Letters from the Coast

Chapter 33: The Eleventh Letter

The drawer stuck. Nathan had to yank it, and the wood came free with a dry crack that made him wince — another thing in this store he was breaking without meaning to. Inside, under the tax folders Daniel had never once used, the envelope sat where it had sat for three weeks. He'd known it was there. He'd known since the ninth letter teased it out of hiding, the way Daniel always teased things out of hiding, patient and sideways, never once asking directly for what he wanted.

He took it to the counter. The store was closed. It was two in the afternoon and the sign on the door still read OPEN because he hadn't gotten around to flipping it, and he couldn't remember whether he had locked it either. He didn't check. He sat with his back to the window and slid his thumb under the flap — careful of the cut, which had healed badly, a raised pink line that ached when it rained.

Eleven.

*Nate.*

*I have to tell you something and I've started this letter four times because every version makes me sound like a worse person than I was, and I've decided I'd rather you have the true version than the flattering one. You spent twenty years with a man who edited himself, and I'm not going to do it in the last thing I write you.*

*Ben came to see me in February.*

Nathan stopped. Read it again. February. Two months before the end, one month before Daniel finally told him the diagnosis, back when Nathan was still working the register and complaining about the HVAC and cooking dinners for a man who had already stopped eating much of them.

*He didn't know I was sick. Nobody did. He came because of the thing that happened between the three of us, because he'd been carrying it around for six years and he wanted to say it out loud to somebody who'd been in the room. He sat in the chair by the window — your chair, I kept thinking, he's sitting in Nate's chair, and I felt so strange about it.*

*And then he said it. That he loved you. That he'd loved you before he ever broke it, and that breaking it was the worst thing he ever did, and that he was going to spend the rest of his life not saying it to your face.*

*Nate, I want you to understand what happened next, because I've thought about it every day since.*

*I told him to tell you.*

Nathan's hand went flat on the counter. He read the line three times and it did not change.

*I told him: when I'm gone, tell him. I made him promise. I sat in a hospital-adjacent chair with my feet up and I made a dying-man request of a man I barely knew and I watched him agree because he couldn't refuse a dying man. That's what I did. That's what's in this letter.*

*I know how it looks. I know exactly how it looks, because I've been the man on the other side of it — the one who's told, gently, kindly, that he should move on, as if moving on were a door somebody else could open for you. I hated being that man. I hated every person who ever told me that grief has a shape and the shape is moving forward.*

*And then I turned around and did it to you.*

He set the page down. The store was very quiet. Out on the street a car went by and its tires hissed over the wet asphalt and Nathan heard it the way you hear things through water.

*Here is my excuse, and it's a real one, and it's not enough. I couldn't stand the idea of you alone in this store. Not the store — you in it. I've watched you all these years, how you lean on one person and don't know you're doing it, how you'll work fourteen-hour days and call it fine. I knew what April was going to do to you. And I knew Ben was the one person alive who'd already been inside the wall, and I knew you'd never let him back through it on your own.*

*So I built him a door.*

*I'm not sorry I wanted you to have someone. I'm sorry I didn't ask you whether you wanted one.*

*That's the whole confession. I don't know what you'll do with it. I only know that if I'd told you while I was alive you'd have looked at me with that face you get — the one that says I've decided how you feel and I'm going to be patient about it — and I couldn't have stood that. So I'm doing it this way. Cowardly. From behind the curtain.*

*I asked him to wait a year. He said he would try not to.*

*I think maybe that was the cruelest thing I ever asked a man to promise.*

*I love you. I was not good at loving you. I was good at keeping you.*

*D.*

Nathan sat with it. Then he stood up, walked to the front of the store, and flipped the sign. He locked the door. He walked back to the counter and read the letter again, start to finish, because he owed it that much.

*He said he would try not to.*

So Ben had been told to wait. Told by a dead man, through a letter he wasn't permitted to mention, to hold still for a year — and then Nathan had shown up in Castine with a box of ashes and a bad haircut and asked him to come along on a journey that wasn't his. And Ben had come. Of course Ben had come. He'd been waiting since February, standing in a corridor Daniel had built for him, being patient in a way Nathan had read as simple tenderness.

Nathan felt it come up through him like weather. Not grief this time. Something sharper and less respectable.

He was angry. He was angry at a dead man, which is the least useful form of anger there is, and he was angry anyway.

Because Daniel had sat in that chair — *your chair, I kept thinking* — and had decided, alone, in secret, what Nathan's life after him would look like. Hadn't asked. Hadn't written it in a letter Nathan could have read while there was still time to argue about it. Had just reached backward out of the grave and arranged him. Arranged them both. Like furniture.

"You didn't get to do that," Nathan said out loud, to the empty store. His voice sounded wrong in the room. "You didn't get to *do* that."

Daniel had spent their whole life together telling Nathan he was the stubborn one. That Nathan decided things and informed people afterward, that he was terrible at asking and wonderful at announcing. It had been a fair accusation. Nathan had always taken it as a fair accusation.

And now here was Daniel, on paper, doing the same thing in the last weeks of his life, and doing it better, and hiding it, and calling the hiding cowardly in a letter when the actual cowardice had been not saying it to his face.

Nathan paced. Three steps, the counter, three steps back. His thumb throbbed where he'd split it, which was ridiculous, he wanted to laugh except his jaw was locked.

He picked up the phone.

It rang four times. Voicemail. He hung up before the beep, because there was no version of the message he could stand to record.

He tried again. Four rings. Voicemail.

He set the phone face down on the counter and put both hands on the wood and stood there breathing. Ben was at work. Ben was at work at four in the afternoon on a Tuesday, and there was nothing sinister in a man not answering his phone at work, and the fact that Nathan's chest had gone tight over it was information he did not want.

He turned the phone back over. The draft message was still there. Three weeks old, unsent, four lines he'd rewritten until they'd stopped meaning anything, sitting under the contact name he'd put in as *Ben (Castine)* years ago and never changed.

He opened it, deleted all four lines, and typed one.

*I need to ask you something and it's not a nice question. Can you call me tonight.*

Then, before he could think about it, he sent it.

The blue bubble sat there. Delivered. He watched the screen like it might do something else.

His eyes went to the letter's last line. *I was good at keeping you.*

"I know," Nathan said. He didn't know whether he was answering Daniel or agreeing with him, and it didn't matter much, because the phone was still quiet in his hand, and the drawer in the back room was open, and somewhere in it — under the tax folders, behind the place where the eleventh envelope had been — there was one more.

He'd been so sure he knew what the twelfth would say. Daniel's last, the one that was supposed to close everything, the one the ninth letter had promised like a destination on a map. Nathan had spent the last three weeks assuming it said *be happy* and *let go* and *Bar Harbor*.

Daniel had just demonstrated, in his own handwriting, that Nathan did not know what was in that envelope. Not remotely.

Very carefully, Nathan put his phone in his pocket, walked to the back room, and looked down into the open drawer.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 33: The Eleventh Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads