Housing Works smelled like old paper and new coffee, and the back room they'd been given had no stage, just a rug, two stools, and a standing lamp someone had dragged in from the café. Nora set her phone on the second stool, screen up, timer running.
"From the top," she said. "You read one. I read one. We don't stop until eleven-forty."
Julian shrugged off his coat and folded it over the arm of a folding chair. He'd brought the letters printed, not on his phone — actual pages, in a folder, which she hadn't expected and didn't comment on.
"You first," he said.
She'd picked the September letter. She always picked the September letter; it was short and it didn't humiliate either of them. She read it the way Danielle had told her to read it — flat, evidentiary, no performance. *I don't know what you look like and I've decided that's the point. If I knew, I'd start writing for you instead of for me.*
"Good," Julian said. "Keep the flatness."
"I know the flatness."
He read his reply. The one from October. *You're wrong about the point. The point is that you keep writing anyway.* He read it differently than she did — slower, with a half-beat before the last sentence, like he was reading something he'd had to memorize to get through.
They went through six exchanges. Deb poked her head in once to ask if they wanted the door closed and Nora said yes and Deb closed it and gave them a look on the way out that Nora chose to ignore.
At the seventh, Julian stopped turning pages.
"There's one more," he said. "March."
"March isn't in the script."
"It's in the book."
"We're not reading it."
He read it anyway.
*I keep looking at the mailbox. I know what day it is. I know the mail comes at eleven and I know you're three hundred miles away and I still check at eleven and again at two because it costs me nothing to be wrong and it costs me something to stop.*
Nora's hand was flat on the stool before she knew she'd moved.
"Stop."
He stopped.
"That's not in the script." Her voice came out thinner than she wanted. "Danielle approved eleven letters. That's twelve."
"I know."
"So why."
"Because it's the one I actually wrote the night before I stopped writing." He set the folder down on his knee. "The rest of those pages, I wrote them for the persona. That one I wrote at a kitchen table at two in the morning because I'd been checking a mailbox for a girl I'd never met, and I wanted to put it in words before I talked myself out of it."
Nora picked up her phone. The timer said nineteen minutes. She set it back down.
"We can't read that Friday."
"Why not?"
"Because it's not evidence." She heard how stupid it sounded as it left her. "Everything we read Friday has to be provable. It has to be a document. The second you read a line that sounds like you meant it, Cross's lawyer stands up and says *see, this is a personal grievance, this is a man who wanted a woman's attention and didn't get it, and now he's built a lawsuit out of it.*"
"That was real," Julian said. "I need you to know it was real."
The lamp buzzed. Out on the sales floor someone dropped a stack of hardcovers and laughed about it.
Nora sat down on the second stool, the one with the phone on it, and moved the phone to the floor.
"When?"
"February." He didn't look away. "The broker. I told you I approached one in February, and you assumed it was business. It was. I was trying to find out who'd been buying archived correspondence out of a defunct teen site, because a romance novel I was acquiring had a voice in it that didn't belong to the woman who sold it to me. That's the whole reason I was ever in this. And then I found out whose letters they were, and it stopped being business, and I filed it under *deal with this later* for eleven months."
"Eleven months."
"Give or take."
She stood up. Paced to the door and back. The rug had a stain shaped roughly like Ohio and she stared at it like it was going to give her something.
"Danielle will cut it," she said. "She'll read the draft tomorrow, she'll get to that line, and she'll cut it, and she'll be right to cut it."
"Then don't put it in the draft."
"It has to be in the draft. She's demanded approval of every word."
"Then put it in the draft," Julian said, "and when she cuts it, put it back in your mouth Friday and let her stand up."
Nora laughed once, humorlessly. "You want me to burn her live in the room."
"I want you to read your own mail in your own voice." He opened the folder and slid the March page across the rug toward her, facedown. "You told me in the booth you weren't going to take my hand. Fine. I'm not offering it. I'm telling you what I wrote."
She looked at the page on the floor. She didn't pick it up.
"Say the rest of it," she said.
"There isn't any rest. That was the last one."
"I mean the broker. February. What did you do with it."
"I kept it." He leaned back against the folding chair. "I have the name of the firm. I have the intake email. It's a one-man operation out of a co-working space in Flatbush and it doesn't appear on any LetterLoop filing, which is exactly why it's useful. That's what I was doing at your building on MacDougal in February. Asking the manager who else had inquired."
"Priya said Cross is doing the same thing."
"Then Cross knows the name too."
"Then Cross has had it since February," Nora said, "and he sat on it."
Neither of them said anything for a second. The timer on the floor hit twenty-six minutes and kept going.
"Okay," she said finally. "New plan."
"I'm listening."
"We rehearse it both ways. Flat version for Danielle. Real version for Friday. And I don't tell her which one I'm going to use, because if I tell her, she'll tell me, and I'd rather find out live." She crouched, picked the March page up off the rug, and handed it back to him. "March goes last. After the September letter. If I'm going to do it, it's the thing they walk out on."
"They won't walk out."
"Then they'll sit there and watch me do it, which is worse, and that's what we want." She picked her phone up off the floor. Twenty-nine minutes. She hit reset. "Again. From the top. Read your parts like you don't know me."
"From the top," Julian said, and turned back to the first page. "You know this is insane."
"I do."
"Your lawyer will kill you."
"She'll try." Nora sat back down, the September letter in her hand, and read the first line flat. *I don't know what you look like* — and she got three words further before her voice did something she hadn't put there on purpose, and she heard it happen, and she kept going anyway.
At 11:40 Deb knocked and told them she had to lock up, and reopened the door at 11:42 for the man from the café who wanted his lamp back. Nora folded her pages into the folder. Julian put his coat on, and she watched him do it and did not say anything about the fact that he had brought printed pages, which meant he had known before he walked in that he was going to read March, which meant he had planned on telling her tonight.
"Friday," she said at the door.
"Friday." He held it open. "Nora. If Danielle pulls you off it—"
"She won't get the chance."
He nodded, and walked her to the corner, and peeled off toward the train, and Nora stood there in the cold for a full minute before she called Danielle to confirm the script review was still on for eight in the morning.