Letters from the Coast

Chapter 11: Kennebunk Conversations

The cove below the Crow's Nest was smaller than Nathan had imagined. A crescent of gray sand wedged between two granite ledges, the kind of place a person only found if they'd been shown. Daniel had been shown. By Margaret, presumably, or by whoever Margaret was to him.

Ben had stopped the car at the end of a gravel lane and pointed downhill through the pines. "I'll wait," he'd said, and Nathan hadn't argued.

The path dropped steeply, roots webbing the dirt. Nathan carried the second letter in his jacket and the urn in the crook of his arm, and at the bottom the tide was half out, everything smelling of cold salt and wet stone. Wind came off the water in long pushes. He stood at the waterline a while, listening to it, and then he opened the urn.

He didn't say anything. Daniel had hated eulogies; he'd said once that if Nathan ever stood over him making a speech, he'd haunt the bookstore and knock over the poetry section every time a customer walked in. So Nathan just poured, and the ash went out in a pale cloud, caught the wind, and spread across the gray water in a way that felt less like loss than like the water accepting something it had been waiting for. Some of it clung to Nathan's fingers. He rinsed his hands in the shallows. The cold bit straight through to the bone.

He stayed until the ash was gone, and then he stayed longer, because going back meant going back up the hill to Ben.

When he climbed into the passenger seat, his hands were still red with cold. Ben had the engine running and the heater on, which Nathan resented for no reason he could name.

"Done?"

"Done."

Ben pulled the car around, gravel popping under the tires, and headed back toward the town. Neither of them said anything for a mile. Then Ben said, "He used to talk about that cove. Said it was the only place he ever felt—" He stopped. "I don't know. He never finished it."

Nathan looked out the window. "You spent a lot of time with him."

"Some."

"Enough that he leaves me letters telling me to forgive you." Nathan turned. "That's a strange thing to put in a letter, Ben. What exactly am I forgiving?"

Ben's hands tightened on the wheel. "He was sick. He was trying to tie things off."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the answer I've got."

"No," Nathan said. "It isn't." He reached into his jacket and took out the folded page, the one with Daniel's words on it. He'd copied them onto the back of the letter so he wouldn't have to carry the slip out of its sleeve. He read it aloud. "Don't pay Ben back." He let it sit. "He wrote me that. He wrote me that, Ben, when he was too weak to hold a pen steady, and you're telling me it's about tying things off. Eight thousand dollars. He borrowed eight thousand dollars from you and asked me to forgive you. Those two things don't fit."

"He came to me." Ben's voice was flat. "In April. He sat in my office and told me he was going to lose the store. Not might. Was going to. He'd run the numbers and there was nothing left, and he said he couldn't tell you because you'd sell the house, you'd sell everything, you'd ruin yourself to save it and then hate yourself for it. So he asked me for the money and he asked me not to tell you where it came from."

"And you said yes."

"I said yes."

"So the whole time," Nathan said, "the last four months of his life, I sat across from that man at breakfast, and he was carrying a debt to you I didn't know about."

"He didn't want you to carry it."

"He didn't want me to know." Nathan's voice came out harder than he meant. "There's a difference, and you know there is, because you were in it with him. You were in it with him, and I wasn't."

Ben drove. The harbor came up on the right, the masts in rows, a gull standing on one leg on a piling.

"The check was never cashed," Nathan said. "Why not?"

"Because I didn't want his money."

"Then what did you want?"

Ben didn't answer right away. He pulled into a parking space by the town dock and shut the engine off, and for a moment there was only the tick of the cooling engine and the wind against the glass.

"I wanted him to be all right," Ben said finally. "That's all."

"That's not all."

"It's what I've got."

"You keep saying that." Nathan turned in his seat. "You keep saying that like it's a door you can close. I sat in a diner with you yesterday and you started a sentence and didn't finish it. He knew how much I still—what, Ben? He knew how much you still what?"

Ben looked at the water. His jaw worked.

"It doesn't matter now," he said.

"It mattered enough that Daniel put it in a letter to me."

Something moved behind Ben's face—something Nathan recognized, because he'd felt it himself, the way grief and shame braid together until you can't pull one strand without the other. But Ben only shook his head.

"He didn't have the right to do that," Ben said. "Putting that in a letter. He didn't have the right."

"He had every right. He was dying."

Ben laughed, short and ugly. "That doesn't make him honest. It just makes him hard to argue with."

Nathan felt the truth of that land somewhere under his ribs. It was the first thing Ben had said all day that he believed completely.

"You know what I think," Nathan said. "I think Daniel spent this whole thing arranging you and me in the same room, and I don't think he did it because he wanted you forgiven. I think he did it because he thought we'd both be too stubborn to do it ourselves. Which means there's something here he wanted me to know, and you're the one who knows it, and you're standing there telling me you've got nothing."

"I'm not standing," Ben said. "I'm sitting."

"Don't do that."

"Do what?"

"Be funny. He did that too. He'd be funny in the middle of the worst thing so I'd stop asking." Nathan shook his head. "I'm not going to stop asking."

Ben was quiet a long time. Out on the water, a fishing boat worked its way out past the breakwater, and a bell somewhere marked the swell.

"You want the whole thing," Ben said. "The whole reason he came to me first. You want me to say it out loud."

"I want you to stop deciding what I can handle."

"He made me promise."

"He's dead, Ben. He's dead and I'm the one standing in a parking lot in Kennebunkport trying to figure out whether the man I lived with for eleven years was actually a stranger. Your promise is not the thing I need to respect right now."

Ben turned and looked at him then, really looked, and Nathan saw how tired he was—tired in a way that had nothing to do with the ferry schedule.

"All right," Ben said. "Not here. Not in a parking lot."

"Then where?"

"On the water." Ben started the engine again. "Six o'clock. I told you. There's a berth in Kennebunkport and I run north in the morning. Come with me. There's —" He stopped, reconsidered. "There's things on that boat. Things he gave me to hold. I don't know what's in them. He told me not to open them until you asked."

Nathan sat with that.

"You've had them this whole time."

"Yes."

"And you weren't going to tell me."

"I was hoping he'd told you himself. In the letters."

Nathan looked out at the harbor, at the masts rocking, at the gray Atlantic beyond the breakwater going on and on the way it always did, indifferent, patient, the same water that had taken the last of Daniel an hour ago.

"Six o'clock," he said.

Ben nodded and put the car in gear. They drove back through town without speaking, and Nathan watched the storefronts slide past and thought about the fact that Ben had been carrying something for four months, something Daniel had put in his hands, some last piece of the man he thought he'd known—and that whatever it was, it had been sitting on a ferry this whole time, waiting for Nathan to ask the right question.

He wasn't sure yet what the right question was.

But at six o'clock, he'd find out.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 11: Kennebunk Conversations · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads