On Thursday I asked him about his hand, and he told me about a fire.
Nothing happened in the eight days between that night and that Thursday. That is not true; things happened, and they were the same thing, eight times over: down at six, the boxes, up at four, and nobody in that house asking me a single question I could answer in a sentence.
I had been in that house twenty-five days by then and had learned the timetable: four o'clock, the door at the top of the stairs, his shoes on the third step and then the fourth, and then his voice saying *Ms. Ellery* in the flat way he said everything, as though my name were a line item he was confirming.
That Thursday he came down with two cups and set one on the corner of my table without asking, and I said, "It's Thursday."
"It is."
"Your hand."
He sat down on the stool on the other side — he had brought a second stool, at some point, without mentioning it — and he said, "In 2011 there was a fire at the Yonkers chapel. The one on Palisade. It started in the embalming room at two in the morning and it went up through the ceiling joists and it took the roof in about forty minutes."
I did not say anything.
"There were eleven in the building," he said. "Nine of them were — they were already dead, Ms. Ellery, that's not a euphemism, that's the inventory. Two of them were staff. I carried a man out of the back room who weighed two hundred and sixty pounds and who was alive and who has sent me a card every Christmas since, and I want you to understand that I am not telling you this to impress you. I'm telling you because it's the only thing in my life that has anything to do with fire."
"Mr. Roarke."
"Yes."
"I asked about your hand."
"I know."
"And you answered a question about fire."
"I did."
"Why?"
He turned the cup a quarter turn and did not drink from it. "Because you asked me a question I've been asked before," he said, "and I've had a long time to work out what to say."
That was the first honest thing he had said to me since the pantry, and it was honest in the way that a locked door is honest: it tells you exactly where it is.
I picked up the cup. I did not drink from it either. We sat there for a while with two full cups between us, and then he said, "You've been sleeping down here."
The archive had a cot in the corner that had been there since the first week, folded, and I had unfolded it on the twenty-fifth and had not folded it back.
"The east wing is cold," I said.
"It's not."
"No."
"I'm not going to ask," he said. "But I'd like you to know that I've noticed, and that I'm not asking, and that the not-asking is a thing I'm doing on purpose."
"Because you already know."
"Because if I ask, you'll tell me something that isn't true, and then we'll both have to live with it." He stood up. "Four o'clock tomorrow."
That was Thursday. The rest of it happened on the second of December, and it began with a thing I had been putting off for a week, which was going up the stairs.
I had never been in his study. I had been in the morning room, the archive, the east corridor, the pantry, and the kitchen, and in twenty-five days I had not once gone up past the second floor, which is a thing I only noticed when I did it.
The study was at the end of the west corridor, above the archive, and the door was open.
He was at the desk with his back half to me, doing something with his left hand that involved a great deal of paper and no writing. When he heard me he stopped and turned and did not look surprised, which I had begun to find more unsettling than surprise.
"You're upstairs."
"I'm upstairs."
He moved a folder off the chair beside the desk, which is a thing people do when they want you to sit and do not want to say so.
I sat. I put the logbook on the desk between us, on the blotter, and opened it to the gutter at page fourteen.
He looked at it for a long time.
"Somebody cut it," I said. "Not tore. Cut. With a blade, close to the gutter, with the book shut, because the facing edges are trimmed too. And before you tell me it doesn't matter, I want you to know that I can read what was on it, because the page that was against it for three years took the pressure, and I've read it."
He looked up.
"Say it," he said.
"*Left brow. Linear. Three centimeters. Not traumatic. Incisional. Sutured and healed. Consistent with prior surgery. Does not match subject photographs. Reported to—*" I stopped. "And then the cut."
The room was quiet. Somewhere below us, in the archive, the dehumidifier kicked on and then off.
"I know there's a page missing," he said.
"I gathered."
"I've known for two years."
I had prepared four sentences for that moment and I did not use any of them.
"How," I said.
"In 2020 the estate was audited. Not for money — for the file. The insurer required a certification that the consultant's records were complete and that the disposition file was available for inspection." He said it without any particular emphasis, the way he said everything. "I signed that certification. To sign it, I counted the pages in that book. There were a hundred and eleven. The index said a hundred and twelve."
"Who else counted?"
"Vance."
"And?"
"Vance said the index was wrong." He turned his hand over on the desk, palm up, and looked at it. "Vance is very good at saying a thing in a way that makes you feel foolish for having asked. I let it go."
"Why."
"Because in 2020 I had a great deal to let go of," he said, "and I had gotten into the habit."
I stood up. I did not mean to; my legs did it.
"You let it go," I said. "You counted the pages, you found one missing, and you let it go. And then in November somebody put a bottle of my siccative in a box and a codicil on a will, and you came down my stairs at two in the morning and told me you wanted a witness."
"That's not—"
"Don't." I put my hand flat on the logbook. "Don't tell me what it isn't. Tell me who in this house had a reason to take a page out of my book."
He was silent for a moment. Then he said the sentence I would think about for the rest of that winter.
"Everyone in this house had a reason," he said. "That's the trouble with this house. It's not that one person is guilty. It's that everybody is."
I went back down.
I sat at my table with the lamp on and did the thing I should have done in the first week, which was to take the engagement letter out of the consultant box and read the second page.
The engagement letter was two pages. The first page was the terms: fee, scope, confidentiality, the clause-six language I had written myself. The second page was signatures.
Mine, at the bottom left, in the good pen, twenty-eight years old and pleased with itself.
And at the bottom right, where the client signs, a signature I had seen a hundred times in the last three weeks, on reports and certifications and the corner of a marriage license.
*Hollis Vance, for the Estate of Theodore J. Roarke.*
I sat there with it for a while.
Then I turned back to the logbook and looked at the six words in raking light again, and I understood that I had been reading them wrong for a week.
*Reported to—*
I had assumed it meant the medical examiner. That is what a person in my profession writes: *reported to the ME's office, 11/09, 4:20 p.m.* But if I had reported it to the medical examiner, I would have written *reported to the office*, and I would have written a time, and I would have written a name, because that is how I write.
I had written *Reported to—* and then a space, and then, at the start of the next line, the blade.
I had reported it to the person who had hired me.
I had reported it to Vance.
And three days later Vance's office had come to my studio with a page that answered it.
I put both hands flat on the table and breathed for a moment.
Then I picked up the logbook, and the engagement letter, and I went back up the stairs, because I had something to say to Julian Roarke and I was going to say it while it was hot in my mouth.
The study door was open. The desk lamp was on. He was not there.
I stood in the doorway with the papers in my hand and waited, and while I waited I looked at the desk, because I am a person who looks at desks.
There was a folder on the left side, under the brass lamp, half out from under a tray. It was the kind the estate used: buff, with a printed tab, and a name typed on the tab.
The name was mine.
The year under it was 2018.
I did not touch it. I want to be clear about that, because I have thought about it since, and the truth is that I did not touch it out of something closer to cowardice than ethics.
But it was half out from under the tray and the light was on it, and there was a photograph clipped to the front, and the photograph was of a door.
A steel door, with a wire-glass window, and a sign beside it that said *ELLERY — RESTORATIVE — BY APPOINTMENT*, and a man in a raincoat standing on the sidewalk across the street with his hands in his pockets, photographed from behind, at a distance, by somebody who did not want to be seen doing it.
The date on the tab was two months before Theodore Roarke died.
I was not working for this family in 2018. I had never heard the name Roarke in 2018. In 2018 I was twenty-seven years old and gluing split panels in a basement in Queens and paying eleven hundred dollars a month for the privilege.
Somebody had been watching my door two months before there was anything to watch.