The Ethical Clause

Chapter 33: The Care Home Inquiry

Marlene Osei had the posture of a woman who had spent forty years telling other people's children to sit up straight, and she sat in Emily's visitor chair with her handbag squared on her knees as though she had been asked to wait for a headteacher.

"I'll say this once and then I'll answer whatever you like," Marlene said. "My mother is ninety-one. She has been at Oakhaven eleven years. In March they took away the night staff. There is one carer for twenty-three residents between ten at night and seven in the morning. I have the rota."

She produced it, folded twice, from inside the handbag.

Emily took it and flattened it on the desk. Photocopied columns, names crossed out and rewritten in biro, three weeks in sequence. Under the heading *Night Cover* the name was the same woman every night, with two blanks she had signed as *slept on site, unpaid* in small, careful capitals.

"Who is this?" Emily asked.

"Dorota. Polish. Been there six years, they never made her a senior, and she is frightened of losing her visa so she will not complain to anyone with a clipboard." Marlene's chin went up a fraction. "I am complaining. My mother fell in April. Nobody heard her for two hours because the night girl was on the second floor and the lift alarm was taped over."

Sian, in the doorway with a mug of tea she had clearly made for herself and then forgotten purpose, looked over Emily's shoulder at the rota.

"That's a staffing breach under Regulation 18," Sian said. "If the rota's real, the CQC has to see it."

"It's real," Marlene said. "I stood in reception and photographed it off the wall while the manager was telling me I was not permitted to be there."

Emily turned the page and found what she had half been waiting for without knowing she was waiting for it. At the foot of the third week's sheet, in the small grey footer every agency template carries, was a line of text: *Oakhaven Care Group is a trading subsidiary of Larchwell Holdings Ltd. Registered office: 4 Cheapside.*

She read it three times.

"Emily," Sian said, in the voice she used when Emily's face had gone too still.

"Larchwell Holdings," Emily said. "That's the Fairview parent. Same holding company."

Marlene looked between them. "Is that good?"

"It's the first useful thing anyone has handed me in a fortnight," Emily said, and stood up.

They gave her the small meeting room, the one with the wonky blind, and for two hours Emily built the wall. Marlene's rota, her daughter's photographs of the accident log, a printout of Oakhaven's most recent accounts from Companies House, and then, at the top, the thing that made her stop and go back over it twice with a pencil.

The accounts listed income under *Grants and Donations.* Larchwell's 2023 filing showed a £740,000 grant from the Fairview Educational Trust — her foundation, Oliver's foundation — marked *capacity-building, staff development.*

Emily put the pencil down and walked out into the main office, where Nadia was pretending to work and Priya's old chair sat empty and too neatly aligned.

"Nadia. When you were at Fairview, did anything cross your desk about Larchwell?"

Nadia went carefully still. "Larchwell. That's — they're the ones with the care homes? I don't think so."

"Think again. Not the name. The payments. Capacity-building."

"Grants went through the education side, mostly. But—" Nadia's eyes moved, as though she were reading a screen that was no longer there. "There was a spreadsheet. Once. It had columns that didn't match the narrative. It had 'programme support' against care providers. I remember because I asked whether we were meant to be funding a care home and I was told it was a portfolio line and not to be curious."

"Who told you?"

"Aden Newton." Nadia said it flatly, the way you say the name of someone whose voice you still hear. "He said, *curiosity is a tax on the team.*"

Emily wrote *Newton — Larchwell grants* on her pad and underlined it twice.

"Good," she said. "That's the route."

At the preliminary hearing next month, she would be a claimant on behalf of Marlene Osei and the residents of Oakhaven. She would ask for disclosure of Larchwell's internal correspondence regarding staffing ratios and finances. Disclosure meant schedules. Schedules meant the grant ledger. The grant ledger meant the money trail into Fairview — not a photograph she had unlawfully copied from a storage unit in Bermondsey, but a document produced by order of a court, in daylight, on the record, with her name on the application.

She could feel the shape of it, the way she used to feel the shape of a wall coming down.

"Emily." Sian was standing at the end of the desk with her phone held out. "The Charity Commission."

Emily took it. The email was four lines long, from a case officer, dry as gravel. *We acknowledge receipt of your submission of 14 October and the correspondence from Kempson Laithwaite LLP in Guernsey, which we are treating as a parallel representation. The Commission will require a meeting. Please note we are also in receipt of a complaint concerning the provenance of documents annexed to your submission. Your attendance is requested on 4 November, 2 p.m.*

Two days before the care home hearing.

Sian sat down on the edge of Nadia's desk. "You see what they're doing."

"They're making me a subject," Emily said. "Fine. Subjects get to sit in the room."

"You know what Kempson Laithwaite is?"

"Guernsey firm. Offshore. Softer edge of the foundation's counsel."

"They've named you personally. Emily Hartwell, of Southwark — they've put your name in a letter to a regulator and accused you of unlawfully acquiring documents." Sian's voice stayed level, which was worse than if it had risen. "That's not a complaint. That's a warning shot."

"I know what it is."

"Then you also know the storage unit is the weak point. You said yourself — someone knew the code."

Emily didn't answer for a moment. She was looking at the Larchwell accounts, still open on the meeting room table, at the £740,000 that had come out of the foundation that carried Oliver Voss's signature, into the company that had cut Dorota's nights to nothing, eleven years after a form with his name on it had told a woman care was safe.

"Nadia," she said. "The visitors log. All of this year."

"Still going through it. There's forty pages."

"Then go faster." Emily picked up her pen. "Sian, draft the funding application for the care home matter. If the Commission wants to ask me about provenance, I'd like to be able to tell them there are three live clients and a hearing date. I am not a woman with a grudge and a stolen photograph. I am a solicitor running cases."

Sian didn't move.

"That's the pitch you want," she said quietly. "Is any of it true?"

Emily looked at her, and then, because Sian had earned it, she told the truth. "The cases are true. The photograph is true. And I don't need to be likable to be right."

Marlene was still out in reception, sitting very upright under the poster about free legal advice, and when Emily came to see her out she stood and buttoned her coat with both hands.

"Lady downstairs said you were in the papers," Marlene said. "Something about a young man."

"Yes."

"People said I should be careful, getting myself involved with someone whose photo's in the paper." She adjusted her scarf. "I told them: the man my mother's home took their money from, I don't know him from Adam either. I know the rota. That's what I brought you."

She held out a hand and Emily shook it.

"Next month," Marlene said. "In the court."

And then she was gone through the door, and the office was suddenly very quiet, and Emily stood holding the folded rota while the realisation arrived fully formed, like a name surfacing: Larchwell Holdings was a party to the Fairview grants, the Fairview grants were signed off by trustees, and the schedule of trustees she had seen in 2009, in Oliver's hand — she was sure of it now, though she hadn't looked properly — would name the man who had ordered the audit file that Priya burned.

If the court ordered disclosure, she would not need the photograph at all.

Which meant someone, somewhere, already knew she was about to find that out, and had two weeks and a Guernsey solicitor to stop her.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 33: The Care Home Inquiry · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads