The lighthouse keeper's museum didn't open until ten, but the tower gate was already unlatched when they pulled into the empty lot at seven-forty. Ben killed the engine and they sat a moment, listening to the Atlantic throw itself at the rocks below.
"You didn't sleep," Ben said.
"Not much." Nathan got out.
The wind came off the water cold and steady, bending the grass flat on the hill. Above them the tower stood white against a sky with no color in it yet, the way Daniel used to say Maine looked before it decided what kind of day it was going to be. Nathan had been here maybe a dozen times. He had never once climbed it.
The stairs spiraled tight, iron railing worn smooth and cold, and their footsteps went up and up in a hollow two-part rhythm. Ben counted off the landings under his breath. At the top Nathan pushed the hatch and came out into the wind, and the whole world opened.
Cape Elizabeth lay off to the south, Portland's skyline small and gray on its neck of land. To the north the coast ran away in headlands, one after another after another, all the way toward places with names Nathan had been saying to himself for a month — Corea, Cutler, Winter Harbor. A gull hung level with the gallery and didn't flap.
"Fourteen months," Nathan said. His voice came out thin in the wind.
"What?"
"That letter was written fourteen months after he died. On paper that didn't exist until 2019." Nathan gripped the rail. "That's what Vance said. Which means Daniel didn't write it."
"You don't know that. Somebody could've—"
"Somebody did. The question is who, and why they wanted me to think it was him." Nathan watched the gull slide sideways on the wind. "I've spent a night wondering if I care."
Ben leaned his forearms on the rail next to him. He didn't say anything. That was something Nathan had forgotten about him in the years when he was busy remembering everything else — Ben knew when to keep his mouth shut.
"Daniel was sick for two years," Nathan said. "Toward the end he got into the habit of writing things down. Instructions. Where the extra fuses were. That the gutters needed doing in October. He wrote me a grocery list three weeks before he died and I found it after, in the truck, and I sat in the driveway and cried over a grocery list." He looked out at the water. "So when a letter turns up with his handwriting on it, telling me to stop walling myself off and go see the coast—" He shook his head. "I wanted it. That's the problem. I wanted it so bad I didn't ask a single question."
"You asked plenty of questions. You asked me."
"I asked you whether you'd drive. That's not a question, that's a dare." Nathan turned around and put his back to the rail. "Here's what I've got. Either Daniel wrote it and left it somewhere, and somebody found it and copied it onto new paper to protect it or sell it or God knows what. Or Daniel never wrote it and somebody knew enough about him to sound like him. Either way it went through Arthur Holden, because everything about Daniel's papers went through Arthur Holden, and either way I've been carrying a dead man's instructions around like they were orders."
"Until this morning."
Nathan breathed out. "Until this morning."
Below them a car pulled into the lot and a woman got out with two kids and a thermos, headed for the museum. Ordinary morning. Ordinary people.
"I'm done with it," Nathan said. "That's what I came up here to say. Not the letters — I'll sign whatever I have to sign, I'll let Vance do his job. But I'm done letting Daniel decide things. He's been dead a year and a half. He doesn't get to keep steering the boat."
Ben straightened up off the rail, careful, as though the tower might be listening.
"Say the rest," Nathan said. "You've been chewing on something since Wednesday."
Ben laughed once, no humor in it. "Yeah."
"So say it."
Ben took his time. When he spoke he kept his eyes on the coastline instead of Nathan, which was how Nathan knew it was going to be true.
"Daniel's letter asked me to take care of you. Take you on the trip. That's what it said." He paused. "And I read it and I cried like an idiot and I thought: thank God, he's giving me permission. His blessing. Like I needed a dead man to tell me I was allowed to want you."
"You didn't need it."
"I absolutely needed it. I lied to you for six years, Nathan. I let you think—" He stopped, jaw working. "I let you think I didn't want what I wanted, because I was scared of it, and then when it came apart I let you be the one who walked away so I wouldn't have to look like the coward. And then I stood at his funeral and shook your hand like we were acquaintances."
"You apologized for all of that Thursday night."
"I know. I'm not apologizing again, I'm just—" Ben turned and faced him. "I'm not taking the trip because Daniel told me to. I need you to understand that. I'd have come up here on my own. I'd have come up here if there was no letter, no lawyer, no envelope, nothing. I've been trying to find a reason to come back to this town for fourteen years and I finally ran out of ways to avoid it."
The wind pulled at Nathan's jacket. He looked at Ben's face — older than it used to be, weathered, a squint at the corners of his eyes that Nathan remembered from a hundred mornings on a different set of docks. He had spent a long time being angry at that face. It was astonishing how much simpler it was to just look at it.
"So," Ben said. "That's the rest."
"Here's mine." Nathan's heart was going harder than the stairs could account for. "I'm not looking backward anymore. Daniel's dead. The years you and I lost are gone. There's nothing back there I want to go dig up."
"And?"
"And I'm ready to let go of it. All of it. Today. Right here."
Ben waited.
"Which leaves forward," Nathan said. "And I don't know what that is. I don't have a plan. The store's half torn apart, there's a man in my living room who thinks it's Monday, and I've got a coast to drive with somebody who broke my heart when I was thirty-one years old."
"Thirty-two."
"Thirty-two," Nathan said. "So tell me what you've got."
Ben exhaled, long, and something in his shoulders let go. "I've got a ferry run at five in the morning six days a week. I've got a crummy apartment in Rockland. I've got no idea how to be with somebody after this long — I've been alone so long I talk to the boat."
"I talk to the shelves."
"Yeah, well." Ben's mouth twitched. "So maybe we're both insane. But I'm ready to build the thing, Nathan. Not the trip, not the letter, the—" he gestured vaguely at the water, at the coast, at the two of them. "Whatever this is. The actual thing. I want it. I've wanted it a stupid long time."
Somewhere below, one of the kids yelled about a lobster trap.
Nathan stepped in and kissed him.
It was not a movie kiss. It was cold and salty and awkward, both of them in heavy jackets with the wind trying to get between them, and Nathan's nose was running, and Ben made a small startled sound against his mouth before his hand came up to the back of Nathan's neck and stayed there. The tower stood over them. The gulls kept flying. Neither of them cared.
When they broke apart Ben was grinning like a fool. "You know this is the third time I've been up here and the first time I've ever looked at anything except the stairs."
"You're a lighthouse keeper's son. You should be ashamed."
"I'm going to be, later. Right now I'm busy."
They stayed up another twenty minutes, until the museum opened and the first tourists started up the stairs and the privacy ran out. On the way down Ben went first, one hand held back behind him the whole way as though Nathan might need catching, and Nathan didn't correct him, because it turned out he liked it.
In the parking lot, Nathan's phone buzzed in his pocket. Two missed calls, both from the store line, and a text from Meg that just said call me now.
He hit dial. Meg picked up on the first ring.
"Andrew Vance is in the café crying," she said. "He says the Historical Society board voted last night and he wasn't authorized to offer you what he offered you, he's going to get fired, and also — Nathan, you need to sit down — he asked me to ask you what the name Arthur Holden means to you, because he found it on the back of the envelope, and he says it's not a lawyer's name. He says it's the name of the man who bought Daniel's papers three months after the funeral. And Nathan — the buyer's address is the lighthouse."
Nathan looked up at the tower. White, upright, ordinary, with its light still turning slowly against the morning sky.
"Which lighthouse," he said.