Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 34: Since March

The envelope came on the eleventh of March at twenty past nine in the morning, by hand, from a man in a car who did not get out.

It was a notice of motion. Fourteen pages, a cover sheet, a certificate of service, and a memorandum of law with the citations in the footnotes where they keep them when they do not want a judge to read them.

*THE ESTATE OF THEODORE J. ROARKE moves this Court for an order striking the Objection and Request for Instruction filed herein by Cora Ellery on the twenty-second of December, 2022, and for such other and further relief as the Court deems just.*

I read it standing in the hall with my coat still on.

Paragraph four was the argument. It was three sentences long and it was the best piece of writing I have seen in this entire business, and it was written by a woman in gray who does not enjoy being clever.

*The Objector's authority to appear in this proceeding derives solely from her engagement by the Estate. That engagement is subject to the terms of the agreement of November 19, 2022, annexed hereto as Exhibit C. Paragraph Ten of that agreement provides that the interpretation of the agreement is vested in the client. The client has determined that the Objector's filing exceeds the scope of her engagement. The Objector's filing is therefore unauthorized.*

I sat down on the third step of the back stairs and read it again.

Then I went down to the archive and got the agreement out of the box where I keep the things I have signed, and I read paragraph ten for the first time in four months.

*This agreement shall be interpreted by the Client, whose determination shall be final.*

Nine paragraphs I had dictated in that room in November, standing up, with my coat on. I had written the ninth one myself in ink because it was mine and because I wanted it in my hand: *You don't sign for me. Not ever.*

I had read the tenth the way you read the terms on the back of a parking lot ticket. Somebody had put it in front of me and I had turned the page.

Four months in that house, and I had used that agreement every single day to be in a room I was not allowed to be in, and I had never once asked what happened if the man who was bound by it was also the man who decided what it meant.

I put it on the table and sat looking at it, and then I did the thing I do, which is not to have a feeling first. I got the exhibit list out.

Exhibit C, annexed. Which meant Vance had attached the agreement to a court filing. Which meant that agreement was now in the public record of a proceeding in Westchester County, with my signature on the last page, in the same hand as the signature on the marriage license, which was the same hand as the signature on a marriage license signed by a man who cannot write.

I turned to the last page of the notice to look at the signature block.

*Respectfully submitted, HOLLIS VANCE, for the Estate.*

And under it, where the client signs: *Julian Roarke.*

It leaned forward. The J had a small hook. The t was crossed low.

I sat at that table for a long time with my finger on it, because I have spent four months learning that hand from the other side. I have written it a thousand times in my own log, practising, the way I practise a brow. I know the width of the loop on the A, and I know that whoever wrote the copy in front of me had been writing it for three years and had stopped thinking about it.

It was not his. It had never been his. He had not written a word since 2019 and he was not going to.

And the name on the motion that removed me from the record was written by Nadia Reyes, in a room in this house, on a Tuesday, at a desk.

Then I got up and went to the cabinet and took out a blank certification form.

The court had begun requiring one a month in January. Two lines and a signature at the bottom. I had refused the first one and written in the margin, and Margot had told me that a habit is expensive and nerves are free, and I had signed the second one in February with a longer note in the margin, and nobody had said anything about it, and the third was due on the seventeenth.

They can strike a filing. A filing is a thing I chose to do. It comes out of my mouth and it goes into a book and a clerk stamps it and a judge can throw it out.

They cannot strike a certification. A certification is a form the court makes me sign. It is one page of the court's paper with the court's case number at the top, and the only place on it that a person can put a fact is the line at the bottom and the space around it.

I took the form to the table and filled in the caption and the date and then wrote, in the margin above the certification, in the smallest hand I have:

*The inventory is not complete. Folder 2019-1146 is empty and has been empty since 2019. The undersigned has been served with a motion to strike her objections, brought under paragraph ten of an agreement annexed to that motion, and states for the record that she will continue to certify what she is able to certify and to note in the margin what she is not.*

Then I initialled it and dated it and put it in an envelope and addressed it to the clerk of the court in my own hand, and drove it to the post office on Post Road and put it in the box and stood on the sidewalk.

