The back room smelled like paper and dust and the ghost of Daniel's cigarettes, which was strange, because Nathan had quit three years before Daniel died and Daniel had quit with him, mostly, except for the last stretch when the cancer was already in his lungs and quitting had stopped being the point.
Nathan had pulled the file boxes out of the closet one by one. He'd told himself it was inventory. The store's insurance needed an updated count of the rare stock, and the rare stock was back here, wedged behind Daniel's journals, which was a sentence Nathan had never quite let himself finish thinking before.
Twelve journals. Leather, cloth, spiral, one held shut with a rubber band so old it snapped when he touched it. Nathan had opened them in order two weeks ago and read the tenth letter's instructions and put them all back. He'd known what they were. He'd just avoided the last four.
He was avoiding them now, technically. He was counting books. He was doing a very good job of counting books until his elbow caught the corner of the bottom file box and tipped it, and a folded square of paper slid out and lay face-up on the floor, and Nathan knew Daniel's hand before he knew anything else.
The paper was from the logbook. Nathan recognized the ruling, the faint blue lines, the torn left edge where it had been pulled out along the perforation rather than cut. He'd held that logbook in his own hands three days ago. He'd read the last entry. He'd written in it.
He picked the page up. He did not fold it back. He sat down on the floor with his back against the desk and read.
*March 14*
*Ben came back to the store again today. Third time this week. He stands near the marine section and pretends to browse and I pretend not to watch him pretending. I finally asked him what he was waiting for and he said nothing, which is the loudest thing Ben has ever said.*
Nathan's throat tightened. He kept reading.
*I told him I knew. I told him I'd known since the summer we all went to Camden and he looked at Nathan across the picnic table like Nathan was the only lit window on a dark street. Ben didn't deny it. He just went very still, the way he does, and asked how long.*
*I said six years.*
*He asked if Nathan knew.*
*I said no. I said Nathan doesn't see things like that, doesn't look for them, and it's not because he's stupid, it's because he's spent his whole life braced for the other shoe and you can't brace and look at the same time.*
*Ben said, "Then why are you telling me this."*
*I said because I'm dying.*
Nathan closed his eyes. When he opened them the room had gotten a little dimmer, or his eyes had. He read on.
*I told him the truth, which is that I've been sick for eleven months and I've known since September that it's not going to work, and the one thing I can't stand is the idea of leaving Nathan alone in that store with the register that sticks and nobody to argue with about the thermostat. Ben said he'd check in on him. I said that's not what I'm asking.*
*He got angry. First time I've seen Ben angry since we were twenty-two and he put his fist through the wall of the dorm when his father died. He said, "You're asking me to wait for your husband to finish grieving you. Do you hear how that sounds."*
*I said yes. I hear it. I'm not asking you to wait. I'm asking you to be there. There's a difference and you know it.*
*He sat down on the floor right there in the store, in the aisle by the poetry, and put his head in his hands and didn't say anything for a long time. Then he said, "If I say yes, you have to promise me you'll tell him. Not after. Before. He should know it was your idea. He should know I didn't—"*
*He didn't finish. I knew what he meant. He should know I didn't go after him while you were still alive.*
*I said I would tell him.*
*I didn't.*
The page shook. Nathan looked at his own hand and realized it was shaking, that his whole arm was, and he set the paper flat on his knee and pressed his palm down over it and breathed until the lines stopped swimming.
Ben had said no. Or Ben had said yes, on one condition. Nathan couldn't tell which, and the not-telling was the point, the whole page was built like a trap, and Daniel had built it carefully, and Nathan had walked into it three days ago at a ferry terminal and turned around and walked out again.
*There's more,* Daniel wrote. *The next part is the part I'm ashamed of.*
*Ben said he needed time. I said fine. And then I asked him for something I had no right to ask, which was that if he ever did tell Nathan, he'd do it after — not while I was still here, not while Nathan was still standing at a bedside every night, because I'm a jealous man and I wanted the last months. I wanted them for me. I told myself it was for Nathan. It wasn't. It was for me.*
*Ben looked at me for a long time and then he said, "You're a real piece of work, Daniel." And then he said, "Fine." And then he left.*
*I stopped the ferry.*
Nathan read that sentence four times. It didn't parse. He read it again.
*I went down to the terminal on the fourteenth and I talked to the scheduler and I told them the Thursday 9:40 had six regulars and no cargo and I'd personally cover the difference out of the store's account if they'd move it to Friday. I told them it was a maintenance thing. It wasn't. Ben rides the Thursday 9:40 home from Rockland. That's the boat he takes. I took it away from him so he'd have to come to me. I wanted him in the store. I wanted him where I could watch him not say the thing.*
*He never figured it out. He just started coming in Thursdays instead. He never asked why. He's so good, Nathan. He's so much better than either of us.*
*I don't know what I'm doing. I'm dying and I'm stage-managing a love story I don't get to be in and I keep telling myself I'm doing it for you. I'm not. I'm doing it because I can't stand that there's a version of the future where you're happy and I'm not in it, and I want to make sure that when it happens, it happens because I said so.*
*If you're reading this you've read the letters. I'm sorry. I made a maze and you walked it and I called that a gift.*
*Forgive Ben. He didn't do anything. He waited. That's all he ever did. He waited and I moved the ferry.*
Nathan sat on the floor of the back room for a long time. Outside, someone was loading a truck down at the pier; the sound came through the wall in dull thuds. He looked at the paper in his lap and then at the file box and then at the ceiling, which had the same water stain it had had for eleven years, the one Daniel had always said looked like Portugal.
Ben had waited. Nathan had known that much. He'd known Ben waited. What he hadn't known was that Daniel had asked him to. That Daniel had asked, and Ben had said *fine*, and then Daniel had moved a boat to keep him close enough to watch, and Ben had never asked why. Six years, Daniel had said. Ben had been waiting six years, and then four more months, and then eight days while Nathan locked the store and didn't answer his phone, and then three days out on the water.
Nathan got up. His knee cracked. He put the logbook page inside the drawer of the desk, not in the box, where he'd see it, and then he took it back out of the drawer and folded it and put it in his back pocket. He picked up the fourth-from-last journal, the one with the rubber band, and opened it. March fourteenth was there too, in longer hand, but he didn't need to read it again.
He needed to go.
He got his keys from the hook by the register and stopped in front of Daniel's painting, the one he'd hung eight days ago, the harbor with the fog coming in and one boat, small, heading out. Daniel had painted it the year before. Nathan had never asked which boat.
He took out his phone. The draft was still there, the apology, forty-one words he'd rewritten nine times. He read it once. Then he deleted it.
Then he typed a new one. Four words.
*I know. I'm coming.*
He didn't send it. Not yet. He could send it from the car, or from the dock, or from the doorway of Ben's boat, wherever Ben was, if Ben was even still in the harbor, if three days out didn't mean something Nathan was afraid to finish thinking.
He pulled the door shut behind him. The bell Daniel had hung eleven years ago, the brass one that didn't ring right, rang anyway.