The harbor road was four blocks down from the bookstore, past the chandlery and the ice cream stand that had already shuttered for the season. Nathan walked it with his hands in his jacket pockets, the wind off the water sharp enough to sting his knuckles. He'd told himself he was just checking the schedule. That was what he'd said to Dot. He'd said it out loud, which made it true enough to repeat.
The terminal was a low gray building with a green shingle roof and a hand-painted sign that read FERRY — DAILY SERVICE. A radio inside played something with a lot of guitar. Nathan pushed through the door and a man behind the counter looked up from a crossword.
"Schedule?"
"On the wall there." The man nodded without moving his pen.
Nathan looked. Winter hours, twice a day, and then he looked at the corkboard behind the counter where a laminated crew sheet was pinned. Names. And there, fourth down, printed in a font that made everyone look like they drove a truck: B. AVERY. Nathan stood in front of it longer than he needed to.
"Ben working today?"
The man set his pen down. "Ben's been out three days. Called in."
"Why."
"Didn't say."
Nathan looked at the corkboard again. There was a second board beside it, smaller, with a stack of thin spiral notebooks on a shelf underneath — deck logs, he guessed. The top one had a piece of masking tape on the cover with a date in ballpoint.
"They leave these out?"
The man shrugged. "Crew leaves their logs. We keep a couple months back. Ben keeps his on the boat mostly."
Nathan picked up the top notebook. The man didn't stop him. In a town like this, if you walked in from the street and your name was on the bookstore sign, you could read almost anything you wanted. He flipped it open.
It wasn't Ben's handwriting. He knew Ben's handwriting from the notes Ben used to leave on the counter at the store — boxy, no loops, the pen pressed hard. This was someone else's, cramped and slanted. He put it back and lifted the next one down.
This one had BEN in marker on the cover. Beneath it, in smaller letters, a date range. Nathan opened to the last page with writing on it.
The entry was short. Six lines, dated four days ago. The pen had pressed hard enough to score the paper.
*Ran the 7:40 and the 4:15. Same water, same gray. Cold front coming in so the crossing was rough going out but fine coming back. Nobody much on board.*
Then a line break. Then this, smaller:
*I can't keep waiting for something that isn't coming. If he wanted to be here he'd be here. He came to the harbor twice while I was on the deck and turned around both times and I watched him do it and he doesn't know I did. So maybe that's my answer. I asked him to come once. I'm not going to ask again.*
Nathan read it twice. The store's cash register made a sound it didn't actually make; he heard it anyway, a low click. He had turned around twice, both times, and he hadn't known anyone was watching. He'd stood at the end of the pier with his hands in his pockets and looked at the ferry and gone home. Because he wasn't ready. Because it wasn't Thursday yet. Because he'd gotten good at finding reasons, over twenty years, and he had a fresh supply.
The last line was underneath, in the same hard pen:
*Guess that's it, then.*
Nathan put his hand flat on the page like he was holding something down.
"Something wrong?"
"No." He turned a page, pretending to read. The dates went backward. Ben had logged every crossing of the season. Weather, passengers, notes about a broken pump, a dog that got loose on the car deck, a kid who threw up on the seats and Ben had cleaned it himself. Small unglamorous records of showing up. Nathan turned back to the last page and read the entry a third time.
He was supposed to be past this. That was the whole point of the letters, the ash, the walk down to Bar Harbor and the wind on the hill. Daniel had asked him for something and he had finally done it, all of it, every one of them. His hands had stopped shaking two days ago. He had a group on Thursdays. He had Daniel's painting hung behind the register where he could see it. He had, by any measure anyone else would use, finished.
But Ben had watched him turn around. Twice.
"There a pen?"
The man behind the counter raised his eyebrows. "For?"
Nathan didn't answer. He took one out of the cup on the counter anyway — the man didn't stop him — and he stood there with the logbook open to the last page and a clean spot beneath Ben's last line, and he wrote:
*You weren't wrong that I came. You were wrong about why I left. — N.*
He looked at that for a second. It was too small. It was four words doing the work of a hundred. He added, in small cramped letters that matched nothing, an old man's scrawl:
*I'm going to call you. If you don't pick up I'll keep calling. I'm not good at this part.*
He put the pen back. He thought about crossing it out. He left it.
"Ben comes back tomorrow?"
The man had gone back to his crossword. "Said he would. If he doesn't, I'm calling his brother."
"What's his brother's name?"
"Wes. Lives over in Ellsworth. You buying a ticket or not?"
"No." Nathan closed the logbook and laid it on the shelf exactly as he'd found it, spine out, BEN facing up. "Thanks."
He went outside. The wind had picked up and the water beyond the breakwater was the color of a nickel. The *Ellie M.* was tied up at the end of the pier with a line slack across her bow, no lights. She should have been running the 4:15. Instead she sat there with her mast rocking, empty, and Nathan stood and looked at her and thought about all the people who had to cross to get to work on Monday and wouldn't, because a man had decided not to come in.
He took out his phone. The draft was still there. It had sat in that box at the bottom of the thread for nine days, blinking at him. *Ben. I know what Daniel wrote to you. Can we talk. I'm sorry I —*
That was where he had stopped, every time, at the sorry I. Sorry I what. Sorry I screamed at you in the parking lot eight years ago. Sorry I said I never wanted to see you again. Sorry I made it a rule in my own head and then followed it for the better part of a decade, and then a letter showed up and told me to drive to Bucksport and a stranger mentioned your name and I sat in my truck in the dark for forty minutes before I could start the engine.
That was more than a text could carry. He put the phone away.
The note was the thing. The note was in the log, in his own handwriting, on a page Ben would turn to because it was the page he'd just written. Nathan knew him well enough to know he'd read it. That was the point of writing it there. You put a thing where a man will find it.
He started walking back up the harbor road. His hands were cold again. Halfway up, past the shuttered ice cream stand, he stopped and turned around and looked at the water one more time, and the *Ellie M.*, and the empty pier, and he felt the small specific thing he had spent thirty years avoiding at all costs: the possibility that the answer to a question he hadn't asked was already gone.
He walked another block and stopped again.
The bookshop was up there, dark, the sign with his name on it. Under the sign, in the window, was a copy of a travel book Daniel had carried on every road trip they'd ever taken, always the previous year's edition, which drove Nathan crazy. He could see it from here. He stared at it for a long time.
Then he crossed to the pay phone outside the market — because he had left his phone at the shop — and he put in a quarter he had to dig for, and he dialed the number he had known by heart since he was twenty-three. Four rings. Five.
"Hi, you've reached Ben Avery. Leave it after the beep, I'll get back to you."
"Ben. It's Nathan." He heard his own voice do the thing it did when he was nervous, getting flat and careful. "I came to the ferry. You weren't there. Somebody said you'd be back tomorrow, so — I'll come by. Or you can call the shop. Or you can come by the shop. I hung the painting, it's — that's not the point." The recording beeped twice, warning. "I read your log. I left a note. Call me."
He hung up. His quarter was gone. He stood on the sidewalk outside the market and the wind came off the water and pushed at his back, and he thought, with a clarity that felt almost like being punched: if Ben had decided *that's it, then*, he wouldn't know where to even begin undoing it.
There was one place he hadn't finished. Daniel had always been the one who knew where the seams were.