Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 21: The Front Desk

The report was due on the sixth, and the sixth was a Friday, and I wrote it in the morning at the long table in the archive with the lamp on and the pipes knocking in the wall behind me.

The photograph was in the drawer with the Pilny statement. There was a woman in the corner of it holding a stemmed glass that matched the glass in Lena Kessler's hand, and I had not looked at the photograph since Christmas Eve, because a question I cannot answer is a thing I put down, and I had a report to write.

It ran to a page and a half. Every sentence was true.

That is the whole trick of a report and nobody teaches it to you. You do not lie. You write a true sentence, put a full stop at the end of it, and let the man reading it fill the space after the full stop with the assumption that you stopped because there was nothing else.

I wrote that the folder tabbed 2019-1146 had held nothing for three years, that page fourteen of my log had been cut out with a knife and that I had recovered six characters from the pressure beneath, and that the dental conclusion had been typed four weeks before the death it described. I wrote out the three documents and the four dates on them, and the route sheet for the eighth of November 2019 with a struck-out name and the initials R.M. beside the strike.

I did not write about the safe. I did not write about the watch, or the boarding pass, or the transcript a woman had handed me in a corridor on Christmas Eve, or the photograph I had printed off a microfilm machine for a dollar.

I signed it at nine and carried it up to the morning room and put it in front of him.

He read it twice, once fast and once with one finger moving down the margin, stopping at the numbers.

"This is a good report," he said.

"It's accurate."

"Those aren't the same thing." He turned to the second page and read to the bottom. "You've written a report about paper. There isn't a body in it anywhere."

"There isn't a body anywhere," I said. "That's the finding."

He looked up at me then, and something happened in his face that I had not seen before, which was nothing at all, carefully.

"Is there anything you left out," he said, "that would change what this says."

It was the right question, asked by the right man, at the only hour in eight weeks when I might have answered it.

"No," I said.

He put his thumb on the pad — the right thumb, the one part of that hand that still did what it was told — and pressed it onto the line, and then he laid the pen down parallel to the edge of the page, which is what he did instead of signing.

"All right," he said. "It goes by messenger at four."

I had carried it for thirteen days and had never once looked at the caption as a document.

*At the annual service dinner of the Roarke chapel, Brooklyn. Among those present: T. Roarke; Mrs. A. Loesser; P. Okonjo; the Rev. J. Slade; Miss L. Kessler; M. Della Rosa; and staff.*

The caption names six people and then says *and staff*. It does not name the woman in dark green at the edge of the frame. A paper writes a caption from a list the host supplies, and somebody supplied that list and left her off it.

I had read *the Roarke chapel* the way you read a name on a hospital wing. A rich man's name on a building he had paid for.

Then I took Pilny's statement out of the drawer and put it beside the print, and read the second line of it, which I had read forty times:

*05:12 — DELIVERY — 1144 SCHERMERHORN — 1 UNIT — SEALED, INTACT.*

I got the telephone book from the pantry shelf and dialled the number for a funeral home on Schermerhorn Street, and a man answered on the fourth ring and said, "Roarke Chapel, good morning."

I asked him for the address.

"One fourteen four Schermerhorn," he said. "Between Bond and Nevins. Do you need directions?"

I said no.

The building into which the case had been driven at five twelve in the morning was the building where Lena Kessler worked the night desk.

There were three doors.

I could take the print up to my husband, who had just asked me whether I had left anything out. I could put it in a drawer and say nothing, which was what I had done in December and which had worked, in the sense that a splinter works. Or I could call the one man in this story who had no reason to lie to me.

I called Owen.

He answered on the third ring with a saw going behind him.

"It's the sixth," he said.

"I know."

"You didn't call me on the first."

"No."

"All right." The saw stopped. "Hold on." A door. Then quiet. "I didn't file."

"Why not."

"Because I went to the clerk on the second and asked what happens if I name you as a respondent, and she was decent about it, she was nicer than she had to be, and she explained it to me twice. And then I sat in the truck in the lot for an hour with the papers on the seat and I drove home." A pause. "They're still on the seat. Every time I get in the truck I move them to the other side."

"Mr. Kessler."

"I'm not going to file. That doesn't mean you don't owe me. It means I took the date off it. Which is worse for you, and I know it's worse for you, and I'm not sorry."

"Did Lena ever talk about where she worked."

"She talked about it constantly. It was the first job she ever had that paid her enough to be boring about."

"Did she say who she worked for."

"She said *the family*." He said it flatly, like quoting. "She never said a name. I asked her once if it was a mob thing and she laughed at me for a week."

"And how did she get it."

He was quiet for a moment.

"She was working the counter at a card shop on Fulton. She was eighteen. A woman came in and asked for her by name, and Lena said, how do you know my name, and the woman said, I've been told you're good with people." A pause. "Two weeks later she had a job on Schermerhorn with three more dollars an hour and a list of rules. Don't talk about the residents. Don't use the front door. Sign the book every time you come in."

"Rules from who."

"From the woman." A pause. "She was eighteen, Ms. Ellery. She thought it was because she was good with people."

I stood in the pantry with the phone against my ear and the ring loose on my finger.

"Thank you," I said.

"For what."

"For answering the question I asked."

I crossed the bridge at two in the afternoon.

Under the order I am not permitted to be outside Westchester County for more than twenty-four hours without forty-eight hours' written notice, and I did the arithmetic on the approach ramp the way I do everything, in numbers: two hours there, four hours inside, two hours back, well inside the limit. A woman who has to calculate that before she can go and look at a building is a woman who has already been taught what she is.

Schermerhorn in January was a street of granite and roll-down gates, and the chapel was a four-story brownstone with *ROARKE* cut into the stone over the entrance in letters a foot high, weathered at the top from a hundred and ten winters of rain.

The front of a funeral home is not for the dead. The dead come in at the back, on a ramp, at four in the morning. The front is for the living, and it is built to say one thing: *this will be orderly*.

A man came to the door before I knocked. He was about sixty, in a good gray suit, with the particular soft-footedness of a man who has spent his life in carpeted rooms.

"We're not taking callers today," he said.

"I'm not a caller." I gave him my name. "I'm the consultant on the estate file for Theodore Roarke. I'd like to see the staff time records for November 2019."

He looked at me, and then at my hand on the rail, where the ring knocked once against the brass.

"Ms. Ellery," he said. "You're not the consultant on anything. I read the trade circulars. Your license is suspended."

The cold came up through my shoes.

He was working from a circular that had been printed in 2020 and never once corrected, and I did not put him right, because a man who has just been corrected becomes careful, and I needed him careless.

"Then I'm a woman who did the face," I said, "and I'd like to see the staff time records for November 2019."

He held the door.

The people at the front desk are not instructed to lie. They are instructed to be correct, and correctness does most of the work, and when it doesn't, they are instructed to be correct more slowly, until you go away.

I stood on that step for a length of time I could not have told you, and a thing happened in his face that I have seen maybe four times in my trade: a man deciding to put something down.

"The time clock's in the basement," he said. "The woman who did payroll never threw anything out and she died in 2021, so nobody's been able to throw anything out since. Light switch is a pull chain."

The cards were in shoeboxes on a steel shelf, in year order, with rubber bands that had gone slack.

*2019.* Just over two hundred cards. I went through them the way I go through a case: everything out, everything ordered, nothing back in the box until I am finished.

*KESSLER, L.*, in blue ballpoint, in a hand that leaned forward and had a loop on the L she had never grown out of.

The card was the old buff kind, thirty rows, two punches a day. One of her seven-day weeks was the second week of October 2018.

The seventh of November 2019 was a Thursday. She had come in at 15:58 and she had gone out at 23:40.

The card after hers on the rack was somebody else's, and it had gone in at 06:12 the next morning.

I sat on an upturned crate with the card in both hands.

At 06:12 on the eighth of November 2019 a woman I will never meet put her card in that clock and started her shift in a building into which a sealed case had been delivered one hour earlier. She made the first pot of coffee and put out the day book and answered the telephone, and she did not know, and there was no reason she should have.

I had been looking for the wrong door for two months.

I had been looking for a conspiracy in a house in the country, among people who wore good shoes and spoke in clauses.

The family did not own a funeral home. The family owned a share of a company that owned two hundred of them.

And the woman my husband's brother killed had been working the night desk in one of them, for three more dollars an hour, because a woman came into a card shop and asked for her by name.

I put the card back in the shoebox in its place and did not take it, and went up the basement stairs and out through the front door, which is not where the dead come in.

The man in the gray suit was at the desk with a book.

"Did you find what you wanted," he said.

"I found a time."

"That's usually what's in them." He turned a page. "Ms. Ellery. The payroll woman kept a week sheet in the front of each year. If she was short a body she wrote it in the margin." He did not look up. "You'll want 2019."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 21: The Front Desk · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads