The tenth envelope had been sitting in the desk drawer for two weeks. Nathan had known it was there—the ninth letter had told him so, in Daniel's careful hand, *there's one more and I'm sorry for the way I've strung them out*—and he had walked past that drawer every morning, opened it twice for pens, closed it again. He took the ferry to Bucksport on a Tuesday in October, when the tour buses had thinned and the river smelled like cold iron.
He didn't read the letter on the boat. He had read it at four in the morning, at the kitchen table with the overhead light still off, the paper lit by his phone's flashlight because he couldn't bear to turn on the room. Daniel had written: *There's a fort at the mouth of the Penobscot, and I want the last of me scattered from the rampart, on the water side. I know it's a big ask. I went there once when I was a boy and I never got it out of my head—the way the river opens up and you can't tell where it stops being river and starts being ocean. I want to be where things blur.*
Nathan had packed the box in the passenger seat—ash box, tissues, the coffee thermos. Daniel's mother, Margaret, had given him the ashes in April; they had sat on the passenger seat of the truck since, through every town on the letter's map. The box was heavy in a way that didn't match what it held. Nathan drove north on Route 1, past the hardware stores and the seasonal motels boarding up for winter, and parked below the fort's earthen walls.
He carried the box up the path. Two women with a dog passed him going down, and he stepped off the trail to let them by, and neither of them looked at his hands.
The fort sat low against the sky, grass on the ramparts like a green roof, the Penobscot spreading gray and wide below. Nathan walked the perimeter until he found the water side—the northwest corner, where the river bent and the wind came up over the wall and slapped at his coat. He stood there a long time and didn't open the box.
It was one thing to have promised. He had promised at the beginning, when the first letter had been funny and sharp and so exactly Daniel's voice that it had felt less like an instruction than a phone call. Now the box was heavier and the voice was quieter and he couldn't shake the sense that he was about to finish something he had never agreed to finish alone.
*You're not alone,* Daniel had written. *You just think you are. That's always been your problem.*
Nathan opened the box.
The ash caught the wind immediately and went out over the water in a long gray ribbon, and Nathan turned away so it wouldn't come back into his face, and for a moment the sky and the river and the ash were all the same color and he couldn't tell where he ended and the water began. He said something. He wasn't sure afterward what it was—Daniel's name, probably, and a word he had not said out loud since the hospital, a word he had believed with his whole body until the moment the letter had arrived and asked him to keep going.
He closed the box. It was lighter now and almost hollow. He stood with his hands on the stone and watched the water keep moving, the way it had been moving before any of them were born and would keep moving after, indifferent and patient.
"Scattering?"
The voice came from behind him. Nathan turned. A man about his age, gray in his beard, standing near the rampart with his hands in his jacket pockets. Nathan hadn't heard him come up the path.
"Yes," Nathan said. "Sorry. I didn't—"
"Don't apologize." The man nodded at the box. "It's a good spot for it. A lot of people bring folks up here. The river takes them out fast. It doesn't hang around."
Nathan put the lid back on the box and set it down on the wall, carefully, the way you'd set down something borrowed.
"I'm not from here," he said, for no reason.
The man smiled slightly. "Tourist season's over. Not many folks up here in October unless they have a reason. That's why I noticed you."
Nathan waited for him to go. He didn't. He stood looking out at the water, and there was something about the way he stood there that made Nathan's skin prickle—not a threat, exactly, but a familiarity. The man knew this view. He knew where to stand.
"You're Cole," the man said finally.
Nathan's mouth went dry. "Who are you?"
"Doug Trask. I worked the boatyard in Belfast for years. Knew Daniel." He said Daniel's name easily, the way you'd say the name of a customer. "I thought I recognized you from the funeral. You were the one who kept standing by the door."
The funeral. Nathan had stood by the door for most of it because he had been unable to sit. That was seven months ago. He did not remember this man. There had been too many people, and none of them had been Daniel, which was the only problem that had mattered.
"I'm sorry," Nathan said. "I don't—"
"Didn't expect to see me again. I know." Trask looked at the box. "He asked me to come out here with him. Three, four years ago. Said he wanted to see where the river opened. So I drove him over and we stood right about here and he talked for an hour about how he was going to build a house on this coast someday, right on the water, and I said the water would eat it, and he said that was the point." Trask shook his head. "He was always—"
He stopped. Nathan had gone very still.
Nathan said, "You drove him. Just you?"
Trask looked at him a moment too long. "No. Ben was there. It was the two of us, actually." He said it lightly, as if it meant nothing. "Ben did the driving. God knows he drove Daniel everywhere that spring."
*Ben.*
Nathan put his hand down flat on the cold stone of the rampart, because his balance had gone strange. The wind came up off the water and pushed his hair back off his forehead and he stood there with his hand flat on the stone, listening to the river.
"I didn't know," he said.
"No, well." Trask shrugged. "You weren't around that spring. Ben was."
"I was—" Nathan started. I was in Portland. I was at the store. I was *there*, at the hospital, every day, at the end. But it was true that there had been a spring before the end, a long spring when Daniel had still been able to walk and drive and pretend, and in that spring Nathan had been working ten-hour days trying to keep the bookstore alive, and Daniel had said *don't worry about me, I'm fine, go run your store,* and Nathan had believed him, because believing him was easier than the alternative.
That spring, Ben had driven Daniel to Bucksport. Ben had stood right here where Nathan was standing, watching the river open. Daniel had told Ben things, apparently, that he had not told Nathan. Or he had told them both, and Nathan had not been listening.
"Why didn't anyone tell me?" Nathan said. It came out smaller than he meant it to.
Trask looked at him with something like pity, and that was worse than anything else. "Maybe he meant to," he said. "Or maybe he didn't want you to know he'd needed someone. He was particular about that. You knew him."
Nathan knew him. That was the problem. Nathan knew him, and Daniel had hid the cigarettes and the fear and the brother he'd killed by accident, and had told the truth to Ben in a car on the way to a fort. And Ben had never said a word about it. Not at the bench, not in the letter's whole long map—not once.
"He lied to me," Nathan said, out loud, and then flinched, because it wasn't fair—it wasn't a lie, it was just a thing that had happened without him. It was only that Daniel had spent his whole last spring protecting Nathan from knowing that Daniel needed anyone but Nathan, and Ben had spent it knowing, and now Ben was out there somewhere, probably sitting in his apartment with the phone on the table, waiting for a text that Nathan had written and never sent.
Trask shifted his weight. "I should get back down. My wife's waiting."
Nathan nodded. He couldn't find anything to say.
Trask turned, then stopped, one hand on the path rail. "For what it's worth," he said, "Ben's a decent man. He didn't want to come that day. He told Daniel it wasn't right, not telling you. Daniel made him promise." He looked back at the river. "Everybody makes promises they end up breaking out here. That's the whole coast, in my opinion."
He went down the path and was gone. Nathan stood alone on the rampart with the empty box and the river moving below him, and he thought about the eleventh envelope still sitting in the drawer at the store—*there's one more, and I'm sorry for the way I've strung them out*—and for the first time since the letters had begun he felt like he understood what Daniel was actually doing.
Daniel hadn't been saying goodbye. He'd been introducing Nathan, one letter at a time, to the person Daniel had actually been—the one with the cigarettes and the brother and the spring when he'd needed someone else. And Ben had been part of that person, in ways Daniel had never let Nathan see.
Nathan picked up the box. He took out his phone. The draft was still there, *I'm sorry I walked away, can we talk,* and he stood on the rampart with his thumb over the send button and the wind coming up hard off the water, and he could not tell whether he was sending it because he missed Ben or because he was furious with him—because Ben had known Daniel's last spring, and had let Nathan believe he'd been there alone.
He put the phone back in his pocket and carried the box down to the truck, and drove south toward the store, and all the way down Route 1 he kept thinking about the eleventh letter, and what else the two of them had decided not to tell him.