Letters from the Coast

Chapter 31: The Ninth Letter

The ninth letter was heavier than the others. Nathan had noticed that the first time he'd weighed it in his hand, before he'd started rationing them, before the eighth had sent him sideways and he'd spent two days with the box shut in the drawer and his phone face-down on the counter.

He opened it on a Tuesday afternoon with the store closed, the CLOSED sign turned and the blinds half-drawn against a wet gray light off the harbor. Rain ticked on the windows. He had stopped trying to make a ritual of it. That was the thing about grief — it stopped being an occasion.

*Nate,*

*I'm going to tell you something I should have told you years ago, and the reason I didn't is the same reason I'm telling you now that it can't hurt me. That's a coward's arithmetic, but it's the only kind I had left.*

*I smoked. You knew that. What you didn't know is that I never quit.*

Nathan stopped. Read it again. The rain kept on.

He flipped the page, but his eyes had gone back to the top, and he was already somewhere else.

The cigarettes had been in the glovebox of the truck, in a hard pack, half-crushed, four left. That was three winters ago, maybe four. He remembered the cold, the way the air had gone metallic with it. They were coming back from the dump with a load of the store's ruined paperbacks — the burst pipe, the mold, a whole shelf's worth — and Daniel had stopped at the light by the Hannaford and Nathan had opened the glovebox looking for the registration.

He remembered how Daniel's hands had tightened on the wheel, the smallest thing, nothing anyone else would have caught.

"What are these," Nathan had said.

"Those are old."

"You told me you quit."

"I did quit." Daniel had kept his eyes on the road. "Those are from before. I forgot they were in there."

"You forgot." Nathan had turned the pack in his fingers. The cellophane was gone, and the lid was torn at one corner, and there was a receipt folded into the pack, and the date on the receipt was six days old. "Daniel. Six days."

The light changed. Daniel drove.

"I have one now and then," he'd said finally. "When it's bad."

"When what's bad."

Daniel had shrugged. That shrug. It was the thing Nathan had loved about him first and hated about him last — the way he could make his own suffering into a small administrative matter, something to be managed quietly so that no one else had to be troubled by it.

"It's a stupid habit. I'll quit. For real this time."

"You lied to me."

"I didn't want to have a whole thing about it."

"A whole thing." Nathan had laughed, and it had come out wrong, hard-edged, the way laughter does when it's standing in for something else. "You've been sneaking out to the porch at midnight for months and I thought you were just, I don't know, looking at the stars, and you were — what, hiding in the dark so I wouldn't smell it on you?"

"That's right." Daniel's voice had gone flat and mild, the voice he used when he was being caught and had decided not to fight. "That's exactly right."

"God." Nathan had put the pack back and shut the glovebox too hard. "I don't know who you are sometimes."

He remembered that sentence. He remembered that it had gone through the cab of the truck like a nail, and he remembered that Daniel had not answered it, and that they had driven the rest of the way home with the radio on and neither of them touching the dial.

He remembered, later that night, Daniel on the back steps in his coat over his pajamas, and Nathan watching him through the kitchen window, and the small orange flare of the lighter, and the deliberate way Daniel had turned his face out toward the water so the smoke would go somewhere else.

He had not gone out. He had washed the dishes instead, and he had gone to bed early, and he had lain there in the dark listening for the door.

*You're wondering why I'd tell you this now, out of everything. It's because of Ellis.*

Nathan set the letter down on the counter and looked at the wall for a while.

Ellis had been Daniel's brother. Younger by two years. He had died at nineteen, in a car on Route 1 outside Belfast, the year before Nathan ever met Daniel, and for the first decade of their life together Daniel had spoken about him maybe six times, always briefly, always as if the subject were something breakable he was handing across a table.

*I wasn't driving. Everyone thinks I was driving. I wasn't. I'd been at a party and I'd had two beers and I gave him my keys because I didn't want to drive and he didn't want to stay, and that was the whole great decision of my life, Nate. Two beers. I gave my little brother my keys so I wouldn't have to drive.*

*He hit the bridge abutment at eleven forty. He was sober. That's the part that stays with me. He was sober and twenty minutes from home and I sent him out there.*

*The smoking started that spring. I was twenty-one. I'd never touched a cigarette in my life and then I was smoking in the parking lot at work and every cigarette was the same thought and I couldn't say the thought out loud to anybody. Not to my parents, who couldn't look at me straight for a year. Not to a therapist, because I tried that, once, and I sat in the chair for fifty minutes and didn't say a single true thing.*

*You have to be able to say the sentence to get better. That's what the therapist said. And the sentence was: I killed my brother. And I couldn't say it because if I said it out loud somebody would agree with me.*

*Then I met you, and I thought, okay. Now I have a reason to be somebody else. Now I'll be somebody who doesn't need that.*

*And I didn't, for a while. But the sentence was still there, and it turns out you can't quit a sentence. You can only keep it in your mouth and hope people don't smell it on you.*

*I was so afraid, those last months, that if I told you about Ellis — really told you, not the four-sentence version — you'd do the arithmetic and find me guilty too. And you would have been right. So I kept the whole thing in a drawer and I smoked on the porch and I let you think I was a person who'd quit.*

Nathan sat with his hands on the counter. Rain, the store, the small refrigerator humming in the back. Somewhere out on the water a bell buoy knocked.

He thought about the glovebox. He thought about *I don't know who you are sometimes*, which he had said and never taken back, not that night or the next morning or ever, and which Daniel had carried around for three more years alongside the other sentence.

He tried to remember what he'd wanted on that drive home. He'd wanted Daniel to say: you're right, I lied, I'm sorry, here is the whole of me on the table. And Daniel hadn't, because — Nathan understood it now, the way you understand a thing at the bottom of a well — because the whole of him on the table was a nineteen-year-old boy on Route 1, and Daniel had been afraid that if Nathan saw him, Nathan would leave.

So he'd hidden it. And Nathan had found a pack of cigarettes and read it as a small dishonesty and been angry about it for a week.

He got up. He walked to the back room. He stood over the drawer for a while and then opened it and looked down at the last envelope, cream paper, *Nate* on the front in Daniel's forward-slanting hand.

He didn't take it out. He looked at the coat hook lying beside it, the one he'd unscrewed from the wall six weeks ago, and picked it up, and turned it over in his fingers.

"I would have stayed," he said out loud, to the room, to no one. "You idiot. I would have stayed."

His voice sounded strange in the empty store. He put the hook back down.

The letter was still on the counter. He picked it up and read the last paragraph again, and this time he read it properly.

*I don't want you to forgive me. I want you to know. That's the difference between us — you think the truth is something you survive and I thought it was something you bury, and it took me ten years and a terminal diagnosis to find out that burying it was what was killing me all along.*

*So here's the ninth thing, and then there's one more.*

*Andrea was the one who told me to write these. She said you'd be angry with me and that anger is just grief with somewhere to go. She said write him everything, even the parts that make you look bad, especially those.*

*I told her that was a lot of letters.*

*She said there aren't that many true things.*

Nathan folded the letter along its crease and put it in his back pocket, and went and stood at the window, and looked out at the rain on the harbor and the ferry dock empty of the boat.

Then he went back to the counter and unlocked his phone and opened the thread with Ben and read his own unsent draft from six nights ago — *I'm sorry and I'm not ready and I don't know which one is more true* — and he held his thumb over it a long moment, and didn't delete it.

He was still holding the phone when the twelfth line of the letter came back to him, the one he'd skimmed past: *and then there's one more.*

He had assumed he knew what the last one said. He'd spent two months assuming it. He had walked to a bench in Castine and found Daniel's name on a plaque and understood that Daniel wanted him to move on, and he had taken that as the whole shape of the thing, the closing argument of a dead man.

But Daniel had written *there aren't that many true things* — and Nathan had counted nine, and there was one left, and he had never once wondered whether he actually knew what it said, or whether he'd just decided he did because it was easier than opening it.

He put the phone face-up on the counter. He reached for his keys. In the bottom drawer of the back-room desk, the last envelope waited, cream and sealed and patient, and he had not touched it in a week, and now his hand was already moving toward it — until his fingers closed instead on the glovebox key, and the fact of Margaret's envelope came back to him all at once, sitting there in the truck, unopened since the day she'd pressed it into his palm and told him to read it when he was ready.

He didn't feel ready.

He put the truck key in his coat pocket, and the ninth letter in the other, and stood in the middle of his dark store listening to the rain, and understood, with a flat and terrible clarity, that Daniel's letters weren't the only ones he'd been refusing to open.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 31: The Ninth Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads