Ben arrived at 10:04, which was close enough to ten that Nathan stopped pretending he hadn't been watching the door since nine-thirty. He'd wiped down the counter twice, moved a stack of used paperbacks to the front display three times, and finally stood by the window pretending to read the back of a Patricia Highsmith reissue. When Ben pushed open the door—bell chiming, a gust of cold harbor air following him in—Nathan set the book down and felt the room get smaller.
"Sorry I'm late," Ben said. He was wearing a gray wool sweater, sleeves pushed up, fingers red from the cold. He looked, Nathan thought, like a man who had spent three days on the water and had not yet decided whether he was glad to be back on land. "I sat in the truck for a few minutes."
"That's fine."
The silence lasted a beat too long. Ben looked around the shop—the mismatched armchairs, the brass lamps, the water stains on the ceiling that Nathan had been meaning to paint over for two years. His eyes landed on the broken chipmunk mug sitting on the counter, and Nathan saw him notice it but not comment. Nathan had been meaning to throw it away for months too.
"Coffee?" Nathan said.
"God, yes."
He ducked into the back room, where the machine sat on the shelf next to Daniel's old lunchbox. It was a percolator Daniel had bought at a yard sale in Camden with a dent in the side, and Nathan refused to replace it. He made two cups, black, and carried them out. Ben was standing by the shelf of local Maine poets, hands in his pockets.
"You still have the Ellsworth chapbooks," Ben said.
"I still have everything."
They sat in the armchairs by the window, the ones angled toward the water. The light was the flat gray November kind that made everything look like a photograph taken before the invention of color. Through the glass they could see the harbor, the boats riding at their moorings, one fishing vessel making its slow way out past the breakwater. Neither of them said anything for a while.
"I'm going to ask you something," Nathan said. "And I want the real answer. Not the one you gave me in the summer of 2019."
Ben looked at his coffee. "You know I didn't."
"I know you told me you couldn't do it. That you weren't built for it. That it wasn't about me." Nathan's voice was steady, which surprised him. He'd rehearsed this in the truck, in the shower, in the hour before the store opened, but he'd expected the words to come out cracked. "I read Daniel's logbook. The missing page. He wrote down the night he called you. He wrote about what you said when he asked you to stop the ferry."
Ben's jaw tightened. He didn't look away, but his shoulders came up a fraction of an inch, the way they did on the boat when the wind shifted and he had to adjust the sails without seeming to.
"He wrote that you told him you were in love with me," Nathan said. "That you couldn't be around me after Daniel got sick. That you were scared of what you'd do if I let you in."
The silence went on long enough that a customer could have walked in and Nathan would have served them without noticing. Ben set his cup on the side table. His hands were unsteady, and he pressed them flat against his thighs as if to hold them still.
"I lied," Ben said. "Not—not about the thing Daniel wrote. That was true. But when I told you I wasn't built for it, I lied. I was scared. That's all it was. I was scared of being around you with Daniel sick, and I was scared of what would happen if I wasn't around you, and I couldn't figure out which was worse, so I picked the one that made me feel like I was in control." He looked up. "It was a lie, Nathan. I'm sorry."
The words landed in the room and sat there. Nathan had spent seven years being angry at a version of Ben who was colder than this one. Seven years of ordering coffee at the diner and pretending it didn't matter which stool Ben took. Seven years of telling himself that the man who'd walked out of his life had done it because he didn't care enough to stay, when the truth was he'd cared so much he couldn't bear it.
"I know," Nathan said. "I think I knew before I read it."
"You just didn't want to."
"I didn't want to."
Ben laughed softly. It wasn't a happy sound. "We're a pair."
"We are." Nathan took a drink of his coffee. It was too hot and it burned the roof of his mouth, and he let it burn. "I forgave you weeks ago, for the record. Before I read the logbook. I forgave you on the dock the first time you agreed to meet me, and then I un-forgave you, and then I forgave you again. It's been a whole process. I don't recommend it."
"You don't have to make it easy on me."
"I'm not making it easy. I'm telling you the truth. I'm trying to do that now." Nathan set his cup down next to Ben's. "I pushed you away too. Every time you came to the door, I told you I was fine. Every time you called, I let it go to voicemail. I built this whole shrine to my own grief and I wouldn't let anyone in it, including the one person who—" He stopped. He hadn't said the rest out loud, not to anyone. "Including the one person who knew what I'd lost, because he'd lost him too. In his own way."
Ben's eyes were wet. He didn't wipe them. "The thing I remember most about Daniel," he said, "is how he never once made me feel like I was intruding. When you two would have me over for dinner, I'd walk in and he'd already have set a place for me. Not like a guest. Like a third chair that was supposed to be there." He swallowed. "I loved him too, you know. Not the way you did. But I loved him."
"I know." Nathan's voice came out rough. "He knew. He wrote it down."
"What did he write?"
Nathan looked toward the back room, where the journals sat in the drawer, where the last unopened letter sat beneath them, waiting. "That he wanted us to be okay. That he was worried about what would happen to us after. That he thought—" He stopped. "That's what he wrote."
Ben waited. When Nathan didn't finish, he didn't push. That was one of the things Nathan had forgotten about him, or made himself forget: the way he could let a silence alone, sit in it without needing to fill it. They sat now. The light shifted on the water. Somewhere down the street a door slammed and a gull screamed and the ordinary town kept going.
"I'm going to ask you one more thing," Nathan said, "and then I'll stop asking questions for a while."
"Okay."
"When you found the envelope in the stern locker. How long had it been there?"
Ben looked at him steadily. "I found it the night you came to the terminal. I was coming in and I reached under the bench for the stern line and my hand hit it. It was tucked up under the gunwale, behind the float cushion. I don't know how long it's been there. Months, probably. Maybe a year. It's addressed to you." He reached into the pocket of his sweater and drew out a stiff manila envelope, creased at the corner, Nathan's name written across the front in Daniel's slanted handwriting. He held it out.
Nathan didn't take it. Not yet. He looked at it the way you look at a wave cresting toward the dock—knowing it will land, not knowing where. "Why didn't you hand it over before?"
"Because I didn't want it to be the only reason you were talking to me." Ben's hand stayed out. "I wanted you to come to the dock for me, not for what was inside."
Nathan took the envelope. It was heavier than a letter should be. Something that wasn't paper pressed against his palm through the manila, a small hard rectangle in the bottom corner. He didn't open it. He set it on the table between their cups, face down, and looked at Ben.
"Stay for lunch," he said.
Ben's mouth twitched. "You just came to the dock to get the envelope."
"I came to the dock to see you. The envelope was the reason I let myself." Nathan reached across the space between the armchairs and rested his hand on the arm of Ben's chair, palm up. An offer. "I'm not going to open it right now. I need to—I need to be here, with you, before I do."
Ben looked at the hand for a long moment. Then he put his own hand in it, warm and rough, calloused across the palm from the ropes. His fingers laced through Nathan's like they'd done it before, in some life Nathan had talked himself out of remembering. Neither of them said anything. The bell over the door didn't ring. The coffee went cold.
Then Ben's eyes moved past Nathan, toward the far wall, and stopped. "That painting," he said. "The one above the register. Did Daniel do that?"
Nathan turned to look. It was a small oil, maybe ten by fourteen, a stretch of coastline he'd never been able to place—cliffs and water and a strip of horizon the color of old pennies. He'd hung it there the month after the funeral and hadn't really looked at it since. "Yes. Why?"
"Nothing." Ben's hand tightened around his. "I'll tell you later."