Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 53: One Page

The fifth of September was a Tuesday and Hollis Vance asked me to meet him at St. Michael's at four in the afternoon, which is the church where my mother is buried in the fourth section, in ground that a woman paid for in 2019 and never mentioned.

I want that on the record. He chose that church.

He was in the third pew from the back with his hat on the seat beside him and a folder on his knees, and he did not get up when I came down the aisle.

"You look worse than the last time," he said.

"My hands are wrapped and my house burned and my husband has four fingers on one hand."

"Yes." He looked at the folder. "I heard about the fire. I want to say one thing about the fire and then I am not going to say anything else about it."

"Say it."

"I did not do it and I do not know who did." He said it without looking up. "I have been the lawyer for that family for nineteen years and I have written every document that has hurt you, and I did not do that, and I am aware that my not doing a thing is not worth very much in your accounting."

"It's worth something."

"It's worth nothing. Don't be gracious with me, it doesn't suit either of us."

He opened the folder.

There was one page in it. Not a copy — the page. Old, soft at the folds, with a carbon smudge along the left edge and a date stamp at the top right in purple ink.

"This is the original transport slip," he said. "Not the one in the file. The one that came off the pad at the facility at four in the morning and went into a pocket."

"Whose pocket."

"Mine." He put it on the pew between us. "I have had it in a fireproof box in my basement for four years, and I have taken it out a dozen times and put it back, and I want you to understand that I did not keep it to protect you. I kept it because I am a man who keeps things."

I picked it up.

It is a form the size of a hand. Three-part carbon, the top sheet, and the top sheet is the one that goes with the goods. The writing is a hand I do not know, in a hurry, and the boxes are ticked, and the description of the goods is the line that says *one (1) unit, sealed, intact*.

And in the box marked **DECEDENT FILE NO.**, in pencil, in the same hurried hand:

**31 — 2019 — 0311 — D**

I sat in a pew in St. Michael's with a piece of paper in my hands and looked at a number that I had put together on the back of an envelope on the eighth of May.

"That's it," I said.

"That's it."

"It was on the truck."

"It was on the truck from four in the morning." He put his finger on the date stamp without touching the paper. "Look at the stamp."

The stamp was purple and it was not a date. It was a time.

**03:05**

I looked at it for a while.

"The permit was issued at three twenty," I said.

"Yes."

"Fifteen minutes after this."

"Yes."

"And the truck left at four."

"At four." He sat back. "Which means that at five past three in the morning, in a facility in White Plains, somebody typed a number into a transport slip for a body that had not yet been released, and fifteen minutes later the county issued a cremation permit for a man who had been dead since Thursday, and fifty-five minutes after that a van with two doors and a ramp went out into the rain."

"Who typed it."

"A clerk who has been dead since 2021." He said it flatly. "Her name was on nine documents in that file and she is not going to be asked about any of them."

"Then who told her what number to type."

He did not answer.

"Mr. Vance."

"I am going to answer that," he said, "but I am going to answer it in a courtroom and not in a church, because in a church it is a conversation and in a courtroom it is testimony, and I have spent four years preferring conversations."

I put the slip down on the pew.

"Say the rest of it," I said.

"The dental conclusion." He looked at the altar. "Four words. *Consistent with the records.* Typed on the ninth of October 2019, four weeks before anybody died, on a form that a hygienist signed because the man who was supposed to sign it could not hold a pen."

"I know all of that."

"You know it was typed early. You do not know who typed it." He turned his head. "I typed it."

The church was very quiet. There is a particular quiet in a church in the afternoon in September, with the doors open and the street going on outside and the light coming down at an angle with dust in it.

"Why."

"Because I was told what was needed and I was good at my job." He said it without any self-pity, which is the only thing about him I have ever respected. "I did not ask what it was for. I have thought about that sentence for four years. There is a version of me in which I ask what it is for, and the answer is that I am fired at fifty-one with a daughter of thirteen and a mortgage, and I go and work for a firm in White Plains and nobody is hurt. I have looked for that version and I cannot find him."

I took the recorder out of my coat and put it on the pew between us and pressed the button.

He looked at it.

"Say your name," I said. "Say the date. Say what you just said."

"Ms. Ellery."

"Say it."

He sat with his hands on his knees for about half a minute.

Then he said his name, and the date, and he said it again, all of it, in the same flat voice, and it took four minutes, and at the end of it he said one more thing that I had not asked for, which was:

"And I want it recorded that on the ninth of October 2019 I saw that man's right hand wrapped at a dental laboratory in Yonkers, and that he told me it was a car door, and that I wrote the word *injury* on my own note and dated it, and that I did not ask a second question."

I sat there with my hand flat on the pew.

"A car door," I said.

"A car door. In October." He looked at me. "Four weeks before the car door."

I turned the recorder off and sat in the pew and did not say anything for a while.

The October hand and the November hand had been in my mouth for eight months and I had never been able to make them into one thing. And a man in a church had just put them in the same sentence without any idea that he was doing it.

He did not know what he had said. That is the part I keep. He thought he was confessing to a dental form.

"What are you going to do with it," he said.

"Give it to a judge."

"Then I will testify." He put his hat on. "But not for you. For my daughter."

"Does she know what you're doing."

He stood up in the aisle with his hat in his hand.

"She knows I'm not home," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 53: One Page · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads