The Ethical Clause

Chapter 47: The Civil Claim

The claim ran to sixty-two pages before the annex, and the annex was the part Emily cared about.

She had been at the office since half five. Nadia had left at eight the previous evening, and again at midnight when Emily told her to go home; the overhead light hummed and the radiator knocked, and on the desk in front of Emily sat the second-hand printer that jammed if you asked it for more than forty pages at a time. She had fed it forty at a time all night.

The claim was straightforward in law, which was the thing Worth would hate most. Breach of charitable trust. The foundation had been established for the relief of poverty and the advancement of education, and instead its money had gone through Ridgeway into Trent Wharf Holdings and from there into things that nobody had ever put in a minute. That was the whole skeleton. The flesh was what Rachel had drafted from Priya's audit and the payment records: dates, references, the parallel vote numbers that existed in the ledger and nowhere else.

Emily read it through once more from the front. Then she turned to the annex.

Rachel had argued against the annex on Tuesday, in the flat way she argued when she meant it. *It's not evidence, it's rhetoric. Litigators who plead their feelings get their feelings read back to them.* Emily had said she understood, and had done it anyway, and Rachel, who had known her for six years, had stopped pushing after the second time.

The annex was titled *Beneficiaries Affected*. It set out fifteen organisations, in the order the money had left.

Emily had spent four days on it. Not the drafting — the checking. Jane Okonkwo had given her the Croydon figures on a Friday and Emily had driven down to the estate on the Saturday to walk the block, because you could not put a number in a court document that you had only heard on the phone. The tenants' association had a hall with a leaking roof and a scheme for fourteen after-school places that had run at eight for two years. The money for the other six had gone to Ridgeway on the eleventh of March.

Then the Archway breakfast club, which had closed on a Thursday and reopened eleven weeks later in a church hall, six tables down, smaller.

Then the two Bristol hostels. The Hull legal advice centre. The Gwent play scheme. The Sheffield care home residents' fund, which Emily had a special reason to know about, because she had sat in a meeting two years ago and watched a manager explain that the fund did not exist, and she had believed him, and signed off, and gone home.

That one still woke her up. It would always wake her up.

She wrote the entries plainly, because the plainness was the point. *Bramley Court Residents' Fund — annual allocation £48,000 — rerouted per payment reference LFX/1147 — sixteen residents, average age eighty-one.* No adjectives. No adjectives anywhere. Margaret had taught her that: *If you have to tell the judge it's terrible, it isn't.*

At six-twenty Nadia came in with two coffees and a bag of pastries and stood behind her, reading over her shoulder.

'Fifteen,' Nadia said.

'Fifteen.'

'That's more than we had on Monday.'

'I found two more. There's a literacy scheme in Newport that I'd missed because it changed its name in 2019.'

Nadia put the coffee down and read the annex in silence, moving her finger down the page the way she did. When she reached the end she was quiet for a moment.

'You've put the tenants' association first.'

'That's the order the money went out.'

'No it isn't. The Newport one went in February.'

Emily didn't answer.

'Fine,' Nadia said. 'It's your annex.' She pulled a chair over. 'Signature page?'

Emily turned to it. Claimant's solicitors, Hartwell & Co, address, date. She signed where she had signed a thousand documents, in the same cramped hand, and then she sat with the pen in her fingers and did not put the cap on.

There was one more thing, and she had not told Rachel about it, and she had not told Nadia, and she had not decided whether she would do it until the moment of doing it.

The annex was a list of beneficiaries. Fifteen organisations, and the money they had not received. That was the correct document. It was what counsel had approved and what the court would read, and it was enough.

Emily opened the document again and scrolled to the end, past the fifteenth entry, and typed a sixteenth.

*North Southwark Legal Outreach — weekend housing clinic — hourly-funded, no allocation — closed 2011.*

That wasn't the shape the others had. It didn't have a payment reference or a rerouted sum, because Gerald Hartwell's clinic had never had an allocation to lose; it had been run out of a room above a chip shop on Old Kent Road, on Saturdays, by a man with a filing cabinet and a kettle, and it had helped people who could not pay, and it had stopped when he died, because there was no money in it and nobody to pay the rent.

But if you were going to say what the foundation's money was for, you had to say what it was for. You had to say what the absence looked like. And the absence, in Emily's case, looked like a Saturday morning in 2011 with her own name on a roster in her father's handwriting, and a woman called Mrs Adeyemi — no relation — who had come in about a damp wall and left with a letter that made the council move, and an office that got colder every winter because the heater was on a meter.

She typed the entry. She read it back.

*Emily.* Nadia's voice, careful. 'That's not a beneficiary.'

'It was a clinic. It served residents. It's in the right section.'

'It's your dad.'

'It's the sixteenth entry on a list of things that don't exist anymore because the money went somewhere else. That's the section it belongs in.'

Nadia looked at it for a while longer. 'Rachel will strike it.'

'Rachel can argue with me about it on Thursday.'

'That's not what I said.'

'I know what you said.'

Nadia stood up, went to the printer, and started loading it. Emily saved the document, then saved it again to the second drive, then to the third, because she had learned in the first week of this case what happened to documents that existed in one place.

'Sixty-two pages plus annex,' Nadia said. 'Service copy, court copy, our copy. Do we serve on their solicitors or the foundation directly?'

'Solicitors. And email the court clerk at the same time, so it's time-stamped before anyone at Larchwell hears it from a journalist.'

'You think Reid will leak it?'

'I think Reid is sitting on twenty-nine months of minuted votes and has already decided what he needs to be seen doing. I'd rather the court had it first.'

They printed. The machine chewed through the last forty pages and stopped with a rattle at the exact moment the sky outside went grey-blue over the rooftops on Union Street.

Nadia bound the copies with the black clips. Emily sat looking at the annex page in the top copy, at the sixteenth entry, at *closed 2011*, and thought about how a document that told the truth still felt like a confession when it was your own father's name at the bottom of the list.

At nine-forty she walked the first copy to the Royal Courts of Justice and filed it. The clerk stamped the receipt and gave her the copy back without looking up. It took eleven minutes. Outside on the Strand, the traffic was doing what London traffic did, and Emily stood on the pavement with the stamped receipt in her hand and felt nothing much, which was how it always went.

Her phone rang at 10:04.

Not Larchwell. Not Rachel. Not Nadia, who was two streets behind her.

The screen said a number with a Bristol area code, and she had last dialled it from the top of a stairwell in Bedminster. She had left it eleven days. She stopped walking, stood still in the middle of the pavement with people flowing round her on both sides, and answered it.

'Priya.'

'Is it filed?' Priya said. Her voice was tight, and there was a sound behind it — a kettle, or traffic, or both.

'Twenty minutes ago.'

A pause. 'Then I need to tell you something before you read it in the newspaper,' Priya said. 'That number you rang. It doesn't belong to me. It hasn't for two years. I gave it to someone at the foundation when I left, so they'd have a way to reach me if anything came up about the tin. It's a pay-as-you-go. It's been in a drawer since I moved.'

Emily looked at the Strand. A bus went past.

'Priya,' she said. 'Who else knew you were at that café on Tuesday?'

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 47: The Civil Claim · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads