The storage facility sat behind a gas station on the edge of Damariscotta, a long aluminum building lit by one flickering sodium lamp. The office was closed. Ben had called ahead, and the night manager had left an envelope taped to the door with a key and a gate code.
Nathan punched the code in. The chain-link slid open on its track with a shriek that carried across the empty lot.
Unit 114 was at the far end. Nathan's hands were steady when he fit the key into the padlock—steadier than they'd been in weeks, which should have told him something. The lock popped. He rolled up the door.
It was a five-by-ten, half-full, and the smell hit him first: stale cigarette smoke, the sour ghost of it soaked into cardboard.
He stood in the doorway and did not move.
Cardboard boxes stacked against the back wall, a few of them labeled in Daniel's slanted capitals—BOOKS, WINTER, MISC. A folding chair. A cooler. And on a shelf at eye level, a wooden cigar box, open, with a carton of Marlboro Reds sitting on top of it and two loose packs beside it, and an ashtray that had not been emptied before someone put it away.
Nathan heard Ben come up behind him, and heard him stop.
"How long," Nathan said.
Ben didn't pretend not to understand. That was something, anyway.
"Since before we met," Ben said. "I found out maybe three years in."
"Three years."
"He'd quit for a while. Then he started again after his father died. He asked me not to tell you."
Nathan picked up the ashtray. It was heavy ceramic, one of the ones from the shop—Daniel had thrown pots for a year, back when they were renovating the storefront, and there were still four of them in the apartment holding loose change. Nathan turned it over in his hands. Grit shifted inside it.
"You knew," he said.
"I knew."
"I sat in that hospital room and listened to a pulmonologist explain what was happening to him, and I asked him, twice, if he had ever smoked, and he looked me in the eye and said no." Nathan set the ashtray down very carefully, because his hands wanted to throw it. "And you were in the hallway. You were right there in the hallway."
"I was."
"You let me ask that question and you let him lie to me."
Ben's face had gone gray under the sodium light. "Yeah."
"Say something that helps."
Ben put his hands in his pockets and looked at the carton of cigarettes for a while. When he spoke, his voice was low and even, the way Nathan remembered it from the ferry deck at night, and Nathan hated him for how much he still liked the sound of it.
"He asked me at the beginning whether I'd keep it from you," Ben said. "I said I wouldn't. So he just stopped telling me. Six months, maybe, he didn't say a word about it. And then one night he called me at one in the morning and he was—" Ben stopped, restarted. "He was scared. He said he couldn't tell you because of how you'd look at him. And he asked me to sit with him while he had one and not say anything. So I drove over. And I sat on his porch, and I didn't say anything, and after that it was—that was the arrangement. I was the one he called."
Nathan stared at the unit. The boxes. The folding chair. Daniel had sat in that chair in this room, in a rented closet off a gas station, and smoked, and called Ben, and not called him.
"So the arrangement was that you got to be the person he trusted," Nathan said.
"That's not—"
"That's the arrangement, Ben."
"No." Ben's jaw worked. "The arrangement was that he got a place he didn't have to be dying in. And I got to be there for it. You want to know the truth? I let him do it because I wanted him to need me. I knew it was wrong. I told him I knew. And I drove over anyway, every time."
The night manager's envelope was still in Nathan's fist. He looked at it like it belonged to somebody else.
The cigar box. He'd been so focused on the cigarettes he hadn't looked inside. Nathan lifted the lid.
Journals. Four of them, the black-and-white composition books Daniel bought by the dozen from the drugstore. Two more loose ones underneath, a spiral, a leather-bound thing with a broken clasp. Nathan picked up the top one and opened it at random.
*Went in to Brunswick for the loan papers today. N didn't ask where I was.*
He closed it. He didn't need to read the year to know which year. That was the spring Daniel had gone quiet, the spring he'd started working Saturdays at the shop alone, the spring Nathan had chalked up to grief over Daniel's father and had given him room, given him space, been proud of himself for it.
The space had been where the smoking lived. Where the loan lived. Where Ben lived.
He looked at the leather journal. The broken clasp. On the flyleaf, in Daniel's handwriting, a date eleven years back.
Nathan set it down in the box and closed the lid.
"There's more," Ben said. He had his hands out of his pockets now, palms open, like he was showing Nathan he wasn't holding anything. "There's a box marked WINTER in the back. It's the rest of it. He told me to make sure you got all of it. He said—"
"Stop."
"—he said you should have all of it so you could—"
"Ben. Stop talking."
Ben stopped.
Nathan turned in a slow circle, taking in the five-by-ten room with its concrete floor and its steel walls and its smell of the thing that had been killing Daniel for years while Nathan sat at the dining table waiting for him to come home. He was so angry his teeth ached. He could feel the anger going in two directions at once, like a river hitting a rock, one arm of it for Daniel, one arm for the man standing three feet behind him, and he did not know which arm to follow and he did not trust himself to choose.
He chose the one he was looking at.
"You should go," he said.
"Nathan."
"Take the ferry back. Get your boat. I'll call a cab, I'll come back for the car in the morning."
"It's eleven at night and there's nothing open to—"
"I don't care. Go."
Ben didn't move. That was the worst of it, Nathan thought later—that Ben stood there in the doorway of the unit with the white light coming down on his face, and he didn't argue and he didn't leave, he just looked at Nathan with an expression that had no defense left in it at all.
"I'm not leaving you in a storage unit at eleven o'clock at night," Ben said.
"You don't get to decide what I'm in."
"No. But I get to stay until you tell me twice."
Nathan opened his mouth.
And then he closed it, because he remembered the locker. The ferry locker, down at the docks, the key hanging on the ring in Ben's coat pocket since two days before Daniel died, contents unknown even to the man carrying it. Waiting for tomorrow morning. Waiting for Nathan to decide he was ready.
He looked at the cigar box. At the four journals and the leather one with the broken clasp. Daniel had built himself a small sealed room behind a gas station, and had filled it with the parts of himself he thought Nathan couldn't hold, and had handed Ben the key.
"How many of these have you read," Nathan said.
"None."
"You're lying."
"I have not opened one journal," Ben said. "I swear to you on anything you want. He gave me the key and told me not to open it. I didn't open it. I sat in this room with him for an hour some nights and never touched the box."
"Why."
"Because he said you'd know if I had." Ben let out a breath that was almost a laugh. "He was probably right."
Nathan stood in the middle of the unit. Behind him the sodium lamp buzzed. Somewhere off toward the water a foghorn sounded, low and stretched out, the sound of the coast at night, the sound that had put Nathan to sleep for twenty years.
He wanted to read the journals. He wanted to read them so badly his hands were shaking again. And he knew, the way you know a wave is going to break, that whatever was in them would change what he believed about the last eleven years of his life, and that he was going to have to read them anyway, and that he was not going to do it with Ben watching.
"Here's what happens," Nathan said. "You go out to the car and wait. I'm going to sit in this chair and read for a while. When I'm done I'll come out. If I'm not done by two, drive to the docks and sleep on your boat and I'll meet you at the locker at eight."
Ben looked at him. Then at the cigar box. Then at the chair.
"You're going to be cold," he said, and went to the door, and Nathan heard his steps cross the lot, and the car door open and shut, and then nothing but the foghorn and the fluorescent hum and the smell of it all.
Nathan sat down in Daniel's folding chair. He took out the leather journal, the one with the broken clasp, and opened it to the first page.
The first line was a date. The second line was a name. It wasn't Nathan's.