The storage unit door rolled down behind him with a sound like a lung emptying. Nathan stood in the dark for a moment before he found the pull cord and the single bulb buzzed awake, cold and yellow, showing him the same flat lawn-mower-and-tarp interior he'd walked out of twenty minutes ago. Ben's taillights were already gone from the lot. Good.
He dragged the plastic crate off the shelf and set it on the concrete floor. Journals. Nine of them. Composition books, mostly, the cheap kind with the marbled covers, plus three in leather that Nathan had bought him one Christmas.
He knew these. He'd seen them on Daniel's nightstand, on the café table by the register, in the pocket of Daniel's coat. He had never once opened one. Eleven years of a man writing every day, and Nathan had respected the spine of it like it was a locked room in a house they both lived in. Now he sat down on the cold floor with his back against the metal wall and opened the most recent one first, because he was a coward and wanted the freshest wound.
July. Two weeks before the end. The handwriting had gone spidery. *Woke at 4. N. sleeping with his mouth open. I keep doing the math on how long he'll be angry and I can't get it to come out any way I like.*
Nathan turned the page.
*Told B. about the loan today. He didn't take it well either. Nobody takes it well. The bookstore was going under and I had the money and I didn't ask because I knew what he'd say. He'd say no thank you, I'd rather drown than owe you, and then we'd both be standing there in the wreck of it. So I just did it. Called it a grant. Called it a gift from the universe. God forgive me, I sat across from him at that little table and watched him cry with relief and I felt like the worst man in Maine.*
Nathan's hands had gone very still. The bookshop. The twenty-thousand-dollar "grant" from a foundation nobody had ever been able to name, the one that had come through in the spring of the second bad year, the one Daniel had said a lawyer friend had arranged. Nathan had framed the letter of award. It was still on the wall behind the register, in a cheap black frame from the hardware store, and customers asked about it sometimes and he told them the story proudly.
He read it again. Then he turned the pages back, hunting, and found March.
*Took the ferry over to see B. at the landing. He looks older. He said, you should tell him, and I said, tell him what, that I bought him? That I paid for his life? He said you know what I mean. He's always known what I mean. That's the problem with B. He's the only person alive who sees the whole of me and doesn't look away.*
Nathan set the journal down flat on his knee and looked at the bulb for a while. The filament shimmered. His breath was loud in the little metal room.
He picked it back up. November, two years back.
*B. came to the house. We sat on the porch half the night. I told him things I never told N. About Ellis. About the water. B. didn't flinch. I made him swear on the boat he wouldn't say a word to N. and he looked at me like I'd asked him to cut off a hand and then he did it. I have used him. I know I have used him. There is a way I do it where I hold a thing up in front of him and I say, protect this for me, and he does it because he's built wrong and loves the wrong man.*
*N. is going to be so angry.*
Nathan realized he'd said it out loud. "You knew," he said to the concrete. "You knew and you did it anyway."
He didn't trust his legs to stand, so he crawled the two feet to the crate and started pulling everything out: the mug — chipped, blue, Daniel's from the diner on Route One they'd stopped at the first summer — a bag of hard candies gone to chalk, and under the third leather journal, a manila envelope with a single word in Daniel's handwriting. *Ben.*
Nathan sat back against the wall. His heart was doing something ugly. He knew, the way you know a wave is going to break, what he'd just found, and he also knew it would be wrong to open it, and he opened it.
One page, folded twice, undated, unsealed.
*Ben —*
*I'm not sending this because you'd only tell me I'm being maudlin and then you'd drive over with soup.*
*I put you in the middle. I want to say it plain, at least once, in a place where you can't wave it off. I asked you to hold things that weren't yours to hold and I called it friendship. I asked you to keep my secrets from the man I loved, and I did it knowing you were in love with him, and I did it anyway, and I want you to know I knew. That's the part I can't get around. I knew.*
*You told me once at the landing that it was killing you to keep it in. I told you to hold on a little longer and I told you he'd be worth it. I want you to hear how that sounds now. I sold you that. I sold you a version of your own life and told you it was loyalty.*
*If I have to pick one thing to be sorry for at the end, it's not the cigarettes and it's not the money. It's that I got eleven good years with him out of a friendship that cost you eleven years of the same.*
*Do what you want with all of this. That's the only honest thing I know how to write. Open the box or don't. Tell him or don't. I've done enough telling you what to do.*
*— D.*
Nathan read it twice. Then a third time, slower, and somewhere in the third pass the tears came, and they weren't grief. That was the thing that shocked him. He sat on the floor of a storage unit in Damariscotta and cried, and what he felt was a kind of cold clarity, a clean anger with edges on it.
Because Ben had been carrying that letter's truth for years without the letter. Because Daniel had stood at that landing and asked Ben to hold the load and never once asked Nathan whether he wanted to be held at arm's length for his own good. Because the whole architecture of the last two weeks — the ferry locker, the poems, the dead brother, the reading, the confession Daniel had scripted from beyond the grave — wasn't a love letter to Nathan. It was a man tying up loose ends on his own terms, one hand on each of them, arranging the aftermath the way he'd arranged the money.
"Nathan."
He hadn't heard the car. He hadn't heard the door. Ben was standing in the open bay of the unit, keys still in his hand, and he had clearly been running, and his face did something complicated when he saw what was open on Nathan's knees.
"You came back," Nathan said. His voice came out flat and strange.
"You told me to leave. I got to the end of the road." Ben stayed in the doorway, deliberately, like a man showing his empty hands. "You didn't come out. I thought —" He stopped. He looked at the envelope, and the flat, unsealed fold of it, and went a shade paler. "He wrote to me."
"He never sent it."
"No." Ben's jaw worked. "That's his handwriting for me, though. He wrote me things he never sent. It was a habit. He said it kept him honest."
Nathan held the page up. "Did you know he knew? That you were in love with me while he was sick. That he knew the whole time and asked you to keep holding it in anyway."
Ben was quiet for a second too long. Then he came in and crouched down across from Nathan, on the cold floor, slow, like a man approaching something that might bolt.
"I don't know," he said. "Honestly. I suspected, near the end. He said something on the porch one night and I didn't ask what he meant." He looked at the page without touching it. "He was good at that. Saying a thing sideways so you couldn't make it his fault."
"Yeah." Nathan looked down at the nine journals, the mug, the cigarettes, the letter. "He put us both in a box and locked it."
"Not the same box."
"No," Nathan said. "Mine's got a bookstore in it, and a fake grant, and eleven years of a man I—" He stopped. He pressed the heel of his hand against his eye. "I don't know which parts were real."
Ben sat down properly, cross-legged on the concrete, and the two of them stayed there in the buzz of the one bulb. Nathan could feel the shape of the room, the cold working up through the floor into his legs, and beyond the roll-up door the gray ordinary night of the town, and past that the water, and somewhere out on the water a ferry with the last run still ahead of it.
"So do we open it?" Ben said finally.
They both looked at the cigarette box on top of the journals. Nathan felt a small, absurd laugh move through his chest and not come out.
"Not tonight," he said, and then, because Ben's face didn't move, he added, more sharply than he meant to: "The ferry's at eleven. You know that. You've known it the whole time."
Ben looked up at him. He didn't argue. That was the worst of it — he never argued. He just sat there on the floor of Daniel's storage unit with his keys in his fist and waited to be told what to do, the way Daniel had trained him to, and Nathan looked at him and understood with a cold clear certainty that whatever else Daniel had built in that box, he had built this too: two men on the concrete, one of them waiting, one of them deciding, exactly the way Daniel had arranged it.
Nathan stood up. He gathered the journals into the crate, set the letter on top, and pushed the crate back onto the shelf.
"Stand up," he said. "We're taking the ferry."