Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 12: Three Pieces of Paper

I did not confront him about the folder.

I want to record why, because it was not caution. It was that I had spent a month being the person who was told things, and I had begun to suspect that the way out of that was not to ask better questions but to build something he could not talk his way around.

So on the fifth of December I did what I am actually good at.

I built it on the wall.

The archive had a corkboard nobody used, four feet by three, and I cleared it and pinned up everything I had, and then I stood back and looked at it the way I look at a damaged panel before I touch it: not at the damage, at the structure underneath.

Six things went up.

The engagement letter, both pages. A photograph of the empty folder with the staples and the torn paper caught in them. The consultant box invoice from 2019, which had a date and a time on it. My own invoice to the estate for the same week. A certified abstract of the cremation permit, which had come back from White Plains on the second of December in a window envelope. And a single index card on which I had written, in block capitals, the number that was on the tab of the empty folder.

*2019-1146.*

Then I stood in front of it with a marker and said, out loud, in an empty basement, "All right. What are you."

Here is what I had, and I want to set it out plainly, because everything that happened afterward happened because of these four facts and no others.

**One.** Theodore Roarke's remains were cremated on the eighth of November, 2019. The certified abstract said so, and it was signed by the county and stamped, and a certified abstract is not a thing you argue with in a basement; you argue with it in a courtroom, and you lose.

**Two.** There was no body. Cremation is not a state of affairs; it is an act with a date and an operator and a permit. When the permit is issued and the retort is fired, the remains stop being evidence and become an urn. Every question I could ask about that man's face — bone, teeth, DNA, the shape of the orbital ridge I had spent nine hours rebuilding — was now a question about paper.

**Three.** The paper that answered those questions had been in a folder in this basement, and the folder was empty, and the staples were still there, and the staples had torn the corner off something when the something was pulled out in a hurry.

**Four.** And the cremation permit, which I had requested from the court on the twenty-first of November and which had arrived on the second of December, cited, in the box marked *DISPOSITION AUTHORITY*, a form number.

*2019-1147.*

I stood there and looked at the index card for a long time.

The tab on the folder said 1146. The permit said 1147.

Two numbers in a series, one digit apart.

I sat down on the stool and put my hands around the back of my neck and did the arithmetic four different ways, and it came out the same every time, and the same every time was this:

There had been two disposition forms.

One of them was for Theodore Roarke, and it had gone to the county, and the county had issued a permit against it, and the permit had a number.

The other one was in the folder in this basement, in a series that ran one digit behind, and it was for somebody else.

And somebody had come down here in the last three years and taken the second one out and left the folder and the staples, and had not taken the first one, because the first one was in a government vault and could not be taken.

I worked until two in the morning and then I did something I had not done in a month, which was to go upstairs and knock on a door.

He opened it in a shirt with the collar undone and no shoes, and I had the sudden, unwelcome thought that he had been awake, and that he had been awake in the specific way a person is awake when they are waiting for a sound.

"Come down," I said. "I need you to look at a wall."

He looked at the papers in my hand.

"All right," he said.

He stood in front of the corkboard for six minutes. I timed it. He did not ask a single question, which I found either impressive or frightening and had not yet decided which.

At the end he said, "Say it."

"The abstract confirms cremation on the eighth. The permit cites disposition authority 1147. The folder in this basement is tabbed 1146 and is empty." I tapped the index card. "One of those forms was for your brother. The other one was for somebody else. And the somebody else's form was in my archive."

"Not your archive."

"It was in the box with my name on it, with my engagement letter and my log and my invoices. Somebody put my working papers in with an estate file and sealed it. That is not an accident. That is filing."

He turned away from the board and walked to the end of the room and back, which is a thing he did, I had noticed, when he was doing arithmetic he did not want to do out loud.

"The number on the abstract," he said. "Can you get the original permit? Not the abstract. The permit."

"The abstract is what the court releases."

"The abstract is what the court releases to *you*." He looked at me. "The original is in the county clerk's file, and the file is open to a party of record, and you are not a party. You're a consultant."

"Then I'll become a party."

"You can't. You're married to one."

I opened my mouth and closed it.

"Say that again," I said.

"You're married to a party of record." He said it flatly. "Which means everything you find is something I've found, and everything you file is something I've filed, and the moment this becomes a lawsuit instead of an examination, you stop being an examiner and become the wife of the defendant's brother."

I sat down on the stool. The corkboard was behind me and I could feel it there, the way you feel a wall.

"That's why the codicil was written," I said slowly. "Not to keep me out of the archive."

"No."

"It was to make sure that whatever I found, I found it as family."

"Yes."

"Whose idea was that?"

He did not answer, and the not-answering had a shape to it that I had learned to read.

"Mr. Roarke."

"It was mine," he said.

The dehumidifier kicked on. I let it run.

"You told me in the pantry that you didn't write the codicil."

"I told you I didn't ask Vance to amend the will. That was true." He said it without flinching. "The codicil was drafted in September, before the petition. It was drafted because I asked for a mechanism that would let a non-family expert work inside this house without the family being able to shut her out. Vance wrote it the other way around. He wrote it so that the only way in was through the family."

"You didn't read it."

"I read it. I read it the way a man reads a contract he asked for — for the clause he wanted, and not for the clause he didn't." He looked at the corkboard. "It's the same mistake you made with clause six, Ms. Ellery. Somebody handed you a sentence that did exactly what you wanted, and you stopped reading at the end of it."

That landed where he meant it to land.

I stood up, and picked up the marker, and turned back to the wall, because it was easier to look at the wall.

"Three pieces of paper," I said. "That's all this is. The permit, the disposition, the transport record. Everything anybody could ever prove about that man is on three pieces of paper, and two of them are missing and one of them is in a vault." I put the cap back on the marker. "There's no body. There's only paper."

He was quiet for a moment.

"Then we should find out who's been writing on it," he said.

I stood in front of the corkboard at four in the morning with the lamp off and the corridor light coming down the stairs, and I made a list of the three documents and what each one would cost me to get.

The cremation permit. The abstract was in my hand. The original was in a vault, behind a party of record I could not become, and the only way to it was a court order I could not ask for without becoming a party. **Cost: time. Maybe eleven months.**

The transport record. It came from the funeral home, and the funeral home was a Roarke subsidiary, and the transfer had a driver, and the driver had a log, and the log had a name. A driver is not a party to anything. A driver is a man with a route sheet who goes home at six. **Cost: a conversation. Maybe two.**

The disposition form. It was in the folder with the torn staples, and the folder was mine, and the form had my signature on the third line. If I found it, I would find out what I had actually signed — and I would find out in front of a court, because the moment I produced it, it stopped being a private thing.

**Cost: me.**

I looked at the three of them for a long time.

Then I put my finger on the transport record, and I wrote in my log, at 4:12 in the morning, in the plainest language I could manage:

*Decision. Transport first. It is the only one that can be obtained without a court, without a husband, and without my own name on it.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 12: Three Pieces of Paper · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads