Signed in Another Hand

Chapter 9: What She Looked Like

I did not go down to the archive the next morning. It was the first working day I had taken off in nine years, and the housekeeper took the news the way she took everything, which is to say she said "I'll tell Mrs. Roarke" and went away.

Then I drove to Queens.

My studio is on the ground floor of a building that used to be a bakery and still has the tile. There are four stainless tables, a sink with a foot pedal, a wall of cabinets with a lock that I have replaced twice, and a cooler unit in the back that runs at thirty-eight degrees and costs me more in electricity than my apartment.

Owen Kessler met me at the door at ten past nine with a cardboard box under one arm and the expression of a man who has decided to be calm and is finding it expensive.

"You said you'd tell me how you knew."

"I said I'd show you."

I let him in and locked the door behind him, and I did not turn on the overhead lights, only the work lamp over table three, because that is the light I think in.

"Before we do this," he said, "I want something."

"Of course you do."

"The disposition file. The one with the three signatures on it. You're in that archive six hours a day."

"I'm in that archive six hours a day with a court order that says I inventory the estate. Not that I carry it out in my coat."

"I'm not asking you to steal it. I'm asking for a copy."

I looked at him. He was not stupid and he was not bluffing, and he had said *a copy* rather than *the original*, which meant he had thought about it on the drive over and had decided to be reasonable, and reasonable men are the hardest to refuse.

"All right," I said. "The file for the phone."

"What?"

"Her phone. It's in the box. If I bring you the file, you let me take the phone to somebody who can open it."

He looked down at the carton under his arm. "It's dead. It's been dead three years."

"That's not the same as empty."

He thought about it for four seconds. Then he put the box on the table and said, "Deal."

I did not tell him the folder was empty.

I had known for two days. I had seen the staples holding nothing and the torn paper caught in them, and I had written it in the log, and I had walked to the FedEx on the Boston Post Road and paid for a certified request out of my own pocket.

And I let him shake on a copy of a document I already knew did not exist, because I wanted the phone.

I want to record that this is the first time in my life I made a bargain I knew I could not keep, and that it took me less than a minute to decide.

Her things: a pair of boots, black, cracked across the toe, with a heel worn on the outside. A phone with a shattered screen. A denim jacket with a pin on the lapel that said *ASK ME ABOUT MY CAT*. A birthday card. A photograph in a cardboard frame, the kind they give you at a chain studio, of a girl of nineteen with her hair pulled back and her chin lifted, laughing at whoever was holding the camera.

I put on my loupe.

This is the part I have never been able to describe to anyone who does not do this work. When I look at a face in a photograph through a loupe, I am not looking at the face. I am looking at the record of what happened to it. The way the skin sits over the bone at the temple. The place where a childhood scar pulled the eyebrow up by a millimeter and never let it come back down. The faint asymmetry at the corner of the mouth that means she slept on her left side.

"That's her," Owen said.

"Yes."

"You can tell from a photograph."

"I can tell you she fell off a bicycle when she was nine and landed on her face, and that she broke her nose around fourteen and nobody set it, and that she bit her lower lip when she was thinking, and that she was left-handed, because the callus on her thumb is—" I stopped. "I can tell you she was alive. That's what I can tell you."

He sat down on the stool by table two and put his hands on his knees.

I looked at the eyebrow for a long time.

The scar was old and pale and it ran up and out, toward the temple, in the direction a fall takes. The skin had healed over it in that slightly dragged way that childhood injuries do, because children's faces are still moving when they heal. It was the most ordinary mark in the world. Half the people in that borough have one.

I put the loupe down.

"Mr. Kessler, I need to show you something and I need you to not say anything until I'm finished."

"All right."

I went to the cabinet, unlocked it, and took out the envelope I have kept for three years. It is a plain manila envelope with a red stripe and a date on the front in my own handwriting, and inside it are eleven photographs and a contact sheet, and I have not opened it since the week I made it.

I laid them out under the lamp.

They are not nice photographs. I am not going to describe them. What I will say is that they are technical: raking light, scale card, three angles, and a close-up of the left orbital ridge taken at four times magnification because I could not make myself believe what I was seeing.

Owen looked at them for a few seconds and then turned his head away and breathed through his mouth for a while, and I stood there and let him, because there is no good way to do this part.

"Okay," he said. "Okay."

"Look at the left brow. Not the injury. The line above it."

He looked.

"There's a line," he said.

"There's a line." I put the loupe in his hand and guided it. "Now. A scar from a fall has a shape. It's ragged at the ends. The skin pulls in different directions because the wound was open for a while. It fades toward the edges."

"And this isn't that."

"No." I took the loupe back. "This is straight. It's the same width the whole way. It's got a tiny row of dots along it, here and here, which is what you get from a running suture that was taken out at day seven instead of day five."

He was very still.

"That's a surgical scar," he said.

"That's a surgical incision. Somebody opened that face and closed it again." I straightened up. "And it was healed. Completely healed. Which means it happened at least a year before I ever saw him."

"Before—"

"Before I touched him, Mr. Kessler. Somebody had already been in there."

The cooler kicked on in the back room. The sound filled the whole studio, the way it does, and then settled.

"So what does that mean," he said.

"It means I was wrong." I sat down on the edge of table three. "Three years ago I wrote in my log that the mark was an old scar that didn't match the photographs. And then a lawyer came and told me it was from the accident, and I signed a paper saying so, and I have spent three years telling myself that I signed it because I was broke and tired and twenty-eight years old."

"And now?"

"Now I think I signed it because I was looking at the wrong thing." I put my hands flat on the steel. "I thought the mark meant the body was somebody else. I thought that was the whole story — wrong face, wrong scar, somebody made a mistake. But a *surgical* scar on a man in a county morgue means something else. It means somebody prepared that face. In advance. Before it was a body."

Owen stood up.

"Say that again."

"Somebody operated on that man's face before he died." I heard my own voice come out flat. "Or after. But not in an emergency room, and not in a car, and not by accident. Somebody sat down with him and made an incision over the left orbital ridge and closed it, and then let it heal, and then—"

I stopped, because the next part of the sentence was not something I could say in front of a man whose sister was in a box somewhere.

"And then gave him to you," Owen said.

The cooler kicked off. The room got very quiet.

We did not talk for a while after that. He walked around the studio with his hands behind his head. I sat on the table and looked at eleven photographs of a face I had rebuilt out of wax and stubbornness and somebody else's photographs.

At some point it got cold. It gets cold in that room in November, and I had the cooler door open, because the envelope had been in the back and I had left it open when I came out.

"Your hands are blue," he said.

"They're always blue."

"That's not a thing. Hands aren't always blue."

"These are." I held one up. He looked at it, and then, without any ceremony at all, he took it in both of his and held it, and his hands were enormous and hot and smelled of copper wire and cold metal, and neither of us said anything for a moment that went on a little too long.

Then he let go, and stepped back, and put his hands in his jacket pockets, and said, "I should go."

"Yes."

"Ms. Ellery." At the door he turned around. "You said you'd show me what she looked like."

I had been waiting for that.

"I can't," I said. "Not yet. There's no photograph of what I saw, and there's not going to be, because it's in a file that somebody emptied, and because the only person who looked at her face for nine hours was me and I've been lying about it ever since."

He nodded slowly. Then he said the thing that kept me awake for the next four nights.

"Then what did she look like," he said. "Not her. The other one. The one in the box."

I opened my mouth.

And I found that I could not answer, because I had spent nine hours with that face and I could not, at that moment, have told him what color its eyes were — and I am a woman who can tell you the undertone of a stranger's skin at four in the morning from memory.

"I don't know," I said.

"That's what I thought," he said, and left.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 9: What She Looked Like · Signed in Another Hand · Lumen Reads