Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 8: The Joint Report

The first joint report was due on the twenty-first, and we did it at my table at four o'clock, because that was the hour he came down.

He stood on the other side. I had the report in front of me, three pages, and a stamp pad, and a pen.

"Put your thumb here," I said.

He took his right hand out of his pocket.

I had seen it before, in the way you see a thing you have decided not to look at: a hand that was the wrong shape, with the three middle fingers drawn back into the palm and the skin over the knuckles pale and tight, and a scar that ran from the base of the index finger down toward the wrist in a line that was too straight to be an accident.

It was not a hand that had been crushed. Crushed is a mess. This was a hand that had been put back together by somebody competent and then had refused to work.

I did not say anything. I put the pad down and he pressed his thumb into it and then onto the page, and left a print, and I noticed that he pressed slightly left of where the line was, and that he did it without looking, the way a man does a thing he has done four thousand times.

"Left of the line," I said.

"It's where it goes."

"The line is the line."

"The line is where the notary put it." He took his hand back and put it in his pocket. "In 2019 it was a quarter inch to the left and nobody has ever moved it. If I put my thumb on the line, Vance's office calls me and asks whether I'm all right."

I wrote the date, and my initials, and then, at the bottom, *Julian Roarke*, in eleven seconds, and I did it badly this time, and it looked like a forgery, and I felt better.

He watched me do it.

"You're getting worse," he said.

"I'm getting honest."

The license came back from the county in four days, and with it a letter from the State renewing my licence for another year, in a limited category, which is the phrase they use when they want you to know they are watching.

*Non-litigious restorative work only.* It meant I could rebuild a stranger's face for a funeral. It meant I could not touch anything that had a case number attached to it. It meant, in practice, that I could work for the dead and not for the court, which is a distinction that had never once occurred to me before and which I found, on the whole, insulting.

I put the letter in my case and went back to the boxes.

The thing about an archive is that it tells you what is missing.

I spent the twenty-first and the twenty-second on the 2019 files, and by the end of the second day I could say, out loud, in a room with a lamp in it, that the disposition file for Theodore J. Roarke was not in the archive. The folder was there. The tab was there. The staples were there, in the seam of the folder, holding nothing, with the little torn bits of paper still caught in them.

Somebody had taken the contents out and left the folder, which is what a person does when they are in a hurry and it is two in the morning.

I wrote it in the log. Then I wrote a letter to the court, on paper, by hand, because a hand-written letter gets read by a person and an email gets read by a clerk, and I asked for a certified copy of the 2019 disposition and the accompanying transport record, citing the order, and I walked it to the FedEx on the Boston Post Road myself and paid for it out of my own pocket, because the estate paid my fee and I did not want the estate paying for this.

That is a small thing. It felt like a large one.

Owen Kessler was in the parking lot behind the county building on the twenty-third at 6:40 in the evening, leaning against a truck with a ladder rack, in a canvas jacket with a tear at the shoulder that had been mended with a staple.

I knew him before he said anything, because I had been looking at his name on a caption for sixteen days.

"Ms. Ellery."

"Mr. Kessler."

"You know who I am."

"I know your name. I know you filed. I know you've been at this for eleven months." I put my case in the car and closed the door. "I also know you're not supposed to talk to me, and neither am I to you, so one of us should go inside."

"I'll be quick." He pushed off the truck. He was thirty-one, maybe, with a work boot that had gone white at the toe and a scar through his left eyebrow. "I want to know what you're doing in that house."

"Inventorying."

"You're inventorying my sister's death."

"I'm inventorying thirty-one boxes."

"Don't." He said it flatly, no heat, and it stopped me. "Don't do the voice. I've had eleven months of the voice. I've had four lawyers do the voice at me." He put his hands in his jacket pockets. "You did her face."

The parking lot was almost empty. A light over the door buzzed.

"I did a face," I said.

"You did *her* face." He was not shouting. That was the terrible part. "They wouldn't let me see her. They said — the funeral home said there was a viewing, and then there wasn't, and then there was a box, and the box was closed, and the man said it was better that way, and I believed him because I was twenty-eight and my mother was on the floor." He stopped. Started again. "And then a year later a woman in an office told me that a restorative specialist had been engaged, and I asked what that meant, and she said it meant somebody had made her presentable."

I had my hand on the roof of my car.

"So I've spent three years," he said, "trying to find the one person who looked at her. Not the lawyers. Not the judge. The person who put her back together. Because that person is the only one in the whole state who can tell me whether what was in that box was my sister."

The light buzzed. Somewhere behind us a car started and pulled away.

"Mr. Kessler," I said, "I'm going to tell you something and then I'm going to get in my car."

"All right."

"I signed a piece of paper three years ago that I should not have signed. It said the mark on his face was from the accident. It wasn't." I looked at him. "I've thought about that paper every day since. So when you ask me what I'm doing in that house, the honest answer is that I'm trying to find out whether I was lied to or whether I did the lying, and I don't yet know which one it is, and until I do I'm not going to sit in a parking lot and be somebody's witness."

He looked at me for a long moment.

"His face," he said.

"What?"

"You said the mark on *his* face." He took a step closer. "I've been reading the file for eleven months, Ms. Ellery. There's no mark on his face. There's no mention of a mark anywhere in it."

I did not move.

The wind came across the lot and moved the rain in the gutter.

"Then somebody took it out," I said.

"Yeah." He nodded slowly, and something in his face came apart and set again, harder. "Yeah. Somebody did."

He got into his truck. He sat there with the engine off for a while, and I stood by my car with my hand on the roof, and neither of us looked at the other.

Then he rolled the window down.

"One thing," he said. "The photo they gave us. The one for the — the announcement." He said the word carefully, like it was hot. "She's got a scar. Here." He touched his own left eyebrow. "Fell off a bike when she was nine. I've got the same one. Our mother used to say it was so people would know we were related."

"I know," I said.

He looked at me.

"How do you know?"

I got into my car and did not answer him, and I drove out of the lot and pulled over on the Boston Post Road half a mile on and sat with my hands on the wheel and my heart going like a bird in a box, because I had just understood something that I had been carrying around for three years without being able to see the shape of it.

Lena Kessler had a scar on her left eyebrow.

The body on my table had a scar on its left eyebrow.

And Theo Roarke, in every photograph I had ever been shown, had smooth skin from the brow to the hairline, like a man who had never fallen off anything in his life.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.