It was eleven o'clock in the morning on a Saturday in March.

I got to Astoria at two.

He had the folder open on the card table and the six things spread out and a pad beside them with writing on it, and he had been at it for a week, and he did not get up.

"Sit down," he said.

I sat down.

He turned the page with my signature on it around so it faced me.

"I know you signed," he said.

"I told you I signed. Last Saturday. In this room."

"I know you signed." He said it again, flat, without any weight on it at all. "Since March."

The radiator under the window knocked twice.

"Since March of what," I said.

"Last March." He put his finger on the page. "I asked the clerk for my own file. I was a party. I had a number and I had a right to it and I went down there with a bag and they gave me a box, and there was a hundred and forty pages in the box, and you were in it. Three paragraphs and a line and your name printed under the line and your signature at the bottom."

I did not say anything.

"March the eleventh," he said. "I remember the date because it was the day my mother's boiler went."

"You've had it for a year."

"I've had it for a year."

"And in November you came to that house and stood at the bottom of the drive and told me you wanted to know what I was doing in there."

"Yes."

"Why."

He looked at me for a moment.

"Because I wanted to see what a person looks like when they're doing it again," he said. "I've thought about that since, and it wasn't a kind thing to do, and I'm not going to pretend it was."

I sat in that chair with my hands in my lap and the radiator knocking.

"Why didn't you use it," I said.

"Use it for what."

"You could have filed. You could have named me. You had my signature on a false statement and you had a case number and a clerk who was decent to you."

"I'm not the state," Owen said. "I'm a man with two ribs and a truck." He sat back. "And I read that page in March and I thought: that's a woman who was twenty-eight and broke and somebody put a piece of paper in front of her. And then I read the date on it, and it's four days after the cremation, and I thought: no. That's a woman who was in a room with a body and wrote down that the scar didn't match, and then somebody came and told her it did, and she signed it, and then she went home and thought about it for three years."

He put his hand flat on the page.

"You wrote it down first," he said. "That's the thing I couldn't get past. You wrote it down in your own book before anybody asked you to sign anything. That's not what a crook does."

"That's not absolution."

"No," he said. "It's not. It's just the reason I didn't file."

I want to record what happened next, because I have gone over it more times than anything else in this account, and because in the version of this that runs in my head at four in the morning I say something different.

"You should have used it," I said. "It would have been the right thing."

He looked at me.

"The right thing," he said.

"Yes."

"You signed a page for six thousand five hundred dollars and you're going to sit in my kitchen and tell me about the right thing."

"I'm not—"

"I'm not fighting with you." He held his left hand up. "I'm telling you what I've got. I've got a sister who's been in the ground three years and a case I lost in front of a judge who didn't look up and a box in my mother's closet I can't open and two ribs that are healing crooked because I couldn't afford to take the time. I've got no money and no law and no education past the tenth grade, and I have spent three years doing this and I have not been paid anything by anybody, not once, not a dollar, not a ride."

He picked up the page with my signature on it and held it.

"The only difference between us is that I never got paid."

I sat there.

Then I said, "That's not true."

"No," he said. "But it's the truest thing I've got today, and you asked."

He put the page down and pushed it back across the table towards me, and I put my hand on it, and neither of us let go for a second, and then he did.

"Take it home," he said. "It's yours. It was always going to be yours."

I drove back over the bridge in the dark with a page on the passenger seat and the ring turned round to the front of my finger, and the county came up on the right the way it does, all trees and no lights.

I had a motion to strike me, a certification in the mail, a date with a man in Astoria in three weeks, and one page that proved I had lied.

And I had, in my coat, in the inside pocket, a card with six minutes of a man on it, and I had not told him, and I had not told the man either, and the reason I had not told either of them was that I had begun, somewhere in February, to think of it as mine.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: Since March · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads