Counterpoint

Chapter 56: The Lecture Demon

The conservatory was a converted factory in Wedding, and the practice rooms still had the ghost of machine oil in the walls. Jonas got the job on a Tuesday, four days after Kessler signed the suspension. The interim department head, a bassoonist named Frau Ostermann who had never heard of him and therefore did not care, handed him a schedule printed on carbon paper.

"Five students. Scales, etudes, one concerto between all of them. Mostly you will teach them to breathe." She squinted at his violin case. "You are not to discuss any orchestra matters. Your name is not on the door. You understand."

He understood. He taught for six hours, and by the end of it his jaw ached from talking. He corrected a girl's bow grip four hundred times and she corrected it back. He told a boy to play the Bruch slowly and the boy played it fast. In the last hour of light he stood in a stairwell and realized he had not touched his own instrument all day, which was the first day in twenty years he could say that, and the fact sat in him like a swallowed stone.

He needed advice. He couldn't call anyone from the orchestra — Kessler's order read like a cordon. Zemlinsky would have answered, probably, but Zemlinsky had a hearing to prepare for and Jonas didn't want to spend the man's credibility before March.

So he called Ada, and she said come Tuesday, and gave him an address in Schöneberg.

Her flat was on the fifth floor with no lift, and the last flight smelled like boiled cabbage and cleaning solution. She opened the door holding a bowl of soup in one hand and a pencil behind her ear, and looked at him the way she had looked at him twenty years ago after he'd broken a window and lied about it.

"You look like a wet coat," she said. "Come in."

The flat was three rooms and a kitchen and every surface had stacks on it: scores, folders, manuscript paper, a cassette deck with a cracked lid. She cleared him a chair by setting the piles on the floor. He sat. She put the soup in front of him without asking.

"I saw the clip," she said.

"Right."

"Three times. Milo's face. Your voice on the phone. I have to say, Jonas, in fifty years of listening to musicians lie about themselves, that was a good one."

He ate the soup because his hands wanted a job. It was leek and potato and too much salt.

"She asked me to come after rehearsal," he said. "Back then. Before all this. I sent her a message. She didn't answer, and then I didn't chase it, and then everything happened." He set the spoon down. "That's not why I'm here."

"You're here because I'm the only person in Berlin who isn't in the paper right now and also knows your mother's handwriting."

"You're here because I want your opinion on whether I should fight the suspension or let it stand."

Ada took the pencil from behind her ear and pointed it at him. "Wrong question. Fight the suspension, let it stand — those are the surface. What are you actually asking?"

He looked at the stacks. He could see, at the edge of one, the corner of a score in his mother's hand — the old brown ink she used, the way she crossed her t's with a little upward hook.

"I don't know if quitting is the answer or the punishment," he said.

"Ah." Ada sat down across from him with her own soup. "So there's a third door and you're standing in it."

"There's a hearing on the fifth. They want me to prove I'm not — " He stopped. Kessler's voice: *conduct unbecoming.* "They want me to explain myself. In front of Kessler and three people I've played second fiddle to for eight years."

"And what would you say?"

"That it was a job. That I needed the money. That I never took a fee bigger than the fee." He turned the bowl a quarter turn. "That's true."

"Mm. And the other thing?"

He didn't answer.

Ada ate for a while. Her flat was quiet in a way that had cost her something to build — no television, no radio he could see, no neighbor noise through the wall. Just the pencil on the table and the soup and a woman who had heard every version of this story.

"Here's what I know," she said finally. "Your mother sat in that chair, in about 1998, and said the same sentence to me. 'Ada, is quitting the answer or the punishment.' She was talking about the ensemble she'd built with your father, which had folded, and she was talking about whether to stop altogether. And I told her what I'm going to tell you, which is: quitting is a decision. Not a verdict. It doesn't have a moral content. People keep trying to make it carry one because they want the pain to mean something."

"You told her to quit?"

"I told her to decide, and to say the decision out loud in a room with one other person in it, and to notice how it felt in her chest when it came out. That's how you find out which one it is." She shrugged. "She decided to keep playing. She played terribly for two years and then she played better than she ever had. That part is her, not me."

Jonas put both hands around the bowl. The soup had gone cool. He thought about the locker with his spare E string and his pencils still in it, and his mother's photograph now in his violin case, and the way the doorman had watched him leave. He thought about nine o'clock the next morning and the insurer's line card still in his coat pocket, unused, and the eleven missed calls from Kreuzberg, and what he actually wanted to hear if any of them landed.

"If I go to the hearing," he said, "I have to say his name."

"You've said his name on the radio."

"I said he wasn't real."

"Then you've got a strategy problem, not a stomach problem." Ada put her spoon down. "Listen. I've got thirty years of material in this flat. Two hundred hours of tape, maybe more. Your mother's arrangement book is in there somewhere, and the ensemble charts from before you were born, and a stack of programs nobody's ever catalogued. I don't sleep much and I don't bend down that far anymore. You want advice, here's my advice. Sort it."

He blinked. "Sort it."

"Alphabetical by composer, then by date. Tapes in the small boxes, they'll fit the shelf by the window if you take out the old insurance files." She stood and started moving piles off a desk with both arms, like a woman sweeping snow. "You'll be here Tuesdays and Thursdays. You'll get paid in soup."

"That's not — "

"I know what it's not." She stopped and turned. Her face was the face from twenty years ago, unsoftened. "You're suspended. You can't play in the building and you can't call anybody in it and if you sit in that flat of yours polishing your E string for three weeks you'll come to March fifth with nothing but your own voice in your head, and that voice is not going to be useful to you. So you'll come here and you'll work with your hands, and in between the tapes and the scores you'll decide. Out loud. To me. And I will not be gentle about it."

He almost smiled. He picked up his spoon and ate the cold soup down to the bottom to keep from having to answer.

On his way out, she handed him a canvas bag. He looked inside: a fat manila folder labeled in his mother's hand with the year he was born, and a cassette with a label that had gone soft with age.

"That's tape one," Ada said. "I catalogued them once, in '04, and then I lost the catalogue. So it's your turn. Start at the beginning, it's more honest that way."

He carried it down all five flights. At the bottom, on the street, under the yellow sodium light, he put the bag on the ground and opened the folder there in the cold. It was an ensemble chart. Handwritten, his mother's brown ink, four players plus piano, and the last line was a tune he had never seen before, with a title written in small letters at the top right, no dedication, no inscription.

The title was a single word, and it was not a word he had ever heard her say.

He sat down on the front step with the folder open on his knees and did not go home for a long time.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 56: The Lecture Demon · Counterpoint · Lumen Reads