The boat was a converted lobster hauler, white hull, green trim, thirty-two feet of stubborn Maine fiberglass that smelled like bait and cold salt. Ben stood at the wheel with both hands, throttling down as they cleared the breakwater.
Nathan sat on the stern bench with the second letter in his coat pocket. He hadn't opened it. He had been not-opening it for an hour, since Ben had said, quietly, "You don't have to come," and Nathan had climbed aboard anyway, because the alternative was going back to the bookstore and being the man the letters described, and he wasn't sure he wanted to meet that man.
"Two hours to Kennebunkport," Ben said over the engine. "If the wind holds."
"Fine."
"Daniel liked this run. He used to sit right where you're sitting."
Nathan looked at the bench, then out at the water. "You keep saying things like that."
"What do you want me to say?"
"I want you to say why he was on this boat with you and not with me." It came out flatter than he meant. "April. The logbook. You were there."
Ben didn't answer. The engine droned. A gull cut a line across the gray sky.
Nathan took out the letter. The envelope was the same as the first one: cream, no return address, the flap sealed with the flat of Daniel's thumb. He'd opened the first one at the lighthouse three days ago, and he'd read it so many times he could recite it. He had not opened the second because the first had ended with a line that sat in him like a swallowed stone — *When you get to Rockland, look for what I left.*
He'd found the slip. *Ellis. 1954. Ask him what he did.*
That was the second letter's door, if there was a door. He slid his thumb under the flap.
Two pages, folded in thirds. Daniel's hand was not shaking here. It was the handwriting Nathan had known for eleven years — the left-slanting scrawl that filled the special-order slips at the shop, that wrote *good morning* on the register tape, that had written *I love you* exactly twice that Nathan could find.
*Dear Nathan,*
*If you're reading this, you're on your way to Kennebunkport, and Ben is probably driving you, because Ben is the only person I trusted to get you there. I know what you think of that. I know what he did to you nine years ago. I'm asking you to read the rest before you decide what to do about it.*
Nathan stopped. Ben's shoulder blades were visible under the sweater, tensed. Nathan read on.
*There's a debt. You don't know about it because I made sure you didn't. Eight thousand dollars. I borrowed it from Ben in April, and I told him not to tell you, and I told him it had to be a secret because you would have tried to pay it back and you couldn't, and I couldn't watch you try. The bookshop needed it. You needed it. The first thing you'll ask is why I didn't ask you, and the answer is: because you would have said no, and gone to the bank, and gotten the loan you only got denied for anyway.*
Nathan's jaw tightened.
*I tried to pay him back. In June, I sold the truck. In July, I sold the tools. He wouldn't take the money. He kept saying it wasn't that kind of loan. He kept saying it wasn't a loan. I don't know what to make of that. I've been trying to figure out what Daniel wanted from him, and I'm running out of time.*
Nathan looked at the last line for a long moment. It was the only point in the whole letter where Daniel had slipped into the present tense, as if he had written it in fragments between doctor visits, losing the thread of his own grammar.
*Forgive him. Please. Not because he deserves it. Because I asked.*
The second page was a list. Three items.
*Kennebunkport. The cove below the Crow's Nest — you'll know it. Scatter.*
*Find the keeper's daughter. Her name is Margaret. The Crow's Nest. Ask about her father.*
*Don't pay Ben back. That's mine to do, or it's mine not to do.*
Nathan folded the pages. His hands were not steady. He looked up.
Ben had turned his head halfway. Watching the water, but watching Nathan.
"You knew," Nathan said.
"Knew what."
"The money."
Ben didn't move. The boat pushed through a swell; spray came off the bow and the wheel corrected lazy, practiced. "He told you."
"He told me in a letter he wrote when he couldn't hold a pen straight. Two pages. He sold his truck." Nathan's voice came out low and hard. "He sold his truck, Ben. I thought — I thought he sold it because he couldn't drive anymore. That's what he told me. *Couldn't drive anymore.*"
Ben's jaw worked. "He could still drive in June."
"You let him lie to me."
"I didn't *let* him. He made me promise."
"He made you promise a lot of things." Nathan stood up, and the boat rocked, and Ben reached out reflexively toward him, one hand off the wheel, and Nathan ignored it. "The logbook. The secrets. The eight thousand dollars. What else did he make you promise? What else is on that list you were so careful to sign?"
Ben turned back to the wheel and steadied it. "That's the whole list."
"Don't."
"That's the whole list, Nathan. I don't have another one."
"You went behind my back to give my partner money to keep my own bookstore open, and you stood in a museum and signed your name next to his and you told him to lie to me. That's not one thing. That's a system."
Ben throttled down, so the engine dropped an octave. They were in open water now, the coast a gray smear off the port rail, and he let the boat coast and then he let go of the wheel and turned around and faced Nathan squarely for the first time since they'd left the dock.
"You want the whole truth," he said. "Fine. He came to me because he was scared. He was scared you'd lose the shop and it would be the last thing he gave you, and he'd have to watch it. He sat on my boat exactly where you're standing and he asked me for money and I said yes. He asked me not to tell you and I said yes. He asked me to be the one who got you through the stops when he was gone and I said yes. That's not a system. That's a man dying and asking for favors."
"And the loan."
"There is no loan. There was a check. I never cashed it. It's in my drawer at the ferry office, with his handwriting on it, and it's going to stay there."
"Then why did he spend his last three months thinking he owed you?"
Ben's face did something then that Nathan had not seen in nine years, not since the night on the dock, the night Ben had stopped the ferry with Nathan's father already in the ambulance and Nathan's coat still in Ben's hand. It was not guilt. It was worse. It was patience running out.
"Because he asked me to be honest with him and I wasn't," Ben said. "Because I told him the money didn't matter and he didn't believe me, and he didn't believe me because *you* didn't." He took a breath. "Because he knew, Nathan. He knew how much I still — " He stopped.
The boat rocked. Nathan stood very still with the letter folded in his hand.
"Finish it," Nathan said.
"No."
"Finish it."
Ben looked at him for a long moment, and then he turned back to the wheel and pushed the throttle up, and the engine rose, and the coast started moving toward them, and Nathan knew that whatever Ben had almost said, it was already in the boat with them, riding low and heavy between the benches.
They came into the channel at Kennebunkport at a quarter to five. The tide was running out. On the shore, past the pilings, past the moored dinghies, there was a squat gray building with a shingled roof and a hand-painted sign that said CROW'S NEST.
Nathan picked up the empty urn from the bench. He did not look at Ben.
"Stay with the boat," he said.
Ben stayed with the boat.