Letters from the Coast

Chapter 65: The Unexpected Letter

The lawyer's call had left the store feeling borrowed, like a room someone else had just stepped out of. Nathan stood in the sawdust of the finished café shelves with the phone still warm against his ear, and Ben was watching him the way he watched weather—head tilted, waiting for which way it would break.

"Arthur found something," Nathan said. "A letter. From Daniel."

Ben set down the drill. "Daniel's been gone two years."

"Fourteen months past." Nathan pocketed the phone. "Postmarked never. Addressed to me."

Ben wiped his hands on his jeans slowly. "You want to open it now or you want me to go get coffee first."

"Coffee. Definitely coffee."

But he didn't wait for the coffee. He went up to the apartment while Ben walked to the Harbor Light, and he stood in the bedroom with the painting propped against the wall where he'd left it—the one Daniel had bought at a yard sale in Rockland the summer they met, a bad watercolor of a lighthouse that leaned left. Daniel had loved it precisely because it was bad. He'd hung it over the bed for eleven years.

Nathan lifted it off the easel. The backing paper had been slit once, long ago, and re-taped with masking tape gone amber. He'd never asked. It was the kind of thing you didn't ask.

His thumb found the seam. He worked the tape loose.

Inside, folded twice, was a page in Daniel's hand.

Not the looping, pressured script of the sickness—the last months had been ballpoint dug into paper like he was carving. This was the earlier hand. Loose. Confident. The way Daniel wrote when he had something to say and believed he had time to say it.

Nathan sat down on the floor.

*Nate,*

*If you're reading this, I've done the coward's version of honesty and left it where you'd have to be looking for it. Which means I think you already know. Which means I'm sorry.*

*It isn't for you. That's the first thing. This isn't yours.*

Nathan read it three times and still didn't understand, which was how he knew his hands had started shaking, because the page kept moving.

*It's for Ben. I need you to give it to him. I know that's a lot to ask from a dead man who was never good at the asking while he was alive.*

*You'll want to know why. Here's the truth, or as close as I can get without you standing there to argue with me.*

*I wrote this in March, before the tremor got into my hands. I knew by then. I didn't tell you because you would have made it about the two of us and it was already about the two of us and I couldn't stand it.*

*I watched you with him at the store that Christmas. The way you laughed at his terrible joke about the lobsterman. You didn't laugh like that with me anymore. Not because you didn't love me—I know you loved me. But because I'd made you tired. I did that. It wasn't the sickness. It was me.*

Nathan put the page down on the floor and pressed the heels of his hands into his eyes until he saw white.

*He's going to run. Ben runs. He ran from you once and it wasn't because he didn't want you, it was because he thought you deserved better and he was right, and then I got you instead. I took the thing he was too scared to hold. I never told you that. I'm telling you now.*

*So here's what I'm asking, and it's the only thing I've ever asked you straight: when I'm gone, don't close the store. Don't sell the letters. Don't make a shrine out of me. That's not love, Nate, that's taxidermy.*

*Give Ben this letter. Tell him I said it's fine. Tell him I said go.*

*I know you'll hate me for this. That's allowed. Hate me for a year if you need to. But then take the trip—the coast trip, the one we planned, the whole damned thing, Cutler to Kittery—and take it with him. He'll know where to stop. I wrote the stops down. He can have those too.*

*I'm sorry I couldn't say this to your face. You would have stopped me. You're very good at stopping people from leaving and very bad at letting them come back.*

*I loved you. I loved you badly and unevenly and I loved you.*

*—D.*

Downstairs, the bell over the door rang.

Nathan didn't move. He read the letter twice more. The fourth time he read it standing up, and by then he could hear Ben's boots on the stairs, two cups, the paper bag crackling.

Ben stopped in the doorway. "Nate."

"It's not for me." Nathan held out the page. His voice came out level, which surprised him. "It's for you."

Ben didn't take it.

"Take it, Ben."

"What is it."

"Daniel wrote it. Before. Before the end. He hid it in the painting." Nathan turned the page over, showed the blank back, as if that proved something. "It's addressed to me but it's for you. He says so. First line."

Ben set the coffees on the dresser. He took the letter the way you take something that might be hot. He read it standing in the doorway in the gray afternoon light, and Nathan watched his face move—jaw first, then the muscle under the eye, then nothing, because Ben had gone very still.

When he finished he didn't look up.

"He knew," Ben said.

"He watched us at the store that Christmas. He says so."

"He never said a word to me. Not once. He shook my hand." Ben's voice cracked down the middle. "He shook my hand and asked about my mother and I stood there thinking *he knows, he has to know* and then he just—"

"He was good at that."

"No." Ben looked up then, and his eyes were wet and furious. "No, he wasn't. That's the thing. He wasn't good at it. He was *relieved*. You could see it. He was so tired and so relieved that I existed and he could stop pretending he was going to get better."

Nathan crossed the room. He didn't touch him yet.

"Read the last part," he said.

"I read it."

"Read it again."

Ben did. His thumb moved along the line—*Tell him I said it's fine. Tell him I said go.*—and then he folded the page very carefully along its old creases and put it in his shirt pocket.

"Why did he hide it," he said. "Why not just leave it on the table."

"Because I'd have opened it." Nathan sat down on the edge of the bed. "And if I'd read that while he was alive I'd have made him say it out loud. He couldn't do it out loud. That was the whole—" He stopped. "That was Daniel. He arranged things. He was always arranging things."

"You're angry."

"I don't know what I am." Nathan laughed, once, badly. "That's the honest answer. I've spent two years angry at a dead man for the wrong reasons and now I've got the right ones and it doesn't feel like anything."

Ben came and sat next to him. Their shoulders touched. Neither of them moved away.

"He told you to take me on the trip," Ben said.

"He told me you'd know where to stop."

Ben was quiet for a long moment. Then: "There's a place in Corea. Where the road dead-ends at the water. He took me there once. Before you. Before any of it."

Nathan turned his head.

"There's one in Cutler too," Ben said. "And one past Winter Harbor. Three places. I could get us there in a weekend."

"A weekend."

"Unless you've got something better on your calendar." Ben's mouth tried for a smile and didn't quite make it. "Nate. You've got that meeting in the morning. The Historical Society."

Nathan went cold.

"You knew."

"Meg told me. She's been texting me for two days trying to get you to say it out loud." Ben's hand found Nathan's knee, flat and steady. "You've been walking around with a dead man's archive and a deadline and a letter you wouldn't open, and you've been letting me build shelves with you like none of it was happening."

"I was going to tell you."

"When."

"Saturday." Nathan heard himself and knew how it sounded. "At the shop. The way you asked."

Ben nodded slowly. He looked at the window, at the water, at the light going long across the bay.

"All right," he said. "So here's how it goes. Tomorrow morning, you take the meeting. I'll be down at the counter. Whatever they offer, whatever they want—you don't sign anything. You don't say yes and you don't say no."

"I can't stall a museum."

"You can stall anybody for a weekend." Ben stood up and pulled him up by the wrist. "Saturday, I give you Daniel's letter—the one Arthur found. Sunday, we drive to Corea. That's the order. Not because it's the way he wanted it. Because it's the way I need it."

Nathan looked at the page in Ben's pocket.

"Ben. If that letter's real, Arthur's going to want to know how it exists."

"It's in his hand."

"It's dated fourteen months after he died." Nathan's voice came out quieter than he meant it to. "That's not possible. So either Arthur's wrong about the date, or Daniel wrote it and somebody sat on it for a year, or—"

"Or," Ben said, "there's another letter."

The bell downstairs rang again, twice, sharp and impatient, the way nobody rings it who hasn't been standing there a while.

Ben's eyes went to the stairs.

"It's almost nine," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 65: The Unexpected Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads