The Commission's own forensic accountant found it, which was the only reason it arrived at all. At half past two, during the afternoon sitting, the panel's counsel stood up and said there was a document the panel wished to put to the witness before the record closed.
Emily stayed at the table. She had been on her feet since ten that morning and her legs had gone past tired into something numb and unreliable, so she kept her hands flat on the wood and watched the accountant take the stand.
"Can you describe the document for the panel, please."
"A SWIFT instruction, outbound. Lloyds, Threadneedle Street, to a correspondent account at Rothschilds in St Peter Port, Guernsey. Beneficiary is a company called Carn Brea Holdings, incorporated in 2014, director of record one P. Marchetti, who I understand is a former trustee of the foundation."
"Amount."
"One point four million pounds."
Emily's pen stopped. She heard it stop, the small scratch of it ceasing, and in the pause a woman in the public benches said something under her breath.
"Date and time of execution."
"Tuesday the fourteenth, eleven forty-two in the morning." The accountant turned a page. "Which I'm instructed is approximately two hours before the High Court's interim freeze on the foundation's UK accounts was served."
The panel chair looked at Emily for the first time all afternoon. "Ms Hartwell. You'll appreciate this falls outside the terms of the reference you brought. Do you wish to address it?"
*Outside the terms.* Hallam's face in the corridor, the folder he had not handed over, the cover sheet he had read and nothing else. He had done the only thing he still had the standing to do — he had made sure it came from someone else, on the record, before he left the building.
"Not to this panel," Emily said. "I have no more questions for the witness."
Priya was in the second row with her coat still on. She caught Emily's eye and did not smile and did not nod, which was a kind of communication in itself: *get out of here.*
Emily got out.
In the corridor she called Wren & Cattermole for the fifth time. Voicemail. She called the chambers of a barrister she had briefed twice, whose clerk said, unhelpfully, that Mr. Ellery was in the Court of Appeal and would not be back. She called a solicitor-advocate she had worked with at Southwark — "Emily, love, what's the urgency" — and told him straight, standing between a radiator and a fire door with her notes under her arm, and he said, "Right. My room, forty minutes. Bring everything."
He was called Daniel Okonjo. He was fifty-one, he had a bad back and no interest in the newspapers, and at twenty past four he read through the transfer schedule, the hand-written chronology, and the note Emily had made of what Hallam said in the corridor, and he said, without looking up, "The panel will recommend. It won't preserve."
"I know."
"So we go to court tonight or we don't go at all."
"We go tonight."
They worked in his conference room with the blinds down. The Commission had no jurisdiction to freeze anything; the panel could name names and refer the file and by then Carn Brea would be a shell with a P.O. box and a nominee signatory and the one point four would be somewhere in the Channel Islands doing whatever money in the Channel Islands did. So the claim had to be amended — not *the foundation diverted funds*, which was a finding, but *the foundation diverted funds and here is a specific sum moved hours before the order specifically to defeat it*, which was a cause of action with a deadline attached.
Emily drafted standing up for most of it. Okonjo's junior, a girl of maybe twenty-six called Sadie who had not been home since Tuesday by the look of her, typed and retyped the schedule while Emily dictated dates from memory and then corrected them from the documents and then corrected them again, because Hallam's handwritten chronology had the Tuesday payments entered in a different order and it mattered, it mattered whether the eleven forty-two was the first instruction or the fourth.
"Is the source contactable?" Okonjo said.
"He's resigned."
"Is he contactable."
"He gave me a bank, a date, a time, and a number, and then he went home." Emily sat down finally. "He's not going to swear an affidavit."
"Then we swear yours and we attach the schedule and we don't overreach." He put the pen down. "Say what you saw, say what you were told and by whom, say what you did about it that afternoon. Judges hate adjectives. Give me the dates."
At eight-fifty that evening an out-of-hours application went in on the CHR (Urgent Applications) list with a hearing time provisionally fixed for the morning, and the amended claim was issued at nine-fifteen, and the request itself — a worldwide freezing order, in the name of the claimants and not the Commission, over everything the foundation held, moved, or had reason to believe it held — was lodged with the court at twenty past nine.
At nine forty Emily went outside to breathe. Chancery Lane, wet pavements, a row of bins, one pigeon with no plan. Her phone had four missed calls from a number she did not recognise and one from Celia, which she had now declined twice, and one message from Oliver that said, *Are you in court tomorrow.* No question mark.
She was standing there deciding how to answer when her phone rang again, and it was the unfamiliar number, and she took it because by that hour she took everything.
"Ms Hartwell. My name is Ruth Achebe, I'm a private client partner at Farlow's, I act for Mr. Oliver Aldridge." A voice like a handshake. "I'm instructed to tell you that as of this evening he has executed a personal guarantee in favour of Lloyds against the Carn Brea transfer."
The pigeon had moved off. Emily watched it go and could not think of a single thing to say.
"I'm sorry, he's done what?"
"He has given the bank his own personal undertaking, uncovered, for the full one point four million, supported by a charge over his personal holdings, so that if the funds were released in breach of any order the bank's recovery would lie against him and not against the foundation." A pause. "He made the call at seven o'clock. He instructed me that you should not be told until it was done."
"Why."
"I'll let him answer that. I'm told you'll have his number."
The line went. Emily stood on Chancery Lane holding a phone with Oliver's message still open on the screen, and understood two things at once, in the wrong order: first, that he had put his name on the money — not the foundation's name, not the trustees', his own, personal, recoverable, and in doing so had turned himself from a witness into a defendant's co-target, since anyone pursuing the funds now pursued him; and second, standing very still, that this had not been asked of him.
He had not been asked. He had read the same schedule she had, or a version of it. He had picked up the phone at seven o'clock and signed away a million four of his own money to stop money moving out of an account he had already given away, and he had told his own lawyer to keep it from her until it was finished, because he knew exactly what she would say. He knew what she would say because he had been listening to her for months.
Which meant — and this was the part that arrived walking, unsteady, like something on new legs — either he believed he owed it, in which case he thought his name on the 2010 audit put him on the hook for everything after it, every instruction, every Tuesday, and was paying without being asked and without being charged; or he had nothing to do with the Guernsey instruction at all, in which case he had just spent one and a half million pounds of his own capital buying his way to being believeable, and he had done it in a way that made him, not Emily, the party exposed if she lost.
Either way she had spent the afternoon drafting the case that would decide it.
Her phone lit up in her hand. The unfamiliar number again. She did not answer it. She stood on the wet pavement and looked at the name on the screen and thought, distinctly, that she had made the most dangerous professional decision of her life at twenty past nine this evening, and that it was not the one she had told Okonjo about.