Nadia put the paper down on Emily’s desk at ten past eight, folded so the headline faced up: LAWYER’S ALDRIDGE ‘OBSESSION’.
Emily was still holding her coat. She read it standing.
“Page four,” Nadia said. “It’s worse on page four.”
It was worse on page four. The byline was a Mail courts correspondent, the kind of piece that ran under a photograph of Emily from the Peckham fundraiser, mid-sentence, mouth open, caught in the ugly half-second before a word lands. They’d chosen it carefully. There was a second image: the Rolls Building steps, and a stock shot of Oliver in a morning coat from a wedding three years ago.
The interview was with a woman called Priya Sandhu.
Emily read the first paragraph twice before the name meant anything, and then it did — Priya Sandhu, Wren & Cattermole, second seat on the Tresco conveyancing file when Emily had been a paralegal, before the firm had decided she wasn’t the right shape for them. They had shared a corridor for eleven months. They had shared a kitchen, once, for four of those months, when Priya’s flat had flooded.
“I liked her,” Priya was quoted as saying. “Everyone did. But she had this thing about the Aldridges. Before the care homes, before any of it. She used to say the name like it was a case she hadn’t been given yet.”
“That’s not—” Emily started, and stopped, because the room was very quiet and Nadia was watching her.
“Keep reading,” Nadia said.
Paragraph six. *Ms Sandhu recalls Ms Hartwell describing the Aldridge family as ‘a machine that runs on other people’s paperwork’, a phrase she says Ms Hartwell used repeatedly in 2019.*
Emily sat down.
She had used that phrase once. Once. In an email, to Priya, in March 2019, after the Tresco file had come back from the partners with the client’s name on it and Emily had been told, kindly, to stop asking who the beneficial owner was. She had typed it at half past eleven at night in a bedroom in Camberwell and sent it from her personal account because she hadn’t wanted it in the firm’s system.
Paragraph nine. *She described the family’s charitable work as ‘a receipt they keep for the tax man’.*
That one was in a text. March 2019, or thereabouts, the week the foundation had announced the Cornwall grant. Emily had been walking to the Tube. She remembered the rain and the phone and the precise petty pleasure of a good line to a friend.
Priya had kept it for four years.
“She’s a source,” Nadia said. “She’s a source and she’s paid and she’s got a book coming out in September.”
“September.”
“Page four, bottom. *Priya Sandhu’s memoir, ‘Second Seat’, is published by Harlow in September.*”
Emily put the paper flat on the desk and smoothed it with the side of her hand, which was a thing she did when she wanted to hit something. Outside, the Southwark traffic was doing what it did. Somewhere below, the boiler in the basement was making the noise it made in cold weather, the noise David had been promising to get someone in for since October.
“How much?” Emily said.
“They don’t say. Five figures, probably. The kind of money a second-seat solicitor doesn’t turn down.”
“She wasn’t a source in the case.”
“No.”
“She was never in the case. She’s nothing to do with the care homes, she’s nothing to do with Truro, she’s never met a client of mine. She’s—” Emily heard her own voice going up and brought it back down. “She’s a person I knew when I was twenty-nine and badly dressed and said stupid things at eleven at night.”
“Yes,” Nadia said. “That’s the story. That’s the actual story. Look at the tagline.”
*‘She was building the case long before the case existed.’*
Emily looked at it for a long time.
It wasn’t a hit on the evidence. That was the thing she had to keep hold of, and she could feel herself failing to hold of it. The piece didn’t touch the Truro accounts, didn’t touch the audit, didn’t touch the fifth trustee or the £14,000 or Carn Brea or any of the narrow, load-bearing facts she was going to stand up in court and say out loud for fourteen days. It didn’t need to. It was a character piece, and character was the only thing Rachel had told her to worry about.
*She was building the case long before the case existed.* Read one way, it was a compliment. Read the way Hallam would read it, in a hushed room at the Rolls Building, it was a motive.
“Celia will have seen it,” Nadia said.
“Celia saw it before I did. Her assistant called at seven-forty.”
“You didn’t pick up.”
“I was on the bus.” Emily pulled the paper towards her again, and found the two lines, and put her finger on each in turn, as if the physical act would make them less true. It didn’t. “The email’s the problem. The text I could argue about, I could say she’s reconstructed it, we all say things. But the email’s quoted exactly. ‘A machine that runs on other people’s paperwork.’ Nine words. That’s not a memory. That’s a forward.”
Nadia didn’t say anything for a moment. Then: “Do you still have the personal account?”
“Probably. I’d have to dig. It’s a Hotmail, I think. It’d be a wasteland by now.”
“Dig anyway. If she’s quoting from the email, there’s a version of it somewhere, and you want to know whether she had it or someone gave it to her.”
Emily looked up.
“What does that mean.”
“It means,” Nadia said carefully, “that Priya Sandhu hasn’t spoken to you since 2021. She doesn’t have your number. She couldn’t have got a 2019 email out of an account you stopped using out of sentiment. Somebody handed it to her, or somebody handed her the whole mailbox, or—” She stopped.
“Or somebody forwarded it while they still had access,” Emily said.
The office door banged. David came up the stairs two at a time, coat still on, phone in hand, and stopped at the top when he saw both their faces.
“Right,” he said. “I’ve seen it.”
“Everyone’s seen it,” Nadia said.
“It’s bollocks.” He came over and read the page upside down, which he could do, a trick Emily had never got used to. “Obsessed. She’s quoting a twenty-nine-year-old. It’s bollocks and it’ll blow over in a day. The hearing’s the story.”
“The hearing’s on the 29th,” Emily said. “This is the 18th. Eleven days. Hallam has eleven days to decide whether to put a copy of this in front of the judge as part of an application on my conduct, and Rachel has eleven days to explain to me why he might get away with it.”
“He won’t.”
“He might.” She stood up and went to the window, because standing at the window was better than sitting. “And it doesn’t matter whether it blows over. What matters is who fed it.”
The office went quiet.
David took his coat off, slowly, and hung it on the back of his chair. “A former colleague,” he said. “It says so. Sandhu. You knew her.”
“I knew her,” Emily said. “I never sent her my emails this year.”
“You sent them in 2019.”
“I sent one email in 2019. Nine words, in a Hotmail account I haven’t opened since the pandemic.” She turned round. “The quote’s exact, David. Down to the comma. That’s not an interview, that’s a document.”
Nadia had gone very still, which was how Nadia went when she was working something out. “When did Priya leave Wren and Cattermole?”
“2020. Six months after I did.”
“And she’d have had your personal address from when you were friends. But not your mailbox.” Nadia was looking at the screen of her laptop now, not at either of them, fingers moving. “Your mailbox is on the practice portal, though. All our mailboxes are on the practice portal. It syncs the case accounts and it syncs anything you’ve ever connected to it, and you connected your personal account in 2022 for the Martin file, you told me you did, because the client’s daughter would only email your personal.”
Emily remembered. She remembered the client’s daughter, and the folder, and the ten minutes she had spent in 2022 thinking she would disconnect it later.
“Everyone here has portal access,” she said.
“Everyone here has portal access,” Nadia said. “You, me, David. And the intern, and the two volunteers, but they’ve only had it since April, and the intern’s in Nigeria until Monday.”
“So it’s one of us,” David said flatly. “That’s what you’re doing. You’re sitting there doing the arithmetic and it lands on one of us.”
“I’m not landing on anyone. I’m saying where the trace goes.”
“There is no trace. It’s a login and a password, it’s an audit log nobody’s ever looked at, and it’s three people who’ve been in this room since seven this morning trying to keep a case alive.” He picked the paper up and shook it. “This is the Mail. They make things up. They’ve got a woman with a book to sell. She could have reconstructed it from memory, she could have had it from a colleague, she could have had it from anyone who ever worked at Wren and Cattermole and heard you say it. You told me yourself you used to say it.”
“I said it once.”
“You think you said it once.”
That landed, and he knew it landed, and he had the decency to look away.
Emily looked at Nadia. Nadia had stopped typing, and was looking back with the particular flat patience that meant she already knew the answer and was waiting to be allowed to say it.
“Pull the portal log,” Emily said.
“I can’t. I don’t have admin.”
“Then ring Wren and Cattermole. Not the partners, the IT contractor, the one who set us up, he’ll do it for a hundred pounds and a reference.” She picked up the paper and folded it, headline in, and put it in the bin. Then she took it out again and put it in the drawer, because Rachel would want to see it, and because she wasn’t going to be the kind of person who threw things away. “And Nadia—”
“Yes.”
“Don’t tell me until you’ve got it in writing.” She sat back down and pulled the Truro bundle towards her, and her hands did not shake, which she noticed, and did not enjoy. “Because in eleven days I have to sit in that room and answer for every line of my character. I’d like to know which of them are mine.”