The morning ferry to Rockport ran late, which meant they didn't reach the harbor until nearly nine. Nathan stood at the rail with the sealed envelope in his coat pocket, the double tape still intact, the little print of the orange raincoat still nested under the flap. Ben stood a few feet away, hands in his pockets, watching the water. He hadn't tried to close the distance. He hadn't tried to say anything that sounded like a question.
That was the deal now. Nathan had spent the ride trying to decide whether he was grateful for it.
The gallery sat on a side street two blocks up from the wharf, its windows full of driftwood sculpture and salt-bleached buoys. A hand-painted sign above the door read ELLSWORTH & CO. — FINE ART, EST. 1978. Nathan stopped on the sidewalk.
"You're sure this is the place," Ben said. Not really a question.
"The letter says the place where he sold the small one. That's all I've got."
"Then that's all we've got."
Nathan pushed the door. A bell rang somewhere in the back. The gallery smelled of linseed oil and cold stone, and the walls were hung with landscapes — most of them Maine coast, most of them competent, a few of them genuinely good. Nathan walked the length of the first room without stopping. Ben followed half a pace behind, which was exactly where he'd stood for the last three weeks, and Nathan had stopped pretending he didn't notice.
A woman came out from the back office — sixties, silver hair cropped short, reading glasses pushed up into it. She looked at Nathan, then at Ben, and something moved across her face that Nathan didn't like.
"Can I help you?"
"I'm Nathan Cole. I'm looking for a painting Daniel Reyes sold here. Some years back."
The woman went still. She set down the mug she'd been carrying and folded her arms. "Daniel."
"Yes."
"He's dead."
It wasn't a question, but Nathan answered it anyway. "Last spring."
She nodded slowly, like she'd already known and just needed it said out loud. "I'm Margaret Ellsworth. I own the place." She looked at Ben again, longer this time. "And you're the ferry captain."
Ben shifted his weight. "I am."
"He talked about you."
Nathan felt it land — the small, cold shock of it, the way Daniel kept surfacing in rooms Nathan had never been in. He pulled the envelope from his pocket and laid it on the counter. "He left letters. This one sent me here. It says there's a painting."
Margaret looked at the envelope, then at Nathan. "He left it with me four years ago. Said he'd come back for it." She paused. "He didn't come back."
"He was sick."
"I know." She said it gently. "He told me. That's why he left it."
She walked to the back and was gone long enough that Nathan had time to look at the walls again, really look this time, and find what he'd missed — three small canvases in the far corner, hung low, unlabeled. The light from the window caught the topmost one. A man in an orange raincoat, seated on a bench. Nathan's throat closed.
Margaret came back with something wrapped in brown paper and twine. She set it on the counter between them and didn't unwrap it.
"There's a condition," she said. "He made me promise."
"Of course he did."
"You have to read the letter first. Before you open it."
Nathan looked at Ben. Ben looked back. Neither of them said anything.
Nathan tore the envelope.
The fifth letter was written in Daniel's small, cramped hand, the letters angled like he'd written it on his knee on a moving boat. Nathan read it twice before he understood what it was asking.
*Nate —*
*By now you've been to Camden, and you've read what I did, and you're probably furious at me, which is fine, you're allowed. I'm not going to apologize in this one. I'm going to ask you for something.*
*The painting in the brown paper is yours. It always was. I made it the winter I got the diagnosis, which means it's the best thing I ever painted and I'll never say that out loud again. But here's the riddle, and I need you to solve it before you look.*
*I painted the man I loved at the age I first loved him. Not the age he was. Not the age he is. The age he was when I knew.*
*You'll know whether you got it right when you open it. If you got it wrong, put it back in the paper and walk away, and I'll never know, and that's the mercy.*
*— D.*
Nathan lowered the letter. His hands weren't steady.
"That's it?" Ben said. "That's the whole thing?"
"That's the whole thing."
"What's it mean?"
Nathan looked at the wrapped canvas. "It means he's playing a game with me from the grave, and he's winning." He picked up the package. "I'm supposed to guess the age. Before I open it."
"The age you were when he first loved you."
"When he knew." Nathan turned the package over in his hands. "The problem is I don't know when that was."
Margaret had stepped back to give them room, but she was watching. "He told me the answer once," she said quietly. "He said, 'The year he stopped being a stranger to me.'"
Nathan went very still.
Eleven years. They'd been together eleven years, and before that — before that there had been a summer, a summer when Nathan was twenty-nine and Daniel was thirty-one, when Daniel had walked into the bookstore for the first time and asked for something out of print and Nathan had told him to come back Tuesday. That was the year. Nathan knew it the way he knew his own name. The year Daniel stopped being a stranger.
"Twenty-nine," Nathan said.
Margaret nodded once. "Open it."
Nathan untied the twine. The paper fell open on the counter.
The canvas was small, maybe twelve by sixteen, and Daniel had painted it in the loose, fast strokes he'd used in those days, before he'd taught himself to be careful. It showed a man in a thick green sweater, seated on a bench at the stern of the ferry, hands in his lap, looking out at the water. Behind him, the rail, the wake, the last grey light off the bay. The man was younger than Nathan was now. His hair was longer. He was looking away from the painter, and he was smiling, just barely, the way Nathan used to smile when he didn't know he was being watched.
The man was Ben.
Nathan didn't move. He stood at the counter with his hands flat on either side of the canvas and looked at it for a long time. He heard Ben take a breath. He heard him not say anything.
"You were twenty-nine," Nathan said finally.
Ben's voice came out rough. "I was twenty-eight."
"You were on the boat."
"I was always on the boat."
Nathan looked up at him. Ben's face was doing something complicated — grief and something else, something Nathan had spent a year refusing to see. The man in the painting was young. The man standing across from him was forty-five, weathered, tired, and still — still — the same shape under the sweater and the wind-burned hands.
"He painted you," Nathan said. "Four years ago. He painted the man he loved at the age he first loved him." He turned the canvas back toward himself. "That's not a riddle. That's a confession."
"He knew," Ben said. "He knew the whole time."
"He knew the whole time," Nathan agreed, and his voice came out quieter than he meant it to.
Margaret cleared her throat. She'd moved to the far end of the counter, giving them what little distance the room allowed. "He said something else. He said if you got it right, I was to tell you the rest."
Nathan looked up.
"He said the painting has a companion. One he didn't finish." She pulled an envelope from under the register, unmarked, unsealed. "He said you'd know what to do with it."
Nathan took the envelope. He didn't open it. He looked at the painting, then at the envelope, then at Ben, who was watching him with an expression Nathan couldn't name and wasn't sure he was allowed to.
"I need to sit down," Nathan said.
He didn't sit down. He put the painting back in its paper, carefully, the way you'd wrap something that could break, and he put the envelope in his pocket next to the fifth letter, and he walked out into the cold Rockport morning and stood on the sidewalk with his back to the gallery window, breathing.
Ben came out a minute later and stood next to him. Didn't touch him. Didn't say anything.
"Ben," Nathan said.
"Yeah."
"I don't know what I'm supposed to do with this."
"I know."
"That's all you've got?"
"That's all I've got." Ben put his hands in his pockets. "And I'm not going to tell you what he wanted, because that's his game, not mine. But I'm not going anywhere, either."
Nathan looked at the envelope in his pocket. Then he looked at Ben — the young man he'd been, the man he was now, both of them in the same frame, both of them painted by the same hand.
"Let's go find out what he left me second," Nathan said.