Letters from the Coast

Chapter 67: The Apology

The bell over the door was still swinging when Nathan came down the stairs.

Andrew Vance stood just inside the threshold, umbrella dripping onto the mat,already scanning the shop like he was cataloguing it — the sagging poetry shelf, the water stain above the register, the café framing still raw and unfinished past the counter. He was younger than Nathan had pictured. Forty, maybe. Good coat. A leather folio under his arm.

"Mr. Cole." He extended a hand. "I know I'm early. My ferry ran ahead of schedule and I couldn't see the point of cooling my heels in a motel parking lot."

"It's fine." Nathan shook it. Behind him, Ben had come down the stairs and stopped on the last step, jacket still on, keys in his fist.

Vance noticed him. "I'm not interrupting."

"You're not," Nathan said. "This is Ben Ashford. He's—" He hesitated for exactly one beat too long.

"Complicated," Ben said, without edge.

Vance's mouth twitched, but he let it go. He unzipped the folio and set it on the reading table like he was claiming territory. "Then I'll be direct, because I think you've been given the runaround and I don't care for it. Our acquisitions committee voted three weeks ago to make a formal offer on the Rockwell correspondence and the associated ephemera. Your agent has the paperwork. The Monday deadline isn't a threat — it's the committee's budget calendar. If it slips, the funds get reabsorbed and we start over in the spring."

"The Rockwell letters aren't for sale," Nathan said.

"I don't think that's what you mean." Vance's voice stayed pleasant. "I think you mean you don't know yet. Which is why I came here instead of sending a fourth email."

Nathan looked at the folio. At Ben, who hadn't moved off the step. Through the window, the harbor sat gray and flat under a low morning sky.

"I have to be somewhere," Nathan said.

Vance blinked. "I've come from Portland."

"I know. I'm sorry." And he was, a little. "Give me until Monday. That's the deadline, that's what you said. You'll have an answer before then."

"Mr. Cole—"

"Monday." Nathan picked up the folio, closed it, and held it out. "You'll want this. My answer doesn't come with paperwork attached."

Vance took it. For a second he looked like he might argue, and then he looked at the shop again — the raw café framing, the two men standing in it like furniture that hadn't been arranged yet — and something in his face let go.

"Monday," he said. He pulled a card from his coat and set it on the table, weighty and unnecessary. "Nine sharp. Call me, don't email me."

The bell rang him out. Nathan watched the umbrella bob down the hill toward the harbor.

"You told him Monday," Ben said.

"I told him Monday."

"That's not agreeing."

"No." Nathan turned. "It's deciding not to decide today. Which is what I seem to be good at."

Ben came down the last step. "You want to drive?"

They took Ben's truck. Nathan didn't ask why, and Ben didn't offer — he just drove south on 295 with one hand on the wheel, past the outlet malls and the auto body shops and the long gray reach of the Fore River, and Nathan rode with his elbow on the window and didn't fill the silence the way he usually did in cars, because there was nothing to say that wasn't already loaded and pointed at them.

Portland Head Light showed up first as a smudge beyond the trees, then white against the sky, the tower holding its ground at the edge of the point the way it had for two hundred years. Ben parked in the lot past the keeper's house and killed the engine.

It wasn't open yet. The museum gate was chained; a man in a windbreaker was walking the path with a clipboard. But the hill was public ground, and the path down to the rocks was open, and so they walked — past the fence, along the seawall where the spray was coming up in long white ropes, until they found the same bench they'd sat on twelve years ago.

Ben remembered. Nathan could tell by the way he stopped at it, half a step early, hands in his pockets.

"I sat on this bench," Ben said, "and told you I'd been called about a job in Seattle, and I didn't tell you that I'd already said yes."

Nathan sat down. The wood was cold through his jeans.

"I know," he said. "I've known for years. Claire told me, back when she was still talking to Meg. She thought I should know." He looked out at the water instead of at Ben. "And here's the thing. It didn't make any difference to how I felt. Because I wasn't angry about the lie, Ben. I was angry that you left. The lie was just the handle I could grab."

Ben sat down beside him, leaving a few inches of bench between them.

"Both of them are true," he said. "I lied. And I left. I should have told you before I said yes to anything. I should have asked you what you wanted. You'd have said 'go,' and I'd have known you meant it, and it wouldn't have sat in me for twelve years like something I stole."

"You would have gone either way."

"Yeah." Ben's voice wasn't defensive. It was just flat and honest. "I would have. I was twenty-nine and I wanted to see something that wasn't this." He gestured at the water, the light, the gray Atlantic. "But I wanted to come back. That part I never got to say, because I burned the bridge on my way over it."

Nathan rubbed his hands together against the cold. His throat was doing the thing it did. He made himself talk anyway.

"I'm sorry."

Ben looked over.

"Not the reflex apology," Nathan said. "The real one. For years. For the whole first year after Daniel died, I told people about you — I told Meg, I told Claire, once at a dinner party I told a stranger — that you were the reason I stopped trusting people. That the one man I'd loved before Daniel broke something in me, and Daniel was the one who fixed it. I used you as the story." He stopped. Started again. "You weren't a story. You were a person who was twenty-nine and scared and made a bad call, and I turned you into a villain so I wouldn't have to look at what I actually was, which was a man who was terrified of being left and then spent three years refusing to let anyone in far enough to leave."

The wind came off the water and pushed at them.

"I'm sorry," Nathan said again. "That's the whole of it. I blamed you for the thing I was."

Ben was quiet for a long moment. When he spoke, his voice was rough.

"I forgave you before you asked."

"You can't—"

"I can. That's the part you don't get." Ben turned on the bench to face him. "I sat in that support group for a year listening to you talk around Daniel like the man was a saint, and I knew I was the villain in your version, and I stayed. You know why? Because I'd already done the math. Whatever you'd built in your head to survive, it belonged to you. I wasn't going to take it from you on my way back in the door." He let out a breath. "And I lied. So you weren't even wrong."

"I was wrong about the reason."

"Fine. You were wrong about the reason." Ben almost smiled. "I forgave you anyway. I just didn't tell you, because I didn't think you were ready to hear it."

"And now?"

"Now you drove down here with me for no good reason except that we said we would."

Nathan laughed — a short, startled sound, salt on his lips. He hadn't expected to.

They sat with the light. The windbreaker man finished his clipboard walk and drove off. A gull worked the rocks below them, patient and stupid.

"I want to go into the tower," Nathan said.

Ben raised an eyebrow. "It's closed."

"Not today." Nathan stood and offered his hand down, the way Ben had offered his own at the poetry alcove, the way they'd been handing each other things for weeks. "Tomorrow. I looked it up before we left. Keeps open at ten this time of year." He pulled Ben to his feet and didn't let go right away. "I want to stand at the top of the thing I've been staring at from the shore for twelve years. And I want you up there with me."

Ben's hand tightened around his. Water, light, the long gray reach of everything.

"Ten o'clock," Ben said. "Then Saturday's the letter. Then Corea Sunday."

"Or," Nathan said, "we go up the tower tomorrow, and then we drive north and don't stop until the road does."

Ben looked at him for a second, quick and searching, checking whether he meant it.

"Vance gets his answer Monday," Nathan said. "I'll call him from a payphone in Cutler if I have to. But I'm done deciding things from this bench."

He was still holding Ben's hand. He let go, because the wind was cutting and they had a long drive back — and because letting go wasn't the same thing as leaving, and that, finally, was a distinction he could feel in his body instead of only argue about in his head.

They were halfway up the path when Nathan's phone buzzed. He pulled it out, expecting Meg, expecting Claire, half-expecting Vance.

Portland Historical Society. Vance.

He wasn't calling about Monday. He was calling about the envelope — the one Arthur Holden had sent to the estate lawyer, the one that had been dated fourteen months after Daniel died.

"Mr. Cole," Vance said, tinny against the wind. "You should know before Monday. That envelope you gave us to authenticate — the handwriting matches. But the paper doesn't. That stationery was milled in 2019."

Nathan stopped walking. Ahead of him, Ben turned back, frowning.

"Daniel died in 2017," Nathan said.

"Yes," said Vance. "He did."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 67: The Apology · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads