The Ethical Clause

Chapter 46: The Unsigned Audit

Rachel Adeyemi's chambers were on the fourth floor of a building off Gray's Inn Square, and she had the kind of office where the walls were all books and the only decoration was a framed photograph of her parents at a wedding in Lagos, both of them laughing at someone out of frame. She had cleared the morning for this. Emily knew that because Rachel had told her, twice, in the tone of a woman who did not intend to be rushed.

"Right," Rachel said. She was in shirtsleeves, no jacket, glasses pushed up into her hair. On the desk between them lay Emily's photographs of Priya's pages, printed at A3, arranged in sequence, and beside them the marked-up reconciliation sheet the woman had posted to the Southwark office nine days earlier. Rachel had spent forty minutes with both. She now took a pen and laid it flat across the audit page, like a ruler.

"Talk me through what you think you have."

"A signed-off audit that was never signed," Emily said. "A payment pipeline to a company nobody can find. A serving director's initials next to an empty signature line. And a vote series that was never minuted, which means the payments have reference numbers that correspond to decisions that officially never happened."

"And the first of those is the one that worries me," Rachel said. "The vote series. Because you cannot prove a negative to a jury. If the minutes don't exist, the foundation says the votes don't exist, and then your fraud case is a fraud case about nothing."

Emily's stomach dropped a degree. "The payments exist."

"The payments exist. But a payment is a payment. Charities move money to trading subsidiaries all the time. Badly, sometimes, but lawfully. What you need is a document that establishes that somebody inside Larchwell knew the money was going somewhere it shouldn't, and put their hand to it." Rachel tapped the pen against the audit page. "So this is the document. Let's be precise about what it says."

She turned the A3 around so Emily could read it upside down, then turned it back.

"Look at the bottom third. This is an audit sign-off block. Standard. Preparing officer, reviewing officer, authorising director. Three lines, three names, three dates." Rachel ran the pen down. "Preparing officer: P. Raman, dated fourteenth March 2013. Reviewing officer: J. Halloran. Authorising director — " the pen stopped — "no name. A line ruled through where a name goes. And then, in the margin, adjacent, in the preparing officer's hand, the note you've already told me about."

"'Authorised per instruction,'" Emily said.

"'Authorised per instruction.'" Rachel sat back. "And above it?"

"'O.A. (Chair's Office).'"

"Which is an identification," Rachel said. "It's not a signature. If your Ms Raman testifies that she wrote those initials because that is who gave the instruction, then it's evidence of who instructed. It is not evidence that he signed. Those are two different crimes and two different men, and if you go into the Commission in six weeks saying Oliver Aldridge signed the Ridgeway authorisations, and he didn't, you'll be finished and so will your witness."

Emily had not slept much. She had lain in the dark working at exactly this, and Rachel had arrived at it in four minutes.

"So the case is — "

"The case is what the initials say. Somebody in the Chair's Office instructed the finance function to authorise a payment that the finance function would not otherwise have authorised. That is a fact your preparing officer can prove from the face of the document, because she was there when she wrote it. The identity of the instructing person is a separate question that gets answered by other evidence. Which brings me to the second thing."

Rachel pulled a single sheet from the pile. Trent Wharf Holdings.

"Your Mr Patel finds it?"

"He found it at Companies House on Thursday," Emily said. "Incorporated 2011. Registered office is an accountant's address in Croydon that services about four hundred companies. One director, since incorporation, a woman named — "

"Bernadette Osei," Rachel said.

Emily stopped.

"You found it too."

"I did." Rachel took her glasses down from her hair and put them on, which Emily had learned meant she was about to enjoy herself. "Sole director, yes. Secretary, none. But share capital is one hundred pounds, held in trust. And the trustee — the registered shareholder — is a Jersey company. And the Jersey company's beneficial owner, as disclosed in the 2012 return, is a trust. And the trust's protector is a firm of solicitors in Lincoln's Inn."

"Which firm."

"The firm that has acted for the Orchard Foundation since 1974," Rachel said. "Marcus Aldridge was a partner there before he took the chair. He kept his consultancy. It's on the website. I checked it before you arrived."

The room was very quiet. Outside the window someone was dragging a bin across the courtyard.

"So Trent Wharf Holdings," Emily said slowly, "is the foundation. Functionally. It's an arm they don't have to file on the register, because it isn't them, except that it is, because the man who signs the trust deed is the same man who signs the grant funding."

"Now you have a concealment," Rachel said. "That's the word. Concealment. The foundation applied grant funding to entities under its own beneficial control, routed through a shelf company, to fund the acquisition and holding of properties from which it then derived rental income, which income was applied — " she flicked two pages forward — "to servicing the Ridgeway loan, which loan was raised against the freehold of three of the beneficiaries' own buildings."

Emily had known the shape of it for months. Hearing it in sequence, in a barrister's flat voice, with dates, was like a hand pressing down on the back of her neck.

"Say the last part again."

"The beneficiaries' own buildings. The Orchard Foundation holds three properties for the benefit of the fifteen organisations you act for. Eldon House, Wharf Road, and the Ridgeway Street site. It borrowed against them, using a company the beneficiaries don't know exists, and it used the money to buy other property for the general endowment. Which is — "

"Unauthorised investment," Emily said. "Application of trust property otherwise than for the purposes of the trust."

"Now you're a lawyer. That's the claim. Not the press story. The press story is a man in a good suit and a girl with a car and a Christmas advert. This — " Rachel put both palms flat on the audit page — "is provable fraud and breach of trust, and the Commission will take it seriously because the numbers are in the foundation's own hand."

She reached over and picked up a second document, which Emily had not seen on the desk. Typed. Headed with the Charity Commission crest.

"Which is why you're not going in there in six weeks to talk about your boyfriend. You're going in to give evidence on a document. And I want your witness in that room with you."

"She hasn't agreed."

"Then get her to agree." Rachel's voice lost the enjoyment and went flat. "Because I can build this case on the audit alone. Raman's initials are on it, she prepared it, and she can authenticate it. I do not need her to say the word 'fraud.' I need her to say 'I wrote that, on that date, and I wrote it because that is what I was told.' Two sentences. Everything else I can do."

"She's frightened. She's been sitting on a biscuit tin under a sink for eleven years."

"Then make her safe." Rachel took off her glasses. "Emma. You know what this is now. You know it isn't a scandal, it's a theft, and you know the theft has a name in the margin and it isn't necessarily his. But the Commission will ask you about him, because his name is on the file and he sits in the chair, and on the day you answer that question you cannot be his — whatever you are."

"I know," Emily said. She did not say anything else, because there was nothing else to say that was true.

Rachel looked at her for a moment, then shuffled the pages back into order, squared them, and slid the pile across the desk.

"Take it to counsel," she said. "You have. Now take it to the Commission, and put it in writing, dated, so nobody can say later that you sat on it. And Emily — " she had stood up, and she was already reaching for her jacket — "whoever wrote 'O.A.' in that margin, the Commission is going to want him in front of them under caution. So you need to decide, before you file, whether you're going to be the person who does that to him or the person who doesn't."

The phone in Emily's coat pocket buzzed, once, against the chair leg. She ignored it, gathered the pages, and was on the stairs before she remembered to look.

A text from Nadia, timed 11:42.

Found Halloran. He's not at Larchwell. He left in 2014 and he's been doing the accounts for a hospice in Wiltshire. He picked up on the second ring and when I said your name he hung up. He called back four minutes later and said — and I'm quoting — "Has she got the unsigned one? Because if she has the unsigned one she needs to look at the numbered pages at the back, because they aren't votes."

Emily stood on the third-floor landing with the A3 bundle under her arm and read it twice.

The parallel series. The unminuted votes. Priya had said the references existed only in the payments.

She had photographed every page in that tin, and she had assumed she knew what she was looking at.

She went back up the stairs.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 46: The Unsigned Audit · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads