Anne picked up on the fourth ring, which meant she'd been deciding whether to. Nathan knew the rhythm of it by now—Anne had spent two years deciding whether to pick up when Daniel was dying, too.
"Nathan." Her voice was flat, guarded, the way it had been at the funeral. "It's late."
"It's eight."
"Late for you."
He stood at the pay phone outside the Boothbay general store because his cell had gone to one bar and died there. Ben waited in the truck thirty feet away with the engine off, hands on the wheel, staring at the harbor like it was a painting he'd been told not to touch.
"I need to ask you something," Nathan said. "About Ellis."
Nothing came back. The silence stretched so long he checked the phone was still working.
"Where did you hear that name," Anne said, and it wasn't a question.
"Daniel wrote it. Under a blueberry field. And there's a page torn out of a logbook at Portland Head with his handwriting on the piece that got left behind." He kept his voice level. "I found it, Anne. I'm not asking to hurt anybody. I'm asking because he left me a map and he left that name on it and I want to know who I'm following."
"Jesus, Danny." She said it to someone who wasn't there.
"Who was Ellis?"
Anne breathed out, long and slow. "Our brother."
Nathan leaned his forehead against the cold metal of the phone box. "You don't have a brother. You told me that at Thanksgiving, the year Daniel and I—"
"I know what I told you." A pause. "I told you what we told everybody. What we were told to tell."
"Then tell me the rest."
"He was older. Five years older than me, seven older than Danny." Her voice had gone somewhere small. "He died when he was twenty. Drowned off the point at Kennebunkport, if you want to be exact, which nobody ever does. It was 1954."
The year sat there and did nothing. Nathan waited for it to mean something and then it did, and it didn't make sense. "1954. That's—that's almost seventy years ago."
"That's what I said."
"You're telling me Daniel was following a brother who died in 1954."
"I'm telling you what you asked." Her voice hardened again. "There was an Ellis, and Ellis died, and after that there wasn't an Ellis. That's how it worked in our parents' house. You didn't lose a child. You stopped having one. His name came out of the mouth once and never again, and if you brought it up you got sent to your room, and eventually you learned to bring up other things."
Nathan tried to put Daniel in that house, at nine, at ten, learning what not to say. "Daniel never mentioned him. Not once. Eleven years, Anne. Not once."
"That's because he learned the lesson better than either of us."
"He put 'Ask him what he did' on the page."
"He was a child when Ellis died." Anne's voice finally cracked. "A boy who lost his brother and was told to act like he hadn't. Whatever he did—he was a boy. He carried it longer than I have and he never once let me carry any of it. So no. I don't know what he meant. I'm sorry. That's the truth and it's all the truth I've got."
"How did he die?"
"The point off the rocks. They said he went in for a swim and the water took him. I don't know more than that because nobody who knew more than that ever spoke in my house again." A beat. "I've thought about him every day since Danny died. I don't know why it's like that. But it is." The line clicked and she was gone.
Nathan stood in the phone booth with his hand on the receiver, watching his reflection in the glass darken as the light changed. He didn't cry. It wasn't that kind of cold. It was the cold of standing in a room you thought you knew and finding a door that had been papered over, painted the same color as the wall, and knowing it had been hidden while you lived there.
He walked back to the truck. He climbed in. Ben didn't start the engine.
"Well," Nathan said.
"Well what."
"Ellis was Daniel's brother. Died in 1954. He fell off a point at Kennebunkport." He said it like reading a weather report. "The family buried the name. Nobody ever said it again. That's what I know now that I didn't know twenty minutes ago."
Ben looked at him, then looked away, and Nathan watched the small telling motion—the jaw tightening, the eyes going to the far side of the harbor, the hands not moving on the wheel. Ben had known that name before tonight. Ben had known it in a way Nathan had never been allowed to.
"Say it," Nathan said.
"Nathan—"
"You knew about Ellis."
Ben's hands came off the wheel and opened on his knees, empty, showing. For a moment he looked exactly as he must have looked eleven years ago on a ferry deck, turning back. "He told me once. After the loan. He said there was a brother, and the brother was gone, and it was the one thing about himself he couldn't have said out loud. He asked me to keep it." He let out a breath. "And I kept it. It wasn't mine to give."
"To give to me."
"I told you," Ben said quietly. "That night, the night I stopped the ferry. That was part of what I came to say."
"You came to say my partner of eleven years had a dead brother I'd never heard of."
"I came to say there were things about Daniel you didn't know. And I knew them. And I was carrying them." He met Nathan's eyes, and there was no defense in it. "Because he asked me to. Because he was scared of what it would do to you, knowing he hadn't ever quite let you all the way in. He thought if he gave you the Ellis part, you'd start adding it up."
"Adding what up."
"That he was a man who kept things." Ben said it gently, which made it worse. "That's all. He wanted to be known. He couldn't stand to be known. It was the one contradiction he never fixed."
Nathan sat with that. The harbor threw lights back at itself. A gull worked the air above the masts, unhurried and indifferent. Somewhere out in the dark the blueberry field held a scattering of the man Nathan had spent eleven years thinking he understood, and the ground underneath that understanding was gone.
"I lived with him," Nathan said finally. "Every day. He knew me. I thought I knew him."
"You knew most of him."
"Most isn't the man I married."
"No." Ben's voice went low. "But nobody gets the whole man, Nathan. Including Daniel. Including me. Including you. The whole man isn't a thing anybody holds."
"Don't." Nathan turned on him. "Don't manage this for me."
"I'm not."
"You're smoothing it over. 'Nobody gets the whole man.' That's the thing you say when you don't want to say 'I knew things you didn't and I let you stand next to me for eleven years and not find out.'"
Ben was quiet a long moment. Then: "You're right. I knew things you didn't and I let you stand next to me. And I kept his secret because he asked me. If you want me to say that it was the wrong call—" He stopped. "I don't know if it was. It wasn't easy and it wasn't simple and I'm not going to pretend it was."
Nathan looked out the windshield. The ferry was tied at the far end of the pier, dark and patient, and under the pilings in its steel belly sat a locker with Daniel's things in it and a letter to Nathan with Ben Cooper's handwriting on it eleven years old. Tomorrow they'd open it. Tonight Ellis sat between them in the cab, an old dead boy off the rocks at Kennebunkport, holding the last door Nathan hadn't opened.
"Drive," Nathan said.
Ben drove. Neither of them spoke again until the lights of the inn came up and Ben pulled in and cut the engine. Nathan had his hand on the door when he said it.
"There's a torn page in that logbook at Portland Head." He didn't look at Ben. "Ellis's name and the year. Somebody ripped it out of the curator's book."
"I know," Ben said quietly. "I saw the stub."
"Somebody wanted that page gone."
"Seems like."
"You didn't ask who took it."
Ben didn't answer. Nathan opened the door and got out and stood in the cold with the harbor noise behind him, and when he looked back Ben was still in the truck, hands back on the wheel, staring straight ahead at nothing, and Nathan understood that the torn page was not a mystery to the man in the truck.