The meeting was set for seven a.m. in the brasserie, before the breakfast service, because it was the only room in Mont-Clair that could hold everyone at once and because Julie wanted them off their feet and off their stations. Fewer excuses to walk out.
She stood at the end of the long communal table with her laptop closed in front of her—closed on purpose, because she'd learned that staff read a screen the way horses read a loaded truck and it made them nervous. Etienne took the far end, near the door, arms folded. Henri hovered by the coffee urn as though it might need his personal protection.
Seven people had come. Julie had counted fourteen names on the payroll.
"Thank you for coming," she said. "I'm Julie Moreau. I'm a consultant. I'm here to look at how the hotel runs, top to bottom, and to write down what I see. That's all. No one is losing their job today, and I'm not going to ask anyone to say anything they don't want said."
A man in a ski school jacket, fifty-odd, weathered to the color of old rope, leaned back and laughed. Not unkindly. "Then what do you want to ask us?"
"Your name first."
"Margot Perrin. Ski school. Twenty-nine seasons."
"Twenty-nine."
"Twenty-eight with Camille." Margot said it flatly, no ceremony, and Julie noticed Etienne's jaw tighten at the sound of the name. "You want to know if we can ski, I can tell you everybody at this table can ski. You want to know if we can run a hotel under a woman who knew what she was doing, I'll tell you that's harder and that none of us has been asked to in a while."
"Margot," Henri said, from the coffee urn.
"She asked."
"I asked," Julie agreed. "Go on."
Margot spread her hands on the table, palms down, as if she were checking the surface was solid. "The lodge is sinking. Everyone at this table knows it. The guests know it. The man at the bank—" she jerked her chin at the lobby door, beyond which, faintly, they could all hear it: the telephone, ringing, ringing, ringing "—the man at the bank certainly knows it. What do you want us to pretend?"
The room had gone very still. The woman from the front desk stared at her hands. The young cook in the corner had stopped moving entirely, a dishcloth frozen in his fist.
"Nothing," Julie said. "I want the opposite. I want you to tell me everything that's wrong, and then I'll write my own list and we'll compare."
That got her a flicker of something around the table—not trust, exactly, but the suspension of active hostility, which in a failing property was close enough to a welcome.
She took them through it. Not a performance review; a triage. Who could service a boiler. Who had worked the old reservations system before the switch. Who spoke German, who spoke Italian, who had ever run a wedding. The answers came slowly at first, then faster, and they were worse than Julie had feared and better than she'd expected in odd, specific ways: the front desk woman, Sophie, had kept her own handwritten ledger of every guest's preferences for six years, because when the computer crashed in January 2022 nobody had been able to pull a single reservation and she'd sworn never to be caught like that again. The cook, Bastien, had trained in Annecy and could actually cook; he'd been serving the same four dishes because the freezer was the only thing in the kitchen that held temperature and the walk-in had been broken since before Camille died.
"How long before Camille died," Julie asked.
Bastien looked at Etienne. Etienne looked at the floor. "The spring before," Bastien said.
"And nobody fixed the walk-in."
"It was quoted," Henri said. "The quote—"
"The quote is in the filing cabinet," Etienne said, and the sharpness in his voice startled even him; he folded his arms tighter, as if to hold the tone back in.
Julie let it sit. She wrote nothing down, because writing made people careful, and she wanted them careless.
"Last question," she said. "What do you want to happen here? Honestly. If you could have anything."
Margot answered before anyone could stop her. "I want Camille back."
Nobody laughed.
"Apart from that."
"I want to know who's going to sign my contract in April," Margot said. "Because it isn't Camille, and every time I ask—" she tipped her head toward Etienne, a small, precise motion, not quite rude, "—nobody answers me. That's not a complaint about the money. It's a complaint about the silence."
"We'll have an answer before April," Etienne said.
"From whom?"
"From the hotel."
"The hotel," Margot repeated. "The hotel is a building, Etienne. You mean you. Or you mean your brother."
The coffee urn made a sound. Julie saw Etienne flinch. It was small—a blink, a half-turn of the shoulder as though something had brushed it—but it was unmistakable, the way the flinch of a man who is not a good liar is unmistakable, because the whole body does the work the face cannot.
"Thibault has nothing to do with the contracts," Etienne said.
"He has his share of them," Margot said. "Legally."
"Margot." This time it was Sophie, and her voice had real fear in it.
Margot shrugged and sat back. "She asked what I wanted. I want the person who signs to be the person who shows up."
The phone in the lobby stopped ringing. Everyone noticed. It was the loudest silence Julie had heard in the building.
"Thank you," Julie said. "That's exactly what I needed." She picked up her closed laptop and held it against her chest. "I'm going to give you an honest review. That means it will be ugly, and it will name things—not people, things—and it will be on Etienne's desk and the bank's desk by the end of next week. If any of you have something you'd rather I heard from you than from a stack of invoices, my door is the third one past the stairs, and it's open."
They dispersed the way staff do, quickly and without ceremony, the cook first because the kitchen called, Sophie to the desk, Henri drifting back toward whatever it was Henri did. Margot was last. She stopped beside Julie and looked at Etienne down the length of the table, then back at her.
"Twenty-nine seasons," Margot said quietly. "I've watched three owners here. Camille was the best of them and she's dead. The other two are brothers, and only one of them ever puts his hands in the snow." She pulled her gloves from her jacket pocket. "You want to know what's wrong with this hotel, ask him about the lift."
"Which him."
Margot pulled the gloves on, finger by finger. "Whichever one answers."
She went out through the terrace door into the cold, and the room was Julie and Etienne and the smell of coffee going stale.
He hadn't moved from the door end. He was looking at the spot where Margot had stood, and there was something on his face that Julie had not seen there yet—not the evasiveness of a man hiding numbers, or the panic of a man hiding a fake fiancée from his grandmother. Something older.
"Who's Thibault?" Julie said.
"My brother." He said it the way you'd name a bad winter.
"He's on the contracts."
"He's on the deed. He's a co-owner. He hasn't set foot in Mont-Clair in four years."
"Why not?"
Etienne finally looked at her. "Because of what he did the last time he did."
The lobby door opened and Henri's voice came through, thin and aggrieved: "Monsieur Chastain? There's a man here from the insurance office. He says he's come about the lift, and he's asking to see the file."
Julie's hand went, without meaning it to, to the side pocket of her bag, where two endorsement slips lay folded inside a paperback she had not opened in three days. Etienne was already moving toward the lobby.
"Which insurance office?" Julie said, following. "Did he give a name?"
Henri's answer floated back to her, and it changed everything.
"Fournier," he said. "Rémi Fournier. He says he's the broker."