Letters from the Coast

Chapter 41: The Conversation

The stern locker door hung open. Inside, wedged where the life jackets usually sat, was a manila envelope gone soft at the corners from salt air. Nathan's name on the front in Daniel's slanted, hurried hand. Ben had told him about it at the top of the ramp and then hadn't said anything else—just walked him down the pier, past the fuel dock, to the end where the pilings smelled of creosote and old rope, and sat down on the edge with his boots over the water.

Nathan hadn't reached for the envelope. It sat between them on the weathered planks like something that might bite.

"You want me to tell you what's in it?" Ben asked.

"You opened it."

"I didn't." Ben took off his cap, ran a hand through hair flattened by three days of it. "It's sealed. I found it when I was changing out the stern line. Daniel asked me to keep a box of stuff on the boat—tools, mostly, junk he didn't want at the house. The envelope was under the star chart. I looked at it for a day and a half before I told you. Didn't sleep."

Nathan picked it up. Light. Maybe two pages. He turned it over, and his thumb found the seam where the glue had dried, and he didn't open it.

"Why didn't you read it."

"It's not mine." Ben watched the water. "Nothing on that boat is mine."

"You've captained it for eleven years."

"I ran it for him." Ben's jaw worked. "Come on, Nathan. You know the difference."

The harbor was going quiet. The last of the afternoon charter crowd had cleared out; a gull stood on a piling and ignored them both. Nathan put the envelope inside his jacket, against his chest, where it pressed flat and warm.

"I wrote you a letter," he said. "A few days ago. I didn't send it."

"I figured." Ben's mouth moved, not quite a smile. "You called and hung up twice. I saw you come down to the harbor and stand at the gate and turn around. Twice."

"I know. I read your log."

Ben's head came around sharp. "You read the log."

"You left it on the deck bench. I wasn't—" Nathan stopped. "I was looking for you. I was going to apologize and I rehearsed it all the way down and then I saw the boat wasn't there and I sat on the bench for an hour, and the log was right there. I read the last entry. The one where you said you were done waiting."

"Yeah." Ben looked back at the water. "That was a bad night."

"I'm sorry it was."

"Don't." Ben held up a hand, palm out, flat. "Don't do the thing where you apologize for how I feel. You didn't make me feel it. I did that on my own, for a long time, and I'm not handing you the bill."

Nathan turned the words over. It was the most Ben had said to him in eleven years, probably, outside of logistics—lines and weather and whose turn it was to lock up. He tried to get a grip on the feeling in his chest and found he couldn't name it. Not quite guilt. Not quite relief.

"I'm scared," he said.

Ben waited.

"I'm scared that if I—" Nathan gestured at the space between them, vague, useless. "With you. That it means I'm replacing him. That I'm saying what we had was something you move on from. And I can't say that. I can't say it because it isn't true." He heard his own voice go thin. "He's still in the house. His mug's on the counter. I haven't moved his coat off the hook by the door. There's a letter in the drawer in the back room I still haven't read. If I—if we—I don't know how to do that and keep him."

Ben was quiet for a long moment. A lobster boat came in past the breakwater, engine ticking low, and the wake rocked the pilings.

"Can I say something," Ben said, "and you don't take it as me being a smartass."

"Go ahead."

"I'm not asking to replace him, Nate." He said it plainly, no heat. "I never was. I don't want his side of the bed. I don't want to be the guy who comes after and pretends the first guy wasn't there. That's not—" He shook his head. "I knew him too. Twenty years I knew him. He's the reason I'm on this water at all. You think I want to erase that?"

"Then what do you want."

Ben took a breath like it cost him something.

"I want to sit somewhere with you that isn't a hospital waiting room or a funeral home or the deck of a boat while you figure out what to tell me. I want to have coffee and not check the clock. That's it. That's the whole ask." He looked at Nathan sideways. "Is that something you can do."

Nathan thought about the notebook in his pocket. He thought about the letter on his chest and the one in the drawer and the envelope in the glovebox that Margaret had sealed, that he'd been driving around with for weeks like a passenger. He thought about how he'd spent two years proving to himself that he could carry all of it alone, and how the carrying had worn a groove in him so deep he couldn't see out of it.

"Slowly," he said.

"Slow is the only speed I run." Ben almost smiled. "I'm a ferry captain. I go four knots on purpose."

"Six when you're late."

"I'm never late. That's Daniel's boat you're thinking of. He'd run it wide open and burn the engine out." Ben said it and then went still, like he'd put his foot on ice. "Sorry."

"Don't be." Nathan was surprised to find he meant it. "He did. He burned out everything he ran. Ask me how I know."

And Ben laughed—short, rough, surprised out of him—and Nathan felt something in his chest shift, a joint loosening that had been locked so long it had grown over.

They sat another few minutes. The gull flew off. The sun was down behind the western shore and the water had gone the flat gray-silver it got in the last half hour before dark, when everything looked like it had been left out in the rain.

"There's a thing I should tell you before you decide anything," Ben said.

"Something worse than the envelope?"

"Different kind of worse." He picked at the seam of his cap. "The log. The night Daniel asked me to stop the ferry. He asked me to keep it quiet. Not the fact of it—you knew, eventually, or you guessed. But why. He asked me to say it was mechanical. He didn't want people thinking he couldn't do the run. And I said yes because I owed him and I didn't want to fight about it and—" Ben's voice dropped. "And because I was scared. If I told the truth about that night I'd have to tell the truth about the rest, and the rest was the part where I'd been in love with you since the summer I turned twenty-nine and I was standing on his deck at two in the morning keeping his secret, and I couldn't say any of it. So I lied. I let you think it was mechanical. And you looked at me like I was something that belonged to him, and I hated every day of it, and I never told you."

The tide was turning. Somewhere out past the breakwater a bell buoy rang once, hollow, and then again.

Nathan looked at him for a long time.

"You were protecting him," he said.

"I was protecting me. There's a difference."

"I know there is." Nathan stood up, and his knees complained, and he held out a hand. Ben looked at it like it might be a trick. Then he took it, and Nathan pulled him up, and they stood there on the end of the pier with their hands together for one second past the point where either of them could pretend it hadn't happened.

"Come by the store tomorrow," Nathan said. "Ten o'clock. I'll make coffee. The real kind, not the pot that's been on since Tuesday."

"I have a run at eight. I'll be there by ten-thirty."

"You'll be there at ten. You said you're never late."

"I said the boat's never late." Ben let go of his hand, slowly, like he was putting something down he'd been holding a long while. "Fine. Ten."

Nathan turned to go, three steps, and then stopped and came back, and got the envelope out of his jacket and held it up between them.

"One more thing," he said. "I'm going to open this tonight. Whatever's in it, I think—I think you should be the one who knows first. After me." He looked at Ben. "So maybe don't sleep on the boat."

Ben didn't say anything for a beat. The buoy rang. Then he nodded, once, and Nathan walked back up the pier toward the truck with the envelope in his hand and his heart going like a man who'd just found out the ice would hold after all.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 41: The Conversation · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads