The Ethical Clause

Chapter 69: The Leak In The Office

The log arrived at 7:40 the next morning, a spreadsheet attachment from a man called Terrence Okoye, who ran IT for Wren & Cattermole under a service contract and who had, apparently, been waiting years for someone to ask him a question that wasn't about his invoice.

Emily printed it at the desk by the window because the office printer jammed less there. Nadia stood behind her with a mug she didn't drink from.

"Rows are sessions," Nadia said. "Column four is the login. Column seven is what it was opened."

Emily ran her finger down. There it was: HERHARTWELL-PRACTICE, the alias she'd set up in 2022 so she could work from home during the Halworth care-home disclosures. Below it, hundreds of rows. Most of them hers, timestamps she half-recognised, a two-year spine of late nights.

And then, in among them, other names. Nadia's. Two juniors she'd never met. And at intervals of a week or so, at hours Emily would never have been in the building — 06:14, 22:51, a Sunday — D.RUSSELL.

Nadia put her mug down. "He had the same alias."

"Everyone had the same alias. That was the point of the portal. Anyone with practice credentials could pull the mailbox."

"Emily."

"I know."

The sessions with David's login went to exactly one folder, every time: SENT, and the sub-folder inside it called HARTWELL-2019-ARCHIVE, which Emily had created when she'd ported her old chambers mail across and had then, in the middle of a care-home injunction, never got around to deleting. The 2019 emails. The ones the Mail had quoted word for word.

She made herself look at the dates. A session eleven days before the Priya Sandhu piece ran. Another four days after — after the Mail had called twice, after Celia had left her third voicemail — as though someone had gone back to check what else was sitting there.

"Where is he?" Emily said.

"Court. Directions hearing, the Rutherford matter. Back at two."

"Don't ring him."

"I wasn't going to."

He came in at ten past two with a paper cup and his coat still on, and Emily was sitting at the meeting table with the spreadsheet printed single-sided, because she wanted him to have to turn pages.

David looked at the papers. Then at Nadia, who was standing by the door with her arms folded, and then back at Emily. He sat down. He didn't take his coat off.

"You spoke to Terrence," he said.

"I asked for an audit log. I got one."

"He shouldn't have —"

"He should have. He's the contractor. That's the whole point of a portal, David. Somebody has to know who's in the room."

David set his cup down and turned the first page. He read slowly, the way he read everything, and Emily had always respected that about him, and now it made her want to put her fist through the window.

Column four. Column seven. His name, in his own office's typeface, nine times.

"Priya Sandhu," Emily said. "You know her?"

"I know her." He didn't look up. "She's a friend. Was."

"Was."

"She rang me in February. Wanted background on the Aldridge litigation. Wanted to know whether the office had ever had concerns about — about how you'd come to the case. I said it was a live matter and I couldn't discuss it, and I meant it, Emily, I did mean it, because it was and I couldn't."

"And then?"

"And then it went on for six weeks. And she kept saying, gently, that if I didn't, she'd write the piece anyway and it would be worse. And I sat with that."

"So you went into my archive."

"I looked," David said. "I looked to see what was there. I wanted to know what she could find on her own, so I could — so I could manage what came out. Damage control. That's the phrase I'd use, and I know how it sounds."

"You forwarded her my schedule."

Silence. Nadia shifted by the door.

"You forwarded her my schedule," Emily said again, "because she asked when the trial was listed, and you sent it in the same email, and somewhere in that email —" she flipped to the page and turned it round to face him, a printout of the sent item Terrence had been able to recover from the backup — "you told her the 2019 exchange existed. You didn't send it. You told her where to look. Which is the same thing with fewer steps."

David folded his hands. He had very clean hands, Emily noticed, for the first time in four years — a man who did the papers and the billing and the insurance renewals and never touched the case files, and here he was with his hands folded on her table.

"I didn't send the emails," he said.

"You didn't have to. You knew she had a memoir coming and a publisher's deadline, and you knew exactly how a woman like that writes."

"I know how I thought about it at the time. I thought I was protecting the practice. I thought if the story was going to run, better a version where you'd answered."

"I did answer. I gave the Mail a statement."

"Not about the emails. You never told me about the 2019 emails at all. I found out they existed by reading them."

"That's because they were private."

"They were work emails on a work archive on a work portal," David said, "and that's the argument you'd make for a client, and you know it."

Emily stood up. She walked to the whiteboard, where the trustees were pinned in order and the fifth name was still blank. She stood there with her back to him because if she looked at his face she was going to say something she'd have to live with.

"How much did she pay you?"

"Nothing."

"That's the answer I expected. It doesn't help."

"No."

Nadia said, from the door, "The audit's going to be disclosable. If Hallam applies on conduct before the twenty-ninth, he'll ask what the office knew and when. You'll be asked, Emily. Under oath."

"I know."

"And if it comes out that the co-founding partner of the firm leaked material to a journalist from the claimant's own archive —"

"I know, Nadia."

David turned the pages back and squared them. He put his palm flat on the pile.

"I'll resign," he said.

Emily turned round.

"Effective today," he went on. "I'll write to the partnership tonight. I'll instruct counsel to disclose the audit and my correspondence with Ms Sandhu voluntarily, before the twenty-ninth, so it can't be used as an ambush, and I'll take the consequences for it, which will be — I don't actually know what they'll be. Probably the end of the practice. That's not a plea, Emily. I'm not asking you for anything."

"You're asking me to keep the lease."

"I'm telling you what I'm going to do. The lease is separate. The lease is the firm's. Which means if I go, the firm is what's left, and the firm is you and Nadia and a photocopier."

"Don't."

"You owe three months. Ninety thousand on the case, forty-five of it still short, and now the office rent on Southwark, which the partnership has paid out of the Aldridge fees and which there are no Aldridge fees to pay it out of, because we've disbursed every hour of them. I've done the numbers this morning. I did them before Terrence's email, for what it's worth. The numbers were bad before the numbers were bad."

"So you're solving the money problem by leaving."

"I'm not solving anything. I'm stopping."

He got up. He put his coat on properly, both arms, the way he always did, and he took his paper cup and dropped it in the bin by the door, and Nadia stepped out of his way.

At the threshold he stopped, not turning round.

"The 2019 emails," he said. "The line about the Aldridge name. You wrote it to me. You remember that? You wrote it to me at half eleven at night and I wrote back and told you to sleep on it, and you said you would and you didn't. I kept that email. It's in my personal account, not the portal. Nobody's going to find it there."

"Then why tell me?"

"Because you're going to spend the next two weeks telling a room full of strangers that you're not obsessed, and I'd rather you knew I knew."

He left. The door did the thing it did, the half-second slow close.

Nadia sat down in his chair, which she would never normally do.

"Forty-five thousand," she said quietly. "And a lease."

Emily picked up the spreadsheet and looked at the row again — the Sunday session, 22:51, four days after Celia's third voicemail — and understood that whatever David had done, he had done it after Emily had already stopped answering, and that this was the fact that would follow her into the witness box and stand next to her the whole time she was in there.

She put the pages face down on the box.

"Get Terrence on the phone," she said. "I want the audit certified, not just sent."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 69: The Leak In The Office · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads