Letters from the Coast

Chapter 66: Ben Reads the Letter

Ben opened the letter at the kitchen table, because that was where the light was best and because Nathan had not moved from the doorway since he'd handed it over. Saturday had come the way Saturdays did now—late, gray, smelling of rain on cold shingles—and neither of them had said much since dawn. Nathan had made coffee. Ben had drunk half of it. The letter sat between them on the scarred pine, a single sheet that Daniel had folded twice and sealed with no envelope.

"You're hovering," Ben said without looking up.

"I'm standing."

"You're hovering while standing."

Nathan sat down across from him. Ben's hands were steady in a way that Nathan recognized as effort—the same steadiness Ben had brought to the boat deck the day they scattered the ashes, the same flat calm he wore when the wind was about to change. Ben unfolded the paper. He read it all the way through once without any expression at all, and then he started over at the top and read it slower, and that was when his face broke.

He didn't sob. He just went still in the jaw and the eyes filled, and then two lines of water came down his cheeks and he didn't wipe them away. He kept reading. His thumb moved along the paper like he was following a shoreline.

Nathan didn't ask. He looked at the table, at the ring of old water stain, at his own hands. You did not interrupt a man reading a letter from the dead.

"Okay," Ben said at last. His voice had gone husky. "Okay." He set the letter down flat and pressed both palms on it, as if it might try to get away. Then he laughed, one short, wet, joyless note. "He wrote it to me."

"I know."

"Fourteen months after he died."

"I know that too."

Ben looked up. His eyes were red and he looked, for once, entirely unguarded—younger and older at the same time, like a man who'd taken off a coat he'd been wearing for years. "Nathan. Do you understand what this is?" He lifted one corner of the sheet. "This is him forgiving me. He doesn't say it in those words. He doesn't have to. He says, *Take care of him the way I would if I could.* He knows I'm the one who—he knows. And he still hands me the job." Ben's mouth twisted. "That's absolution, is what that is. He wrote me absolution and then he died again, fourteen months later, in a poet's handwriting."

"That's one reading," Nathan said.

"What's the other?"

"That he had no right."

Ben went quiet.

"You broke my heart," Nathan said. "You know that. It's not a mystery, it's the—it's the whole floor of the thing, everything's built on it." He heard his own voice going flat and businesslike, the way it did when he was about to bleed. "And he—" Nathan lifted his chin toward the letter. "He knew. He knew the whole time. He watched me come apart, he watched me put myself back together wrong, he watched me not date for six years, and at the end of it he sat down with a pen and wrote instructions."

He had not meant to say *instructions*. Ben flinched at the word.

"You don't have to defend him," Nathan said. "That's not why I gave it to you."

"I'm not defending him."

"You are. *Absolution.* That's a big word for a note from a guy who—"

"Who what?" Ben's eyes came up hard. "Who was dying and knew it and didn't tell you? That's the guy. That's the same guy, Nathan, the one who hid a letter in a painting frame and dated it like an Easter egg. You want to talk about manipulation? Fine. But let's talk about the manipulation *and* the rest. You're the one who keeps making me pick."

Nathan felt the heat come up his neck. "I'm not—"

"You are. He's either a saint or a—"

"I never said *saint*."

"You never had to." Ben pushed the letter across the table, one finger on it, like a chess move. "Read the third paragraph. Read it out loud. I want to hear you say it."

Nathan looked down. Daniel's handwriting—still that loose forward-leaning slant, the lowercase *g* that looped like a fishhook—the same hand that had written shopping lists and birthday cards and the *do not open until* instructions on a box of ornaments they'd never gotten to, because he'd died in March and the ornaments were still in the cellar. Nathan read.

"*He'll fight you,*" he read. His own voice came out strange. "*He'll tell you he doesn't need it. He does, and he'll never say so, so you have to be the one who says it first, Ben, every time, and I'm sorry to put that on you because I know what it costs. I know because I did it for eleven years. The first time he says yes, that's the yes.*"

He stopped.

"The first time he says yes," Ben repeated, quiet. "That's the yes."

Nathan sat with that. Somewhere past the back wall, the rain ticked on the café's new planks—Daniel's planks, cut and stacked and now holding up the future. Nathan had spent the whole week laying shelves on those boards. He hadn't once thought of it as Daniel's hands under his own. He thought of it now.

"So he knew," Nathan said finally. "He knew what he was doing."

"He was dying. He was—shit, Nathan. He was *dying*. He didn't tell you. That's the cruelest thing anybody ever did to you and I'm not going to pretend it wasn't. He wrote you a goodbye in a box of Christmas ornaments and made you find it yourself, three days after." Ben's voice cracked. He stopped. Swallowed. "But he also—look at it. Look at what he *wrote.* He wrote you a man. He spent his last coherent month trying to make sure you wouldn't be alone. That's not control. That's not even love, that's—that's a guy who ran out of time and spent the last of his strength on a stupid, arrogant, doomed plan." Ben's eyes were wet again. "He just wanted you looked after."

"And he picked you."

"He picked me."

"After what you did."

"After what I did." Ben's mouth was unsteady now, and he made no effort to steady it. "Which is either the most generous thing anybody's ever done for me, or the most stupid. And I don't think Daniel was stupid."

Nathan looked back down at the letter. *The first time he says yes, that's the yes.* Daniel, who knew the difference between a no and a maybe and a person saying yes with his whole body and then taking it back in the morning. Daniel, who had watched Nathan do exactly that for the two years Ben was in the picture and then left, and who had said nothing, not one word, the whole time. Nathan had always read that silence as patience. Generosity. Now he wasn't sure. Silence was not the same as permission. Silence could be a man waiting at the mouth of a trap, holding the door.

"He let it happen," Nathan said.

"He let *what* happen?"

"You. Me. All the—the year of it." He didn't have the words for it. The furtive years. The coffee at odd hours, the long walks, the thing Ben had known about and Nathan had refused to name, and Daniel had known too, Nathan was nearly sure of it, there had been that night in the kitchen with the two of them and the wine and something Daniel had said and then unsaid. He'd buried it because it didn't fit the story he needed. "He knew. He never asked. He just—waited. Maybe he thought if he waited long enough, I'd choose."

"Maybe he thought he'd die before he had to know."

Nathan looked up. Ben's face was very steady now, in the way that meant he'd decided something.

"I don't know what he thought," Ben said. "I don't get to. Nobody gets to. He's dead, Nathan. He's been dead for fourteen months and one month, and the letter doesn't make him alive again and it doesn't make him the villain either. It makes him *a man* who wrote a thing." He folded the sheet, carefully, in threes. "He wanted us together. I'm not going to pretend I don't want it too. But if I take this letter as a *permission slip*—" he shook his head— "then I'm doing the same thing he did. I'm taking a dead man's words and using them to get what I want. I won't do that to you."

The kitchen clock ticked. Rain on the roof. Downstairs, one of the new café shelves settled into the wall with a small wooden groan, as if the old planks were agreeing.

Nathan reached across the table. He didn't take Ben's hand. He put his fingers on the folded letter, and Ben didn't move his hand away, and they sat like that—four hands stacked on one sheet of paper—for a long moment.

"I need to apologize to you," Nathan said.

Ben's eyes flickered. "For what?"

"For the years of blame. For putting you in a box labeled *the one who left* and never letting you out of it, even when you came back and stayed and—" He heard his voice going, and pushed on. "I've been walking around carrying that box like it was the only thing I had left. It wasn't fair. You did what you did, and I did what I did, and I've been making you pay for both of us."

Ben didn't answer. His jaw worked.

"And I'm sorry I lied about Claire," Nathan said. "And I'm sorry I didn't tell you about Vance. I've been running a protection racket on myself for so long I forgot who the protection was for."

"Okay," Ben said. He sounded hoarse. "Okay." Then: "I left."

"I know."

"I left *you.* And I have never—"

"I know," Nathan said. "Say it Saturday. Say it to me properly, at the lighthouse. Say it where it started."

Ben looked at him.

"Portland Head Light," Nathan said. "Before the coast trip. Before the Historical Society decides anything. We drive down tomorrow and we stand on that rock and you tell me everything you should've told me six years ago, and I'll tell you the same, and then—" He breathed. "Then we decide if the letter was permission or just paper."

Ben unfolded the letter one more time—just the top corner, just enough to see the date written there in Daniel's hand—and stared at it. Then he looked up, and his face was doing something Nathan hadn't seen on it since the boat, something open and unguarded and only a little bit afraid.

"Nine a.m. tomorrow?" he said.

"Nine a.m.," Nathan said. "Which is—" He glanced at the clock. "Which is in fourteen hours."

The bell over the shop door rang. Both of them flinched—the impatient ring, twice, the way Andrew Vance had rung it. Nathan looked at the stairs. Ben looked at Nathan.

"I didn't tell him anything about the trip," Nathan said.

"I know," Ben said. "You told him to meet you at nine."

"I told him—" Nathan stopped. He had told Vance nine a.m. Monday, hadn't he? Or had he? He'd said something. He'd been standing in the alcove with the pry bar in his hand and Meg had been there and his phone had buzzed and he hadn't even looked up.

The bell rang a third time. Then a voice came up the stairwell, cheerful and unmistakable.

"Nathan? It's Andrew. Your email said *tomorrow at nine*, and I have to say—I'm early. Can I come up?"

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 66: Ben Reads the Letter · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads