The ferry smelled of diesel and salt and old rope, and Nathan stood at the stern rail watching Kennebunkport shrink into a line of white church spires and gray roofs.
Ben had untied them at six exactly, no ceremony, no speech. He’d just nodded at the bow and said, “Sit anywhere that isn’t the engine cover,” and Nathan had done it. The sun was low, the water hammered copper. The Crow’s Nest was already gone behind them, and so was the cove, and so, in a way he couldn’t name, was the man he’d been standing there as.
He heard Ben’s boots on the deck behind him and didn’t turn.
“You want the office,” Ben said. “It’s warmer. Coffee’s not good but it’s hot.”
“I’m fine.”
“You’re turning blue.”
Nathan turned. Ben stood with his hands in his jacket pockets, hair pushed back by wind, face doing that careful thing it did when he was waiting for Nathan to decide whether he was allowed to be kind.
“Fine,” Nathan said, and followed him.
The pilothouse office was a box bolted behind the wheelhouse—two chairs, a chart table, a dented steel coffeepot, and a shelf of paperbacks with broken spines. A small woodstove ticked in the corner. Nathan sat. Ben poured two cups and pushed one across the table, then sat down across from him and reached under the chart table for something.
A logbook. Canvas-bound, the corners worn round as river stones.
“You said you had things of his,” Nathan said.
“I do.” Ben set the logbook down between them. “This isn’t his. This is mine.”
Nathan looked at it. “You brought me in here to show me your diary?”
“It’s a ferry log. Weather, tide, passengers, cargo, every crossing since I bought her.” Ben’s jaw worked once. “Daniel read it. All of it, cover to cover, one night in April while we were waiting out a squall off Seguin. I’d never shown anyone. He asked. I let him.”
Nathan didn’t reach for it. “Why are you telling me this.”
“Because he wrote in it,” Ben said. “Front to back, he signed every damn page like a hotel register.” He pushed it closer. “And because you asked me last night what he wanted, and I’ve been sitting on the answer like a coward.”
Nathan opened the logbook.
Daniel’s handwriting marched across the margins and between the ruled lines—small, precise, the same hand that had signed checks and grocery lists and the inside covers of books. *Tide 3.2 rising. Ben ran the lines himself though he has a deckhand. Wind NE 18. Ben overcooked the chowder. Ben laughs at his own jokes before he gets to the end of them. Ben is the only person on this coast who still says ‘aught’ instead of zero.*
Page after page. Nathan turned them slowly, and the tightness in his chest loosened and tightened again, a tide of its own.
Then, halfway through, in a passage dated the previous October, the handwriting changed to Ben’s.
*Ran the last crossing of the season. Cold enough the lines froze. Daniel called from the bookstore at nine, said come get a coffee, said I sounded like a man who needed one. I did. I took the Margaret Anne out, made the crossing, stood outside his window like a stray, and then I turned around and came back. Don’t know why. I know why. Because it was the anniversary of the night I stopped the ferry—the night I didn’t cross, didn’t show, didn’t answer the phone—and I couldn’t walk through that door and sit down across from him like the last eleven years never happened.*
Nathan read it twice. The woodstove ticked. The engine rumbled under their feet.
“The night you stopped the ferry,” Nathan said.
Ben didn’t answer.
“That’s a specific way to put it.” Nathan closed the logbook. “What night?”
Ben got up and checked the gauge on the wall, which didn’t need checking. “Old history.”
“You wrote it down in ink in a book you knew I’d read.”
“I didn’t know you’d read it. I only knew I couldn’t say it out loud.” Ben turned around. “There was a night. A long time ago. I was supposed to cross and I didn’t.”
“You were supposed to cross where.”
“Kennebunkport to Portland.” Ben said it flat, like a man laying down a card he’d rather keep. “You were at the pier. You waited.”
Nathan remembered. He remembered it the way you remember a bone that has healed crooked—an ache on certain days, no shape to it. Twenty-one. A cooler with sandwiches. Four hours on the cold end of a pier, and the last boat gone, and Ben never coming, and the phone in his apartment ringing twice at midnight with no one on the other end.
“You were going to tell me something,” Nathan said. “That’s what you said then. You had something to tell me.”
“I did.”
“And you stopped the ferry instead.”
“I did.” Ben leaned against the chart table. “And then I spent the next eleven years finding ways to be exactly far enough away that I never had to say it.”
Nathan set his coffee down. It had gone cold without him noticing.
“Daniel knew,” he said.
“Daniel guessed. He was better at guessing than either of us.” Ben’s voice was low. “He never asked me straight. He just—started taking the ferry. Every trip, bookshop business, always my boat. And about a year in, I figured out he wasn’t coming for the crossing.”
“What was he coming for.”
“Company.” Ben shrugged, and the shrug didn’t fit him. “Long water. Two men who’d both loved the same stubborn bookstore owner and couldn’t say it.”
Nathan stood up. The pilothouse glass showed his own reflection overlaid on black water, and he couldn’t look at it.
“You don’t get to say that,” he said. “Present tense. Not after eleven years. Not while I’m carrying his ashes in a duffel bag.”
“I know.”
“Then don’t.”
“I won’t.” Ben held his hands up, palms out. “I’m not asking for anything. I’m telling you what’s in the book because you asked what he wanted from me, and the answer is: he wanted me to hand you the truth in pieces small enough to swallow.” He tapped the logbook. “This is a piece.”
Nathan looked at the shelf of broken-spined paperbacks. *The Old Man and the Sea. A Moveable Feast.* A birdwatching guide. Daniel had left his fingerprints all over this boat before Nathan ever set foot on it.
“There’s more,” Nathan said. “You said items.”
Ben nodded slowly. He crossed to a locker under the port window, unlocked it, and lifted out a plastic tote with a cracked lid. Inside: a manila envelope, a blue ceramic mug Nathan recognized from their kitchen shelf, and a spiral notebook with a rubber band around it.
“That’s tomorrow’s work,” Ben said. “Tonight we make Boothbay.”
“Boothbay.”
“He left instructions. Mile by mile.” Ben held up a hand before Nathan could ask. “I only know the town names. I swear on the boat. He gave me an envelope the same day as the check, told me to open it when you got on board, and it says Boothbay Harbor. Blueberry field.” He paused. “He wrote a word under it. *Ellis.* No explanation.”
The name landed like a dropped plate. *Ellis. 1954. Ask him what he did.* The torn page from the Portland Head logbook. The stranger in Daniel’s secret trips.
“You’ve seen that name before,” Nathan said.
“In the logbook, a few times. Daniel would write it and then scratch it out.” Ben’s brow furrowed. “Whoever Ellis is, Daniel didn’t want me reading it. He wanted you to.”
The engine note changed. Ben glanced at the compass, corrected a point, and the ferry swung south.
“Get some sleep,” he said. “We’ll tie up around dawn. I’ve got bunks forward, and I’ll keep the wheel.”
Nathan took the logbook with him. In the narrow bunk, with the hull thudding against the swell, he opened it again and read the October passage a third time, and then a fourth, until the words stopped being about Ben and started being about Daniel—about a dying man who had spent his last year riding this boat, sitting in this office, reading a logbook written by the man who had broken Nathan’s heart, and never once saying a word about it.
*Don’t pay Ben back.*
He closed the book. Above him the ceiling creaked, and Ben’s footsteps paced the wheelhouse, patient as weather.
At the top corner of the last page, in Daniel’s hand, in pencil, so faint Nathan had missed it twice: *Nate—ask him about the letter he never mailed. It’s still in the locker. I put it there.*
Nathan lay still. Outside, the sea kept going, and the coast slid past in the dark, and there was a locker twelve feet away holding something a man had written to him eleven years ago and never sent.