down at the semicircle and wrote one sentence on the notepad. *I am requesting the hearing and I will respond fully at that time.* He signed it. His hand did not shake, which surprised him, and it only afterwards occurred to him that the reason was that none of it had landed yet — the solo, the building, the ensemble, none of it had landed. He was writing his name on a piece of paper in a small hall and then he would walk out of a building he had walked into every morning for four years and that would be that, and his hand did not shake.

"Frau Zemlinsky will confirm the hearing date in writing today," Kessler said, closing the folder. "One more thing. The press office has a statement. It says the orchestra has no comment on a private matter between a member and a third party, and that the member's status is under internal review. Do not talk to anyone until then. Not to a journalist, not to a colleague, and not to any person connected to that record. If the artist in question calls you, and I understand he has been calling, you do not answer. Is that clear?"

The building was quiet in the way it was never quiet. Rehearsal started at ten. The small hall smelled of coffee and floor wax and Jonas stood at the table a beat too long, and then he gathered the four pages, and the lawyer's card, and he walked out and shut the door behind him, and the sound of the door was the last sound the building was going to give him for a while.

His locker was in the corridor past the canteen. Ruth Weber was already there with her violin case and her coat half on, and when she saw him she stopped with her arm in a sleeve.

"Jonas."

"I know. You've been asked. Take it."

"I told Kessler I didn't want it that way."

"I know. Take it anyway. You'll be better than I would have been — the cadenza's in your hand." He opened his locker. Inside were two pencils, a spare E string, a photograph of his mother at fifty in the garden in Zehlendorf, and his violin, which he had left after last night's rehearsal. He had brought it in and left it, and if he had taken the rosin cake back to the flat it had only been the rosin; the instrument had stayed at the building like a claim.

He took it out. He took the photograph. He left the pencils and the string.

"Jonas," Ruth said, quiet. "Is it true? The thing on the radio."

"Which part."

"Any of it."

He closed the locker and put the photograph in his coat and held the violin case in his left hand the way he always held it, by the handle, strap over his shoulder, and something in the weight of it felt different, as if the case had grown heavier or his arm weaker. And in that moment, before he answered Ruth, before he walked the long corridor to the stage door for the last time until the fifth, before Wolter looked up and did not say anything kind because nothing kind was available, Jonas had a thought he could not get rid of, arriving as cleanly as a downbeat: he had told Kessler there was nothing discoverable. There was. There was the flyer without his name on it, reprinted, sitting in Milo's pocket somewhere in Kreuzberg. And there was the one thing on this earth that could prove he had done all of it, that he had built that record, and that thing was not any document. It was Thursday, and Milo would decide on Thursday, and Jonas, as of nine in the morning, was nobody's concertmaster and nobody's soloist, with nothing left to protect.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 55: The Board Reads the Transcript · Counterpoint · Lumen Reads