The Ethical Clause

Chapter 34: The Empty Chair At The Hearing

The Royal Courts of Justice smelled of wet coats and floor polish. Emily had been sitting on the bench outside Court 14 for twenty minutes, the preliminary hearing bundle balanced on her knees, when Sian slid in beside her and said, quietly, "He's not coming."

"Who isn't?"

"Oliver. Their side. That's his usual chair, and it's empty, and I've just watched two of Kempson Laithwaite's people walk past it twice like they're scared of it." Sian nodded down the corridor. "Malcolm Rees is leading for them now. He doesn't do preliminaries unless there's something to protect."

Emily looked at the bundle, at the tabbed pages, at the schedule she had spent two nights building out of Fairview Trust grant records and Larchwell's filed accounts. Seven hundred and forty thousand pounds, traced from a charitable trust into the parent company of a care home where Marlene Osei had been left in a soiled nightdress for four hours because the night rota had been cut to save money. The two things were the same thing. That was the whole case, and it did not need Oliver Aldridge in a chair.

"You've gone very quiet," Sian said.

"I'm counting."

"Counting what?"

"How many times I'll have to say his name out loud in there."

The usher called the matter. Court 14 was small and over-warm, and Malcolm Rees was already on his feet, a QC in his sixties with the unhurried manner of a man who had never once been asked to hurry. Emily took her place at the claimants' bench. Behind her, in the second row, Marlene's daughter Abena sat with her hands folded, wearing the same navy coat she had worn to every meeting.

The judge, Mrs Justice Ferris, adjusted her glasses and glanced at the parties.

"Miss Hartwell. You appear for the claimant."

"I do, my Lady."

"And for the respondent, Mr Rees." A pause. "I had understood Mr Aldridge would be present as a director of the second respondent. I see the chair is empty."

Rees did not so much as blink. "My Lady, Mr Aldridge has taken the decision to resign from all roles within the Aldridge Foundation and its associated entities. It took effect this morning. He will not be appearing, and he will not be filing evidence in these proceedings."

The room did not react, because rooms like this one never do. But Abena's hands came apart in her lap, and Sian, three rows back, stopped writing. Emily kept her eyes on the judge and her face absolutely still, while something behind her sternum turned over once, slowly, like a coin on a table.

*This morning.* She had been in Southwark at seven, reading the Larchwell accounts with a coffee going cold beside her. He had signed something this morning and she had not known.

"I see," said Ferris. "Then we proceed on the papers as they stand. Mr Rees, your application."

Rees was brief on the law and generous with the adjectives. The claim, he said, was brought by a solicitor with a well-documented history of seeking attention for her causes; the funding allegations were speculative; the care standards allegations were the proper subject of a regulator, not the High Court; and the claimant, he said, leaning on the phrase as if testing the weight of it, was a *publicity-seeking* claimant pursuing a private grievance against a charitable foundation under the cover of a public interest claim.

"That last phrase," said Ferris, when he had finished. She had taken off her glasses. "Miss Hartwell, opposing counsel has characterised you as publicity-seeking and motivated by a personal grievance against the foundation. That is a serious imputation and it is directed at an officer of the court. You may address it directly. I would prefer you to."

Emily stood.

She had prepared for a hearing about grants and rotas. She had not prepared for this, which meant she had to say it plainly, and plainly was the only way she knew how.

"My Lady, in the last two months I have been on the front page of three newspapers in a relationship I did not choose to make public, then on the front page again when it ended. I have had photographers outside my flat. My client's daughter has had to walk through them to reach me." She did not look at Abena. "I did not seek any of that, and I did not sell any of it, and I have not given a single interview about the foundation or about Mr Aldridge, then or since. What I have done is this: I have obtained the respondent's own grant records through an application under the court's disclosure powers, which the respondent did not oppose, because they were not in a position to. Those records show that Fairview Trust, a charitable trust, paid seven hundred and forty thousand pounds to Larchwell Holdings, which owns Oakhaven Care Home, where my client's mother was left for four hours without attention. That is the claim. It has never been about him."

"Then why," said Ferris, "in your submission, has he gone?"

The question was not for her to answer, and she knew it, and Malcolm Rees knew it, and there was a small, sharp silence while she decided whether to take it anyway.

"I don't know, my Lady," she said. "I would rather find out from his evidence than from his absence."

Ferris looked at her for a moment, then put her glasses back on and made her orders. Standard disclosure from both respondents, fourteen days. Costs reserved. The substantive hearing to be listed in the new year. She rose. It was over in thirty-five minutes.

In the corridor, Abena caught her arm. "He's gone," she said. "That's good, isn't it? That's them giving up."

"It's not giving up. It's somebody moving the pieces." Emily was already thumbing her phone, scrolling for the press office line, for anything filed to Companies House in the last three hours. "It's a resignation without a statement and without evidence, which is exactly what you do when a director has something in his past that disclosure would reach."

"Then it's good."

"It's better than good." She found nothing. She put the phone away. "It's also two days before I have to sit in front of the Charity Commission and explain a letter from Guernsey that accuses me of holding stolen documents. And I'd rather know which of us they're protecting before I walk in there."

Sian appeared at her elbow, coat already on. "Press office says no comment. Kempson Laithwaite says no comment. Nadia's been ringing the foundation switchboard since ten past, and guess what—" She held up her own phone. "Somebody there told her the resignation letter was hand-delivered to the board secretary at eight-forty this morning. Two people saw it. Neither of them will say what's in it."

"Eight-forty," Emily said. "I was reading Larchwell's accounts at eight-forty."

"Yeah," said Sian. "So the question is, did you push him out, or did he get out ahead of you?"

Emily did not answer. On the far side of the corridor, Malcolm Rees was walking towards the exit with his junior, unhurried, and as he passed he glanced at her, once, and it was not the look you give an opponent you have just called publicity-seeking. It was the look you give a door you are glad is closed.

"Marlene," Emily said. "Abena, go and tell your mother the disclosure order's granted. She was right, and she should hear it today."

Abena went. Sian waited until the corridor was empty, then said, "You're going to the Commission meeting alone."

"No."

"Emily."

"I'm going to the Commission meeting with everything I've got, which is now everything Larchwell filed, plus whatever is in that resignation letter, plus the fact that a foundation's counsel stood up in Court 14 and told a High Court judge his client no longer exists as a party in any meaningful sense." She pulled her coat off the back of the bench. "Find out who the board secretary is. And find out who else resigned this morning."

"There's nobody else. They'd have said."

"No," Emily said, walking. "They wouldn't. That's the point of a hand-delivered letter at eight-forty."

Outside on the Strand the rain had stopped and the light was going. She checked her phone one more time, and there it was, finally, at the bottom of the feed: a two-line statement from the foundation's press office, no photograph, no quotes, confirming that Oliver Aldridge had resigned from all roles with immediate effect to pursue other interests.

She stood on the pavement with the traffic going past and could not decide, honestly, whether she had won or lost. That was new. She did not like it.

She did not call him.

Instead she phoned Nadia. "The board secretary. Full name, home address if you can find it, and I want to know every meeting Oliver Aldridge attended in the last eighteen months where the trustees' schedule was on the agenda."

There was a pause. "You think he took something."

"I think," Emily said, turning towards Temple, "that somebody knew the storage unit code, and I think I've just worked out who could have told them. Nadia—the 2009 trustee schedule. Oliver's name isn't on it because he wasn't a trustee then. But he was a beneficiary of the family settlement that sits behind it. We've been looking for the man who ordered Priya's audit file. What if he's not on the schedule either, because he was never a trustee? What if he was family?"

"Marlene's hearing is in two days—"

"Then I have two days." She started walking faster. "Print the schedule. And find out what Oliver Aldridge signed at eight-forty this morning, because whatever it was, someone paid a great deal of money to keep it out of Court 14."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: The Empty Chair At The Hearing · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads