Letters from the Coast

Chapter 53: The Unexpected Guest

The woman was standing at the mystery shelf with her back to the door, reading the first page of a paperback she hadn't paid for, and Nathan almost told her to take her time. Then she turned, and he saw her face.

His hand stopped on the counter.

She was maybe fifty-five, gray-streaked dark hair cut short, a canvas bag over one shoulder. The kind of face that rearranged itself once you knew it—the same deep-set eyes as Daniel, the same narrow jaw, softer in the mouth. Nathan had seen her twice in twenty years, both times at funerals, and only one of those had been Daniel's.

"Marion."

"Nathan." She set the paperback down like it was evidence. "Claire said I could wait. I told her I'd rather not come in at all, and then I did anyway."

He came out from behind the counter, because it felt wrong to have a counter between them. The store was empty, mid-afternoon light coming low off the water and turning the dust to something almost deliberate. Somewhere in the back Ben's painted cabin was still drying on the *Sagacity*, but Ben wasn't here. This was Nathan's to stand in.

"Coffee?" he said. "Tea. I think there's tea."

"There's never tea, when someone offers tea." She didn't sit. She looked at the shelves, the stacked paperbacks, the reading chair with its busted arm. "It's exactly what I pictured. He never described it."

"He never described much of anything to you," Nathan said, and it came out flatter than he meant.

Marion's mouth tightened. "No. He didn't." She finally took the chair, sat forward, both hands on the canvas bag in her lap. "I owe you an apology, and I've been practicing it for three weeks in the car, and now it sounds even worse. I'm sorry I didn't tell you about Ellis."

Nathan didn't move. Out the window, a truck went by, too fast for a town street.

"I didn't know he'd kept it from you," Marion said. "That's the part I want you to hear. I found out at the memorial. Someone mentioned Ellis, one of the cousins, and you looked like the floor had tilted."

"I remember."

"I thought—" She stopped, restarted. "I thought you knew. I assumed, all those years, that he'd told you. Because who doesn't tell the person they've built a life with?"

"Apparently Daniel."

"Apparently." She pulled in a breath. "When I realized, I told myself I'd write. Then I told myself he'd want to tell you himself, and I should leave it—and then he was gone, and I'd left it too long, and it turned into a thing I couldn't do. Which is a coward's story. It's the story of a coward. I'm not asking you to forgive it."

Nathan crouched—his knees complained—so he could see her face straight on. "Ellis is his brother."

"Half-brother. Twelve years younger. My father had an affair, and Ellis came out of it, and for a while nobody in the family would say his name in a room." Marion's voice stayed level, the way people talk when they've worn the edges off a thing by repeating it. "Daniel was nineteen when Ellis was born. He was the only one who ever went to see them."

"He never said." The words came out thin. "Twenty years."

"He was ashamed, Nathan. Not of Ellis. Of us. Of the whole arrangement. He used to say the family was a house with a room he couldn't bring anyone into." She looked at the shelves again. "You were the only person he ever brought into anything. That's not nothing."

Nathan stood up because his knees hurt and because sitting still was becoming unbearable. He went to the window and looked at the harbor, the *Sagacity* sitting gray and patient against the dock. He thought of the key in the manila envelope, unnamed, unlabeled. He thought of a room he'd never been shown.

"Did Ellis know about me?"

"Ellis died at thirty-one. Motorcycle, on the Turnpike. Eight years ago." Marion's hands closed on the bag. "Daniel drove down for the funeral and came back the same night. He called me from the highway and he sounded—I've only heard a man sound like that twice. The other time was you, at his."

Nathan stood very still.

"You're the one he grieved *in front of,*" Marion said. "That's what I came to tell you. I spent eight years thinking he had someone, and I was jealous of it, and then I understood it was you and I was only jealous of something I never got to have." She reached into the bag. "I brought this because I couldn't bring the rest. This is the one thing I want to give you, and then I'll go, and you never have to see me again."

It was a snapshot, four by six, the color gone soft and yellow along one edge, the way only real prints go. Two boys on a porch step. The older one maybe fourteen, long-limbed and severe, already wearing the face Nathan knew—the closed expression, the careful hands. Beside him a small boy, six or seven, with the same jaw softened into something open and unguarded, his head tipped against his brother's shoulder. The older boy's arm was around him. Not posed. Just there.

Nathan took it and his thumb found the older boy's face without being told to.

"That's the porch on the old house," Marion said. "Nineteen eighty-one. Ellis was maybe six. Daniel used to put him to sleep on that step, summer nights, when our mother was—she wasn't well, that year." She stood, straightened her bag. "He kept that picture in his wallet. All the way through, until the end. I don't know if you knew that."

"I didn't."

"I'll go now."

"Marion." She stopped at the door and didn't turn around. "Did he ever—" Nathan held the photo by its corner, very carefully. "Did he ever say why he couldn't tell me?"

"He said he'd made too many rooms to keep straight," Marion said. "And that he'd rather you never find out he was the kind of man who made rooms in the first place."

Then the bell over the door rang, and she was gone, and Nathan stood in his own bookstore holding a photograph of a man he'd lived with for twenty years and never quite known.

He sat down in the reading chair, which was hers now, still warm. He looked at the boys on the step for a long time.

Not betrayal. That was the thing he turned over and over. All year he'd been building it into infidelity, into a second life, into the shape of a man with a locked door and someone behind it. But there was no one behind it. There was a six-year-old with Daniel's jaw, and a nineteen-year-old who decided the family was a house he'd have to keep a room out of, and took the room with him into every year after.

*I built too many rooms,* Nathan thought, and then: *you could have brought me in.*

But he could see it now, the way you see a rock beneath water. Daniel hadn't hidden Ellis to keep Nathan out. He'd hidden him because he couldn't stand to be seen carrying him. Shame. That was what the key was for. The manila envelope, the unnamed key, the painting wrapped and waiting in the truck—rooms Daniel had built and couldn't walk back out of.

Nathan looked at the photo's edge, the date in pencil, the small curled corner where it had lived in a wallet for thirty years. He reached for his phone. Ben would be at the marina by now, finished sanding. Ben, who had heard Daniel say something once and promised not to tell. Ben, who had been waiting a year to say what was in the letter he'd opened.

The bell rang again.

"Sorry," Marion said, from the doorway. She had gone white, and not from anything in the shop. "I got to the car and I couldn't—there's a second part, and if I don't say it now I won't come back." She came in three steps and stopped. "The key. The one in the envelope. It's not a deposit box. It's a storage unit on Route 1 outside Rockland. I know because Ellis lived there. Daniel paid it for eight years. I don't know what's inside."

She turned and left, and this time she didn't come back.

Nathan stood holding the photograph, the bookshop light going orange and long across the floor, the *Sagacity* riding her lines out in the harbor, and Ben's number bright on the phone in his hand—everything he'd written down in letters, everything Daniel had refused to say out loud, waiting eight years in a room off Route 1.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 53: The Unexpected Guest · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads