Letters from the Coast

Chapter 15: The Third Letter

The call to Anne had left him wrung out, and the drive north to Damariscotta was the first stretch of the trip he and Ben had done without the ferry. Ben had offered to drive. Nathan had let him, not because he wanted company but because his hands were still unsteady from the phone call, and he didn't trust himself on a two-lane coastal road with his mind three time zones away.

The letter had come out of the envelope in the glove box sometime after Wiscasset, when Nathan couldn't stand the silence any longer and pulled it open just to have something to do with his hands.

Daniel's handwriting. The fourth thing he'd touched that day that still smelled faintly of Daniel's cologne, a stupid detail that kept ambushing him.

*Nate —*

*Drive to Damariscotta. There's a café on Main Street where the poet used to read. Ask at the counter. And here —*

Inside the folded page was a key. Small, brass, no tag. And below it, four lines of poetry in Daniel's hand, not Daniel's words, or maybe Daniel's words pretending to be someone else's.

*A ferryman counts the crossings he did not make,*

*and calls them mercy.*

*The water keeps no ledger,*

*only the weight of what we carried.*

Nathan read it twice. Then a third time. Then he folded it along the crease and put it back in the envelope and looked out the window at the maples going orange and said nothing.

"You okay?" Ben asked.

"Fine."

Nathan watched the trees for another mile. Then, because the silence was worse than the alternative: "Where did he go in April? You said the farm stand saw him. Did he tell you he was sick?"

"No."

"Did he tell you anything?"

"Some things."

"That's not an answer."

Ben's hands tightened on the wheel, then relaxed. "It's the answer I've got, Nathan."

The sign for Damariscotta came up and Ben took the exit, and the town opened up around them, small and white and stubbornly beautiful, the way every town on this coast was stubbornly beautiful, and Nathan hated all of it just a little.

He found the café because Ben pulled up in front of it and killed the engine. A hand-painted sign over the door, a bell on a string, the smell of coffee and old paper. Nathan went in alone. Ben stayed in the car. He'd learned, somewhere along the way, when to stay in the car.

The girl at the counter was maybe twenty and had no idea who Daniel Cole was, but when Nathan showed her the key and said "the poet," she went through a door and came back with a woman in her sixties with gray hair in a braid and a cardigan that looked like it had opinions.

"You're Daniel's," the woman said. Not a question.

"I was."

"He talked about you." She said it simply, the way people said things they'd been holding. "He read here. Last October. Tuesdays, sometimes."

"He didn't —" Nathan stopped. Started again. "I didn't know."

"He said you wouldn't."

She led him to a small room in the back, an open mic space with folding chairs and a small raised stage, and a cabinet against the wall. She unlocked the cabinet with a key of her own — Nathan's key, it turned out, opened an inner box inside it — and there it was. A spiral notebook, the same kind Daniel had always kept, and a mug, and a second envelope with Nathan's name on it.

"The notebook's the one he read from," the woman said. "He left it. He said if someone came with the key, give them the whole box. Nobody else."

"Did he come back?"

"Not since October." She looked at him for a moment. "I'm sorry."

Outside, Nathan stood on the sidewalk with the box under his arm and didn't get back in the car. Ben had the window down.

"What did you get?"

"A notebook."

"Anything else?"

An envelope. Nathan didn't say so. He didn't know yet whether the envelope was something he wanted Ben to see.

They drove to a small inn at the north end of town, and Ben took the room next to his, and Nathan spent an hour with the notebook on the bed in front of him not opening it. Then he opened it.

The first poem was about the ferry. Nathan read it twice before the words sorted themselves into sense. A ferryman, a crossing, a man on the far shore who stayed. A man who didn't cross, and a ferryman who counted it anyway. Nathan read the poem again, slowly, and this time he heard Ben's voice in it, the way Ben said *dinghy* instead of *boat*, the way he counted stars off the deck like he was doing inventory.

The third letter was in the envelope. It said: *read the poem out loud, Nate. Not for me. For you.*

He didn't read it out loud. He read it again in silence, and then he put the notebook down and went out onto the porch where Ben was already standing with two cups of terrible coffee, and he took the cup without thanking him.

"You knew," Nathan said.

"Knew what?"

"Daniel's poem. About a ferryman."

Ben took a slow sip of coffee. "He showed me a draft."

"When?"

"Spring."

"And you said nothing."

"He asked me not to."

Nathan laughed, once, without humor. "He asked you not to do everything. He asked you to hold his money, hold his secrets, hold his envelopes, hold his —" He stopped.

"His what?"

"His husband," Nathan said. "He asked you to hold his husband after he died. He set this up. You driving me around Maine, you reading me his letters, you standing next to me at every one of these places. He arranged the whole thing, didn't he. From the grave."

Ben set the coffee down on the rail. "I offered to drive you. That part was me."

"Everything else was him."

"Some of it."

Nathan looked away, out past the porch to the road going south, the maples, the water somewhere beyond that he couldn't see yet. "I don't know which one of you I'm supposed to be talking to anymore."

Ben didn't answer that.

"He knew," Nathan said, quieter. "Didn't he. He knew how you felt. About me."

Ben's jaw tightened. He didn't look at him.

"How long?"

"Long time," Ben said.

"Before me and Daniel."

"Before."

Nathan set his cup down too. He couldn't drink it. His hands weren't steady enough to hold it without spilling.

"So this whole trip," he said. "All of it. You're — what. Filling in. Waiting for me to finish grieving so you can —"

"No."

"Don't lie to me, Ben. Not now."

"I'm not lying." Ben turned to face him. "I'm here because Daniel asked me. Because I owe him. Because I loved him too, in my way, and because —" He stopped himself, the same stop Nathan had heard on the ferry, the same unclimbed wall.

"Because what."

"Nothing."

Nathan stepped back from the rail. One step, then another. Putting the width of the porch between them.

"I can't do this," he said. "Whatever this is. Whatever you came here for. I'm not — I'm not going to let you be a replacement for him. And I'm not going to be a replacement for whatever you and he were. Do you understand what I'm saying? I'm not a part of his plan. I'm a person. I'm Daniel's —" He couldn't finish it either. "I was his. And now I'm just standing here in the middle of a fucking plan, and the two of you have been writing it together behind my back for years."

"That's not fair," Ben said.

"No," Nathan said. "It isn't."

He went inside and closed the door.

He lay on the bed with the notebook open on his chest and didn't sleep. Around two in the morning he heard Ben's door open, then close. Around three he heard it again. He didn't get up.

At breakfast, Ben was already at a table by the window with two coffees and a plate of eggs, and he looked like he hadn't slept either. Nathan sat down across from him because there was nowhere else to sit, and because his body was forty-five years old and needed food, and because said body had driven all the way up here and wasn't going to walk back.

"Read the rest of the notebook," Ben said, without looking up.

"I did."

"There's a page near the back. He marked it."

Nathan had seen it. A turned-down corner, which Daniel never did to books, only to his own notebooks. He'd left it alone on purpose.

"I'm not reading it in front of you."

"Don't." Ben finally looked at him. "Read it in the car. There's somewhere we need to go before we head back to the ferry."

Nathan set his fork down. "Where."

"Damariscotta's got a reading tonight," Ben said. "Small thing, at the library. Daniel's name's on the list from last fall. I called. They kept his slot." He paused. "You'll want to be there."

Nathan looked at him for a long moment across the table, and then, without agreeing, he took the notebook out of his jacket and opened it to the marked page, and read the first line, and felt the floor of something he'd been standing on give way all over again.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 15: The Third Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads