Letters from the Coast

Chapter 21: The Truth About That Night

The wind off Camden Harbor had a bite that Nathan remembered from every October of his life. He sat on the hood of his truck in the nearly empty lot below Mount Battie, hands deep in his jacket pockets, watching Ben's ferry-orange raincoat come toward him through the sodium light.

Ben stopped a few feet away. His hair was wet. He'd clearly come straight off the water and straight here.

"You drove fast," Nathan said.

"I didn't," Ben said. "The page was in the bottom of the tool drawer. I found it this afternoon when I was looking for a wrench."

He held it out. A single sheet of notebook paper, folded twice, soft as cloth at the creases. Nathan took it and turned it toward the light.

*Ben — if this ever gets read, I want the record clear. The night you stopped the boat, you called me first. You asked if you should do it. I told you to. I asked you. You said, Daniel, this is going to hurt him worse than anything. I said, then let it hurt, he'll still be there in the morning. That's on me. All of it. — D.*

Nathan read it twice. Then a third time, moving his lips around the words without saying them.

"Kennebunkport," he said finally. "The night before. You were already gone."

"I was already gone," Ben said. "I got as far as the Bath exit. Sat in the turnaround for forty minutes. Then I went home and called him."

"You called *him*."

"He was the only person I could call who'd know what I was talking about." Ben's voice was flat, careful, the way a man talks when he's practiced the sentences for a long time and still doesn't trust them. "I told him I was going to come back and tell you. He said don't. He said—" Ben stopped, breathed out through his nose. "He said you'd just had the biopsy results and you weren't sleeping. He said if I put that on you now, you'd carry it like it was another thing wrong with your body."

Nathan slid off the hood of the truck. His knees felt loose, like the ground had tilted and he was the only one who'd noticed.

"So you didn't stop the ferry because you got scared of me."

"I stopped the ferry because he asked me to." Ben looked out at the black water. "I was scared of you, but that wasn't why."

Nathan looked down at the page again. *Then let it hurt, he'll still be there in the morning.* That was Daniel's voice exactly. The particular smugness of a man who believed he could schedule other people's pain around his own convenience and call it kindness.

"For how long," Nathan said.

"How long what."

"How long did you know he was sick before I did."

The pause was long enough to be an answer on its own.

"Four months."

Nathan didn't say anything. He walked a few steps toward the water, and his boots scraped loud on the frost-cracked asphalt, and he stood there with his back to Ben because his face was doing something he didn't want witnessed.

"Four months," he said.

"He made me promise."

"Everybody made everybody promise." Nathan turned around. "That's the whole architecture of it. He made you promise, then he made me promise to finish a trip he'd already half-run behind my back, then he wrote it down like a will so neither of us could argue with a dead man. And I did argue with you instead."

Ben didn't move.

"I blamed you," Nathan said. "Eleven months. I sat in the store and I thought: he got scared, he chickened out, he came back to town and stopped at the end of the street and turned around, and then he didn't even have the decency to stay the hell away. And the whole time—" He slapped the folded page against his leg, once, hard. "He'd told you no."

"You didn't know."

"That's not the point."

"It's a little bit the point."

"It's not." Nathan's voice cracked and he let it. "I *watched* you. All that time. You'd come in and buy a book you didn't want and I'd think, look at him, he thinks he can just walk back in here. I made you pay full price. I wouldn't let you use the staff discount because you weren't staff anymore."

"I remember."

"I was punishing you for following his instructions."

"You were punishing me for something," Ben said. "It wasn't the wrong thing to punish."

Nathan stopped. Looked at him properly for the first time since the storage unit.

"No," he said slowly. "Some of it wasn't."

He took his hat off, ran a hand through his hair, put the hat back on. The gesture of a man buying himself two seconds. Then he crossed the asphalt and stood in front of Ben, close, and made himself say it without looking away.

"I'm sorry. For the storage unit, and for the eleven months, and for all of it. You didn't deserve it."

Ben's jaw worked. He nodded once, short, like a man agreeing to a fact rather than accepting a gift.

"Okay," he said.

"Okay."

"I'm not going to tell you it's fine. It's not fine. But I hear you."

They stood there. Somewhere down in the harbor a line knocked against a mast, a hollow woody clinking that carried in the cold.

Then Ben said, "I can't do this part."

"Do what part."

"Stand here in this parking lot being your friend." He said the word like it cost him something. "I've done that. For years. I did it while he was alive and I let him build a whole machine out of it, and I'm not doing the second act of it now that he's gone. I came back up here in March because he asked me to, and I stayed because you asked me to, and somewhere in the middle of it I stopped being able to tell the difference."

Nathan's mouth went dry. "Ben—"

"You want someone to hand you the letters. I can do that. I'll do that tomorrow and the day after and however many there are left. You want a guy to sit in the truck with a map on his knees and read the postscripts out loud, fine. But don't ask me to eat dinner with you and then go home to my own bed and call it friendship."

The wind pushed between them. Nathan could feel the fine spray of it, salt and cold, on the skin around his eyes.

"I don't know what I want," he said. And it was true, and it was the first entirely honest thing he'd said to another human being in almost a year.

"I know you don't," Ben said. "I'm not asking you to."

"You're asking me for something."

"I'm telling you what I've got left." Ben pushed his hands into his pockets. "That's different."

Nathan looked down at the folded page in his hand, at Daniel's handwriting, at the crooked line of the dash before the initial. *That's on me. All of it.* Twelve words, and Nathan had spent eleven months assigning them to the wrong man.

"Fourth letter," he said.

"What about it."

"It's in the truck. He wants me to forgive you." Nathan looked up. "I don't think I understood the assignment."

Ben's mouth did something that wasn't quite a smile. "No."

"Tomorrow," Nathan said. "The notebook had a page flagged with a fifth one. The third letter says Rockport. There's a marked page I haven't matched to anything yet."

"Rockport's twenty minutes."

"I know it's twenty minutes."

"I'm just saying." Ben took a step back toward his own truck. "I'll come by the store at eight."

"Eight," Nathan said.

Ben got into the truck and pulled the door shut, and the dome light went on and off, and he sat there a moment with his hands on the wheel before the engine turned over and he backed out, slow, careful, the way you drive when you know someone's still watching.

Nathan stayed in the lot until the taillights were gone past the turn.

Then he took out his phone and went back to the fourth letter, and read it again standing right there in the cold — the part where Daniel said *forgive him*, the part where Daniel said *he has been waiting longer than you know* — and he thought about the difference between being handed a person and reaching for one.

He folded the letter and got in the truck.

Halfway down the hill his phone buzzed in the cupholder. Ben.

*Check the back of the fourth letter. There's something under the tape, I didn't want to touch it.*

Nathan pulled over at the bottom of the hill under the streetlight and lifted the envelope out of his jacket. He ran his thumb along the taped flap. It was doubled, he saw now, one seal laid over another, and under the second layer something had been slid in flat — a thin strip of card, or paper, something stiff.

He worked the tape up with a fingernail.

Not a note. A photograph, three inches square, the old kind with the white border and the date in orange in the corner — a print of a painting, maybe, or a photo of one. A canvas on an easel in a bright room, unsigned, unlabeled, and on the canvas a man on a ferry bench, seen from behind, wearing an orange raincoat.

Nathan held it under the light. He knew the shoulders. He'd know them anywhere, the way you know a person from a hundred yards in a crowd and across eleven years and through a dying man's arrangements.

It was Ben.

And on the white border, in Daniel's handwriting, two words: *Rockport. Ask.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 21: The Truth About That Night · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads