They drove to the marina in Nathan's truck, the painting still wrapped and riding in the glove box like something with a heartbeat. Ben didn't talk much on the way, and Nathan didn't push. The morning was bright and cold and the water on the bay had that hammered look, all light broken into pieces.
Ben parked and led him down the dock to the Sagacity. She sat at the end slip, freshly painted, her name repainted by hand in Ben's careful block letters. But he didn't take Nathan aboard. He stopped at the piling and put his hand on the wet wood, and looked at the boat instead of at him.
"I opened Daniel's letter a year ago," Ben said. "I told you that. But I didn't tell you everything it did to me." He took a breath. "I need to go back further than the letter."
"Okay."
"I lied about why I stopped running her." Ben's jaw worked. "I told you it was Daniel. That after he died I couldn't stand to be out here without him, that the ferry felt like a grave. That's not why."
Nathan said nothing. The gulls were arguing over something down the dock.
"It was you," Ben said. "I stopped because of you."
Nathan waited.
"The season before he died, I started pulling back. I told people it was the survey, the money, the certification—all of it was true enough. But the reason was that I couldn't stand watching the two of you." Ben finally looked at him. "Every crossing, you'd be standing at the rail and he'd lean in and say something and you'd laugh, and I'd be inside the cabin running the wheel and I'd want to put my fist through the window. I was in love with you, Nathan. Had been for years. I couldn't bear to see you with him, so I quit before I did something I couldn't take back."
The bay went on making its small noises. Nathan felt the cold come up through the soles of his boots.
"You never said."
"I never said." Ben laughed, short and ugly. "What was I going to say? You were happy. He was my friend too. So I told myself I was being decent, and I made it into a story about grief, and I've been telling that story so long I almost believed it."
Nathan put his hands in his jacket pockets. He looked past Ben at the Sagacity, at the cabin he'd helped paint, the white and the clean lines of her.
"I know," he said.
Ben blinked. "What?"
"The logbook." Nathan pulled his hand out and rubbed his face. "When I helped you sort the wheelhouse, back in the fall. There were entries in your hand. All that last season, you wrote less and less. And then there were the runs you gave away—you had Arthur take three of the September crossings, and you wrote the reason as 'crew,' but there wasn't any crew. I read it and I thought, that's a man who's trying not to be somewhere." He shrugged. "I told myself I was imagining things. But I knew. I think I've known for a while."
Ben stared at him. "You knew and you didn't say anything?"
"Same as you." Nathan's voice came out gentle, which surprised him. "You were my friend. Daniel was my—Daniel was everything then. What was I going to do, walk up to you and say, I can see it, stop? You'd have hated me. Or worse, you'd have told me the truth and I'd have had to do something about it."
Ben made a sound, half a laugh. "And now?"
"Now Daniel's dead, and I've spent two years being angry at a version of you I made up." Nathan turned and faced the water, and Ben came and stood beside him, shoulder to shoulder, not touching. "I thought you took the ferry away from me because you couldn't handle losing him. That did something to me. I decided you were the kind of man who runs."
"I was." Ben's voice was rough. "I ran. That's exactly what I did. You weren't wrong about me."
"No," Nathan said. "I was wrong about why. There's a difference." He looked at the boat. "You refitted her. You put your money in and you're going to run her again, and you want to carry people out to the islands, and you gave me all that—" He stopped. Started again. "You didn't have to do any of it."
"I wanted to."
"I know." Nathan turned to him. "Ben. I'm not angry."
"You should be."
"I've been angry for two years about a lie I made up myself. I'm done." He reached over and took Ben's hand out of his pocket and held it, there on the dock, in the daylight, where anyone coming down to their boats could see. "No more secrets. That's the deal. Whatever else you're carrying—Daniel's letter, whatever it says—you say it out loud to me. And whatever I'm carrying, I say it to you."
Ben looked down at their hands. His face was doing something complicated.
"Okay," he said. "Deal."
They stood there a while. One of the lobstermen went by and nodded at them like it was nothing, like men held hands on the dock every day, and it was—it was no one's business and it was fine.
"There's something else," Ben said finally.
Nathan braced. "Go ahead."
"The letter from Daniel." Ben reached inside his jacket and brought out a folded paper, worn soft at the creases, the way paper gets when a man carries it for a year and reads it too many times. "I need you to have it. I've been holding it like a stone in my pocket and I want it out of my hands. But before you read it—there's one thing I have to say, and I want to say it here, so you can walk away if you want to."
"Ben—"
"Your man knew," Ben said. "About me. He knew, and he wrote to me about it, and he was kind about it, and I don't think I ever forgave him for being kind." He held the letter out. "That's what's in here. Whatever else you find. That's the part I couldn't say to your face."
Nathan looked at the letter in Ben's hand. His own handwriting was nowhere on it; it was Daniel's steady engineer's print, the letters he used to write out invoices and grocery lists in, the same hand that had written twelve letters to Nathan and this one to Ben.
"All right," Nathan said. He took the letter, and folded it into his own jacket without opening it. "But not here. And not alone."
Ben nodded. "The diner's still open. The one with the bad pie."
"Lead the way."
They started up the dock. At the head of it Nathan stopped and looked back at the Sagacity, sitting at the end of her slip like a promise someone finally intended to keep. Then he looked at Ben walking ahead of him, shoulders loose now, the way a man walks when something's been carried too long and set down.
"Hey," Nathan called.
Ben turned.
"Saturday." Nathan gestured with his chin back at the boat. "Great Harbor. You still want to take her out, or do you want to take the truck?"
Ben thought about it. He looked at the Sagacity and then back at Nathan, and something in his face changed—not relief exactly, but a decision, the kind you only get to make once.
"Neither," he said. "There's something I need to show you first. Something in Daniel's letter I never told you about."
Nathan's hand went to the envelope inside his jacket. "Ben."
"It's not what you think." Ben's voice was even. "It's a place. He wrote about a place he wanted you to go. And Nathan—" He stopped, and when he spoke again it was slow and careful, like he was setting something down on a table between them that neither of them could pick back up. "It's not in Maine. It's not anywhere near here."