The Dead Letter Office

Chapter 33: The Cross Counter

The letter arrived at 7:52 a.m., which was itself a message. No one pays a courier to deliver a cease-and-desist before eight unless they want you to read it with your coffee and feel your morning dissolve.

Nora read it standing in her kitchen, coat still on.

*Kessler Vaughn LLP, on behalf of Cross Media Holdings.* Three pages of throat-clearing about commercial disparagement, tortious interference with prospective business relations, breach of the implied covenant of good faith, and—her favorite—*intentional infliction of emotional distress*, as though Cross were the one who'd spent ten years having his adolescent sentences published under someone else's name.

The demand was simple. Cancel Friday. Cease and desist from any public reading, discussion, or dissemination of correspondence "originating from or derived from LetterLoop user data." Turn over all copies. Confirm in writing by five p.m. today.

They'd attached an exhibit. Nora's own letter, dated June 2003, reproduced in full, with the salutation *Dear Julian* and eleven words in the middle circled: *I think you'd like the way I say your name.*

She sat down on the kitchen floor with her back against the cabinets. The linoleum was cold through her tights. She read the letter three times, which was two times too many.

Then she took a photograph of the exhibit, sent it to Danielle with the subject line *guess*, and put the kettle on.

Danielle called back in four minutes.

"I'm reading it," Danielle said. "Page two—they're citing *Salinger v. Random House*, which is a stretch so aggressive it's almost flirtation. And page three, paragraph fourteen, they threaten to sue you *personally* for emotional distress. Nora. Read paragraph fourteen again. They're saying your letters caused Julian distress."

"They didn't read my letters. They read *his* letters. He was the one who wrote back."

"Correct. Which means they have his side of the correspondence."

Nora looked at the kettle, which hadn't boiled. "Cross has said he's had the broker's name since February."

"He's had more than the name. He has the archive. Both directions. Which means—" Danielle's voice went flat and quick, the way it did when she was doing arithmetic she didn't like. "Which means every demand they make in this letter, they could satisfy themselves. They don't need your copies. They're not trying to get the letters. They're trying to get *you*, in a room, on the record, saying them out loud."

"Because a public reading converts my private grievance into a commercial act."

"Because a public reading gives them a defamation hook and a witness list and a reporter. Yes." A pause. "Nora, I told you I would approve every word of that script and I meant it. This is the part where I tell you the smart thing is to cancel."

"Are you telling me that?"

"I'm telling you what the smart thing is. I'm not telling you what I'm going to do." Another pause; paper rustling. "File it. I'll respond by noon. Do not respond yourself, do not call them, do not—"

"I have an eight o'clock script review."

"With me. Yes. Bring the version I approved and nothing else."

"Nothing else," Nora said, and hung up, and did not think about the March letter sitting in a manila folder on her desk under a stack of Parchment backlist contracts.

At 8:03, the script review took nineteen minutes. Danielle went line by line and struck four passages as inflammatory and one as hearsay. She kept the framing Nora had written—*These letters were taken from me in 2016. I am reading them because reading them is the only act of ownership left to me*—and told her to remove the word *stolen* entirely.

"Taken," Danielle said. "Taken is provable. Stolen is a verdict."

At 8:40, the second letter came, this time by email, addressed to Nora at her Parchment address. Same firm, same tone, escalated. It cc'd Martine Ash of Parchment House. It noted that Parchment's rights agreement with Cross Media contained an indemnification clause. It noted that Ms. Ellery was a Parchment employee.

Nora read it at her desk, deleted the word *stolen* from line seven of her script, and printed two copies.

At 9:15 she called Julian. It rang through to voicemail, twice. At 9:40 she texted him the exhibit photograph with no caption. At 10:02 he wrote back two words: *on my way.*

He arrived at 10:31, and Cross's process server arrived at 10:36, and neither of them knew it yet.

Julian read the letter in the conference room with his sleeves pushed up, which he only did when he was angry. "They're threatening you personally."

"They're threatening everybody. They cc'd Martine. She'll be delighted."

"I'll cover your legal fees."

"You cannot do that. That is—" Nora stopped, because it was exactly the kind of thing that would go into a subpoena and get read aloud. "Thank you. No."

"Nora—"

"Julian, if you pay my lawyer, then every time I stand up in that room on Friday I'm standing up as somebody's investment. I've had enough of that."

He looked at her for a while. Then he said, "Fine," and folded the letter lengthwise like he was about to file it, which he wasn't, and said, "The broker's intake email. I want to give it to Danielle."

"Do it. But she'll ask how I know you have it."

"I'll tell her I have it."

"Then she'll ask why you sat on it since February."

"I didn't sit on it. I didn't know what it was. I sent one email to a broker in February and got a price list and a sample and I closed the tab, because at that point it was a curiosity and I had a company to run." He put the letter down. "And then in April I read a book called *The Long Way Home* and I recognized a sentence. And then it wasn't a curiosity."

Nora spent a long moment deciding whether to believe him, and discovered she already did, and decided that was a thing to examine later.

"Give her the email," she said. "Give her everything. I'm done keeping anyone's February."

At 11:20 the third communication arrived, and this one wasn't from Kessler Vaughn.

It came from Deb at Housing Works, subject line *just so you know*, and it was a screenshot of an email forwarded from the events coordinator to the store manager: a letter from Cross Media Holdings' communications office, received that morning, stating that Cross Media held rights in the material to be read on Friday and formally requesting that Housing Works "decline to host the event to avoid association with an active commercial dispute." Attached was a legal memo. Attached to that, a press release template, already drafted, with the date filled in.

"They drafted the press release *before* they sent the letter," Nora said.

"They sure did," Deb wrote. "Store's standing by you, for the record. But I've got five RSVPs from press now and one from somebody using a burner. Should I hold the two seats at the back?"

"Hold them."

At 11:58, Martine's office called Nora's desk line and hung up when she answered.

At 12:15, Danielle emailed the response: refusal, on all counts, with a footnote citing *New York Times Co. v. Sullivan* that Nora suspected was mostly for show.

At 12:30, Nora ate half a sandwich standing over the sink in the office kitchen and looked at the March letter in its folder and thought about the difference between *taken* and *stolen*, and about how the second word was the only one that described what Cross had actually done to her, and about how Danielle had made her delete it anyway.

The rest of the afternoon went like that—a tunnel of it. Priya sent one message: *Feb records subpoenaed. Manager called me this morning. FYI only.* Nora typed *thank you* and deleted it and typed *I'm sorry* and deleted that too and sent nothing.

At 6:40 she left the office. At 7:05 she climbed the four flights to her apartment because the elevator was out again. At 7:06 she saw the man at her door.

He was young, in a Navy jacket, holding a legal-sized envelope and a clipboard. He looked like he did this eight times a day and had long since stopped enjoying it.

"Nora Ellery?"

"That's a question you already know the answer to."

He held out the envelope. "You've been served."

She took it. It had weight—twenty, thirty pages, the whole complaint with exhibits stapled in. Through the paper she could feel the ridge of the staple, and under her thumb the paperclip, and under that the corner of a page that was a photo reproduction of handwriting she recognized, because it was hers, because it was a letter she had written in September 2003 and never shown a living soul.

"Have a good night," the server said, and started down the stairs.

Mrs. Feldman was standing in her doorway across the hall with her keys in her hand, back from the market, two bags at her feet. She was eighty, maybe eighty-five, and she had lived in this building longer than Nora had been alive, and she did not pretend not to look.

"Trouble?" she said.

"Paperwork," Nora said.

Mrs. Feldman looked at the envelope. She looked at Nora's face for a beat longer than was polite, and then she set her bags down, and said, "I used to type for a company that did paperwork like that."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 33: The Cross Counter · The Dead Letter Office · Lumen Reads