Letters from the Coast

Chapter 34: The Twelfth Letter

The glovebox latch stuck in the cold. Nathan had to work it twice before the envelope came free, and even then he didn't open it. He just set it on the passenger seat of the truck and drove with one hand, the heater rattling, the Atlantic grey and flat to his left the whole way up the coast.

Bar Harbor in early November was a ghost town that hadn't admitted it yet. Half the storefronts were shuttered, plywood over the windows with hand-painted signs promising to see you in May. The wind came off the water hard enough to make the gulls walk instead of fly. Nathan parked near the town pier and sat a minute with the engine off, listening to it tick.

The twelfth letter was in his coat pocket. Daniel's handwriting had gotten worse toward the end — the letters leaned, the letters broke — but this one was steady. He'd written it early, maybe. Or maybe he'd just decided to be careful with this one.

*Nate. Go to Bar Harbor. Not to the pier — the shore path, the part past the gardens where the rocks come down close to the water. You'll know the spot. I sat there a whole afternoon once when we were first together and I decided I was going to ask you to stay. You never knew that was the day. I told you later I'd decided in the car on the way home. I lied. It was the rocks.*

Nathan read it twice, then folded it and put it back in his pocket. He walked. The shore path was empty except for one woman with a dog that ignored him. The rocks came down steep and pinkish where the wind had worn the granite clean, and the water slammed and sucked at the base of them, white foam climbing and falling back.

He knew the spot. God help him, he knew it. A flat shelf of rock, angled toward the water, with a deep crack running through it like a fault line. He'd sat here with Daniel a hundred times, back when Daniel could still walk this far. That was their first autumn. Daniel had brought a thermos of coffee that turned out to be mostly whiskey and they'd laughed about it for years.

He sat down. His knees complained. The wind moved through his hair.

He took the box out of his bag — the last of the ashes, the portion he hadn't scattered at the fort. He'd been carrying them around in the truck for days, maybe weeks; he'd lost track. He held the box in his lap and looked out at the water, at the ferry cutting its way toward Frenchman Bay, small and white and unhurried.

The letter said more. He hadn't read to the end. He pulled it out again.

*Here's the thing I couldn't say to your face. I want you to forgive yourself. Not for me leaving — that's not on you. For the rest of it. For the truck that night north of Bangor. For every time you looked at me and thought you'd failed me because I was getting smaller and you couldn't stop it. For the way you stopped touching my hair because you were afraid you'd hurt me. I noticed. I didn't know how to tell you it was fine.*

Nathan's eyes burned. He kept reading.

*You were not made to fix me, Nate. You were made to sit with me. And you did. Every single day. Even when you were angry. Even when you didn't know what to say. That was enough. That was more than enough. I need you to know that, because I know how you're going to spend the next year telling yourself you should have done more. You didn't. You did the thing.*

*Go to the water. Let me go. Then go live.*

The letter ended there. No flourish. Daniel had never been one for flourish.

Nathan sat with it a long time. The wind got colder. His fingers went numb inside his gloves. He thought about Daniel on this rock deciding to ask him to stay, and how Nathan had said yes as if it were nothing, as if it had been easy, as if anyone could have said no to Daniel Grant that autumn.

He stood up. His legs had gone stiff.

He walked down to the edge of the shelf where it sloped toward the water, where the spray reached him, cold against his face. He opened the box.

The ashes caught the wind and went out over the water in a pale streak that broke apart and dissolved. Some of it caught on the rocks. Some of it stayed on his gloves. He brushed his gloves together over the edge and watched that go too.

"Okay," he said. Out loud, to the water, to Daniel, to no one. "Okay. I hear you."

The water kept slamming the rocks. The gulls kept walking. The ferry kept going toward Frenchman Bay, and further out, beyond the bay, out past the islands, there was the pale line of the open Atlantic, and Nathan stood there a long time looking at it.

He didn't feel what he expected to feel. He'd braced himself for something huge — a wave, a collapse, a sob that would come up from his sternum. Instead there was a kind of quiet. A flatness. The ashes were gone; the last of Daniel Grant was out on the water now, and Nathan Cole was standing on a rock in Bar Harbor with wet gloves and no idea what came next.

It wasn't peace, exactly. It was what peace might feel like if someone described it to you over the phone.

He turned around. The walk back took longer than the walk out, or felt like it. The woman with the dog was gone. The wind had changed direction. Somewhere near the gardens a gate creaked on its hinge, over and over, and nobody closed it.

He stopped on the path and looked back at the ferry. It was smaller now, heading out past the breakwater, its wake a long white scar that widened and faded and widened again.

Ben had taken a ferry like that once. They'd gone to Nova Scotia in their twenties, back when they were still — whatever they were. Nathan remembered standing on the deck with him, the wind doing what it was doing now, Ben's hand at the small of his back, both of them too young and too stubborn to say the obvious thing. He remembered how Ben had laughed at something, throwing his head back, and Nathan had thought, in that unguarded way you think things at twenty-six, *this is the person.*

He hadn't thought about that in years. He thought about it now.

He got back to the truck and sat in the cold cab without turning the key. The envelope from the glovebox was still on the passenger seat, Margaret's handwriting on the front — *For Nathan. When you're ready.* He picked it up. He turned it over. He put it back down.

His phone was in his pocket. He took it out.

The draft was still there. *Ben — I've been an asshole. I read the letters. There's a lot I didn't know. I don't know what I'm asking for. I just wanted to say I'm sorry.*

He stared at it. He thought about Daniel confessing about Ben in the eleventh letter, and about the fury he'd felt, and about how much of that fury had actually been at himself for not noticing, for being the last one to know the shape of his own life.

He deleted the draft.

Then he typed a new one, short. *Ben. I scattered the last of him today. Bar Harbor. I'm not ready for anything. But you were his friend and I didn't know, and I'd like to know. If you want. — Nathan.*

He didn't send it. Not yet. But he didn't delete it either. He locked the phone, put it in his pocket, and drove home south along the coast with the heater finally warm and the water on his right the whole way down, thinking about ferries, and about how a person could stand at the stern of one and watch the country they came from get smaller and smaller until it was just a grey line, and how you had to decide, at some point, whether you were going to keep looking back or turn around and see where you were going.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: The Twelfth Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads