I asked him on the eighteenth of March, at four in the afternoon, in the study, with the rain coming off the roof onto the porch in a way that made the room sound like it had a clock in it.
I had the visitors' book copy in my hand. One photocopy of one page, carried since October, and on the ninth of October 2019 there are two lines on it. *J. Roarke.* And under it, *Nadia Reyes*, in a hand that leaned forward.
I put it in front of him.
"Tell me about your hand," I said.
He looked at the page, then at me.
"A car door," he said. "In November. It was wet and it swung back."
"On the ninth of October your hand was already wrapped," I said. "You were in a dental laboratory in Yonkers and you signed nothing and a woman wrote your name in a book for you, and the man who did the bitewings wrote the word *injury* on his own note and dated it. That was four weeks before the car door."
"I have had that page for five months," I said. "I have been waiting for a story I could believe, and you have told me the same one three times, and it has a date in it that anybody can check."
He sat back.
"All right," he said.
"I was told at nine o'clock at night," he said. "On the seventh. I was in the city and I came out at half past nine and I was told on the telephone, and I drove up, and I was in that building at eleven."
"Which building."
"The facility. In White Plains." He looked at the window. "There was a man at the loading door and a case on the floor of the corridor, and I was told what the arrangement was, and what it would cost, and what it would be worth to everybody in this family for the rest of their lives, and I was asked whether I understood, and I said all right."
He said the two words without any expression at all.
"I've said it every day since," he said.
"What arrangement."
"That the man in the case would go into the county's paper as my brother, and be burned as my brother, and that a face would be made so the family could look at it and be satisfied, and that everybody would then go home and be quiet for the rest of their lives."
I sat down in the other chair, slowly, because my legs had done something.
"And you knew it wasn't him."
"I knew it wasn't him."
"How."
"I don't know." He said it before I had finished the question. "I looked at the case and I knew. You would want a measurement and I don't have one."
He was right about what I would want.
"They brought the van round at four," he said. "A box van with two doors on the back and a bar across them and a ramp that pulls out. The man with the van did the ramp. There was a second man with the paperwork who was not going to touch it."
"Go on."
"I took the head end."
"I put my hands under the case at the head end and the man with the van took the foot, and we walked it up the ramp. The case was heavier than it looks, because a body in a bag in a case is a worse load than a body in a box. We got it to the top and the man went to swing the door and the ramp was wet and his foot went and the whole thing came back."
"And you put your hand out."
"I put my right hand out." He looked at it, on the arm of the chair, the three fingers drawn back. "You don't decide to. It's there before you decide. The door came back on the edge of the case and the case came down on the door and my hand was in the door."
"It took them nine seconds to get it off me," he said. "I counted. I have counted a great many things since, and that is the only count I am sure of."
"And then?"
"And then I picked it up again."
I had built a whole architecture out of that hand, and I had been counting on it the way you count on a wall.
"Why didn't you put him down?"
He did not answer for a long time. The rain came harder and the gutter over the porch began to run.
"Because if I put him down," he said, "then I had to stand in that corridor and decide what he was. And as long as I was holding him he was a case with a man in it, and I was a man carrying a case, and there was nothing to decide." His voice did something on the last word and he stopped and started again. "I have not been able to say that out loud. Not to her. Not to anybody. I have said *all right* to a great many people in three years and never that."
And then he cried.
I had spent four months building a picture of him out of paper, and the picture was wrong in the way all such pictures are wrong.
He did not put his face in his hands. He sat upright with his ruined hand on the arm of the chair and his face came apart, quietly, without any noise, and the tears went down the sides of his nose and onto his collar, and he did not look away from me, and it was the first time in four months that I had seen him not doing something with his face.
It was not for me. A woman can be vain about a thing like that. He was crying because he had held a case at the head end and had known, and walked it up a ramp anyway, and said *all right*.
I went round the desk and put my hand on his shoulder, which is the only thing I could think of that was not an apology.
He put his good hand over mine and held it there for about a minute, and then he stopped the way men stop, all at once, with a breath.
"I'm sorry," he said.
"Don't."
"I'm not sorry for this." He wiped his face with the back of his left hand. "I'm sorry you had to be the person in the room. You have been in the room for everything."
He got up after a while and went to the window.
"There's something else," he said. "You've had it in your teeth since the seventh of February and you haven't asked."
"The camera," I said.
"You think I told them about the camera."
"I think somebody described that room to a man with a brick," I said, "and four people had been in it, and one was me, and one was a super who takes fifty dollars, and one had a key."
"I called my mother on the twenty-seventh of January," he said. "At one in the morning. It took forty seconds. I told her one thing, and the one thing was that you had said the word Lisbon at my desk.
"On the seventh of February I went to your shop at three in the morning because I wanted to see what you had. I didn't know what I was looking for. I found a camera — above the cabinet, with a lens on it and a little red light.
"That afternoon I went to her and asked her to stop. All of it. And I told her there was a camera and that I was on it, and that if anything happened to you I would go to the county myself and say what I did in that corridor."
He turned round.
"She is sixty-three years old and I have known her thirty-eight years," he said. "I knew what I was doing when I said it. I did it because I had decided that week to stop being the man who says all right."
"And that evening I went back and took it off the bracket and put it in my pocket and drove into the city and put it in the river." He looked at me. "Because I had told her it existed. And a thing I have told my mother exists is a thing that will be found."
"So the shop," I said.
"The shop was the answer," he said. "I asked her to stop and that was the answer, and it came that night. The two men who did it said my name to a man in a parking lot in Astoria first, and then broke two of his ribs. The ribs were the polite version."
"You didn't tell them about the camera."
"I told my mother there was one." He said it flatly. "That is not the same as telling them and not the same as not telling them, and I have had six weeks to work out where it sits and I can't. So I am giving it to you the way it happened."
"I thought you'd sold me," I said.
"I know."
"I have been living in your house for six weeks with that in my mouth."
"I know that too." He came back and sat down. "You've been very polite."
"I've worn his watch the whole time," he said.
I looked up.
"Since the eighth," he said. "I put it on in a hotel room in Lisbon and I have not taken it off. Not in three years." He turned his wrist over. There was nothing on it. "It's upstairs. In your room. I left it on your table in January because I thought you should have something of his, and then I couldn't —" He stopped. "So it has been there for two months and I have been going up at night and looking at it, which is a thing I would rather you had not known."
I went up two flights and came back down with it. I put it on the desk under the lamp and got the small calipers out of the drawer where the dividers live, and I did the thing I do, which is not to have a feeling first.
Case, thirty-one millimeters. Across the bezel, thirty-two with the crown.
A man's dress watch of that period is thirty-six to forty. I know that because I have measured stranger things for a family who wanted a hand in a photograph.
Thirty-one millimeters is a woman's watch.
And in a safe on the third floor of that house there is another watch, and I have held it twice. It has a crystal broken in a starburst from the eleven and it stopped at the same minute as this one, and I did not measure it, because you do not measure a watch.
I could not measure it now. But I have held both in the same hand, four months apart.
The watch in the safe is bigger than the watch on the desk.
The watch in the safe is a man's watch.
He had been wearing the other one for three years, and calling it his brother's, and it is not his brother's, and it is not a man's watch at all.
I put the calipers down very carefully, the way you put down a blade.
"Ms. Ellery," he said.
I stood at that desk in the gray light with a woman's watch in front of me and a man behind me who had walked a case up a ramp, and I did not turn round, and I did not tell him what I had found, and I have not told him since.