The Ethical Clause

Chapter 57: The Freeze

Courtroom 34 of the Rolls Building had the flat, over-lit quality of a place where nothing good had ever been announced. Emily had been in it four times in her career. She had won twice.

She sat at the front with Daniel Okonjo on her left and a bundle of 340 pages in front of her, tabs already curling at the corners. The bank's counsel, a silk named Fahey who had cross-examined her in a previous life and remembered it, was arranging himself with the unhurried confidence of a man billing by the hour regardless of outcome. Carn Brea Holdings was not represented. Nobody had been able to find anyone to represent it.

Mr Justice Whitlock came in at eleven minutes past ten and had read everything. Emily knew this because he opened by summarising her own chronology back at her, accurately, and then asked Fahey a question about the Tuesday transfer that Fahey answered badly.

"The bank's position," Fahey said, "is that it executed a lawful instruction from a signatory. There is no evidence of dissipation."

"There is evidence of a transfer of one point four million pounds to a shell company in Guernsey two hours before this court's interim freeze," Whitlock said. "That is not nothing."

"It may be prudent timing, my Lord."

"Prudent," Whitlock repeated, in a tone that made the word sound like something found on a pavement.

Emily kept her hands flat on the bundle and her face still. Okonjo beside her wrote nothing; he had a habit of putting his pen down when things were going well, as though he didn't want to tempt anything.

Whitlock asked to hear the applicant.

Emily stood. She took the court through it without ornament — the nineteen consultancy payments, the engagement letter that arrived eight months after the first invoice, the unsigned 2010 audit with the initials in the margin, and the SWIFT instruction to Carn Brea routed through a bank that had, on its own internal risk memo, flagged the recipient as unverified two years earlier and processed it anyway.

"The respondent has had six weeks to explain where that money went," she said. "It has not. The person who signed the instruction has not identified themselves. The person who benefited has not been located. I'm asking the court to preserve the position before there is nothing left to preserve."

Fahey came back on the timing. He made an argument about adverse publicity and the foundation's charitable objects, and about the fact that a freezing order over a charitable foundation would strand residential residents and clinical staff.

Whitlock looked up at that. "Ms Hartwell."

"The order I'm seeking carves out operational expenditure," she said. "Salaries, utilities, food, medication, the care-home contracts. It bites on disposals over fifty thousand and on the Guernsey route. I have no interest in closing a single bed."

"How many beds are we discussing?"

"Four hundred and eleven, my Lord. Across six sites."

Whitlock wrote something. He wrote for a long time. Emily stood with her hands loose at her sides and the air-conditioning ticking overhead and did not look at the public benches, where she could feel, without turning, at least three people she knew.

"Order granted," Whitlock said. "Worldwide. Return date fourteen days. Costs reserved." He put his pen down. "I have read the witness statement of Priya Raman and the Commission transcript. I say this for the transcript and not for the press: what has taken place here is a serious breach of trust. The conduct of those who administered this foundation, and of those who assisted them, appears to have been directed at concealing the provenance of charitable funds rather than applying them. That is a matter for the claimants to pursue and for others to explain."

He rose. The court rose.

Emily had been in this building enough to know what the half-second after a judgment sounds like. It sounds like paper.

Okonjo touched her elbow. "Nicely."

"We haven't got the money."

"We've got the order. We didn't have the order at nine o'clock this morning." He was already closing his folder, and there was something careful in how he wasn't looking at her. "Press are outside. The usual."

"Right."

"Emily."

"I know."

She didn't know what he was going to say, but she knew the shape of it, and she didn't want it said in a corridor with a clerk listening. She shook his hand instead, which was not what they did, and he let her.

The steps of the Rolls Building had been colonised by a wood of tripods. There were six or seven cameras and maybe twenty people, and Emily had been through this enough times that her body knew the drill — chin level, no handbag in front, don't stop walking, don't answer the question that isn't a question.

"Emily — Emily, is it true Oliver Aldridge funded your case?"

"Is it true you were sleeping with him while he was on the board?"

"Ms Hartwell, has the foundation collapsed? Are the residents safe?"

"Emily — over here — does the order cover his personal assets too?"

That one got her. She stopped. She shouldn't have, and she knew she shouldn't have while she was doing it, but she stopped, and eleven microphones moved toward her like water finding a level.

"The order covers the foundation's assets," she said. "Mr Aldridge has no interest in the foundation. He disclaimed his interest last week and the documents are public. I'm not going to comment on anything else."

"Do you feel used?"

"Emily, did you know about the Guernsey transfer when you were—"

"I'm not going to comment on anything else."

She walked. There was a woman from the Press Association she'd dealt with before, and a man from a legal affairs blog who had once been fair to her, and she found neither of them in the crowd, which was the kind of thing that could ruin a person's morning if they thought about it too long. The crowd was cameras and freelancers and one man in a puffa jacket who filmed her the whole way to the corner and then stopped, because he had what he needed and she had walked out of frame.

She got as far as the corner of Fetter Lane before she realised she had no idea where she was going. She had a hearing return in fourteen days. She had a claim amended overnight. She should go back to the office. She got out her phone and found it had eight notifications, and she swiped them all away without reading any of them, then stood on the pavement for a moment looking at the black mirror of it and feeling, absurdly, like a woman who had just been handed something she had asked for and couldn't lift.

The office smelled of the kettle and Nadia's lunch.

They had not intended to have a party. What happened was that Priya had come back from the Commission with two boxes of M&S pastries because they were on offer, and Chidi from the housing case had brought a bottle of something from the off-licence on Borough High Street because he had heard, and by half past one there were eleven people in a room built for five, and someone had put the local radio on low, and Dan was telling the story of the Guernsey transfer in the voice he always used for the ending of the story of the Guernsey transfer, which got longer every time.

Emily stood in the doorway with her coat still on.

Priya came over with a paper cup. "You should sit down."

"I'm fine."

"You've been standing in a corridor for an hour."

"Something like that." Emily took the cup. It was tea. Priya had remembered, from nine years of nothing, that Emily took tea.

"Nadia's been on the phone to the Standard," Priya said. "She's very good. She keeps saying 'the clients, the clients' — I think she's frightening them."

"She's right to."

"Mm." Priya looked out at the room. Chidi had his phone out, filming Ola, who was twenty-three and had come to them over a damp-wall case in Camberwell and had never seen a case end well before, and who was now telling someone about a judge she had never met as though she had briefed him personally. "They don't know what a freezing order is," Priya said. "Do they."

"No. They know the foundation can't sell the building now. That's enough."

"Is it enough?"

Emily drank the tea. It was too hot and she drank it anyway. "For them, today, yes."

Nadia came off the phone and cut in front of her, red-faced, forty years old and still moving like a person who had somewhere to be. "Three things. One, the Press Association want a comment by four. Two, someone from the Commission called for you and wouldn't leave a name. Three —" she paused, holding up a hand — "Rob from the care home in Croydon called. He says the manager told staff this morning that nothing changes, no redundancies, don't worry. He says they were all crying in the office and it wasn't about the order, Emily, it was about the fact that someone outside had *done* something."

"Right," Emily said.

"That's good, isn't it? That's what you wanted."

"Yes."

"You don't look like it."

"I've got a court return in fourteen days and no idea where the 1.4 million is," Emily said. "That's all. I'll be all right by four."

Nadia looked at her for a beat, and Emily could see her deciding not to push it, which was one of the reasons Nadia worked here. She went back to the phone.

The room filled and emptied. People left at ten past two because they had clients at two-thirty, and the ones who stayed were the ones who had nowhere to be, and by three o'clock there were four of them and the pastries were gone and the radio was playing something old and Chidi had fallen asleep upright in the good chair.

Emily went into her own office and shut the door.

Her desk. The bundle. The tabs she had put in it at seven that morning with a marker pen that had run dry at the fourth tab.

She had expected today to feel like something. She'd been telling herself for four months that when the freeze came down she would know — finally, cleanly, the way you know a bruise when you press it — that it had been worth it. That the years of paperwork and the witness who kept the photocopy in a drawer and the solicitor who told her, in 2019, that she was spending her career on people who couldn't pay for it had all been standing on something.

Instead she felt like a woman at the end of a very long corridor who had arrived to find the door she remembered was the wrong door, and behind it another corridor.

Her phone lay on the desk. Celia, twice, Thursday and yesterday. Wren & Cattermole, four times. Ollie — the messages hadn't been texts, exactly, they'd been the ones where he wrote two lines at 11pm and three at 6am and she'd read them all without answering any of them.

She picked it up. She put it down.

On the whiteboard behind the door there was still the timeline she had drawn in January, eight months of it, black and red, the whole edifice of the thing in marker and it had held. She looked at it for a while.

Then she got up, and found the marker in the drawer — a new one, green — and wrote at the bottom, under the last red line, the words *Carn Brea — where is it*, and stood back, and looked at it, and let that be the whole of what she had to say about today.

Outside the window the light was going. Someone in the next room laughed, once, and then it was quiet, and Emily sat down and started to read the bank's evidence again from the beginning, because it was twelve past three and there was a return date in fourteen days and somewhere in the Guernsey channel there was one point four million pounds of other people's money.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 57: The Freeze · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads