The Ethical Clause

Chapter 71: The First Day Of Trial

The Rolls Building smelled of carpet tiles and photocopier heat. Court 26 had the particular acoustics of a room built for accountancy disputes: everything you said came back at you a half-second later, slightly flattened, as if the walls were taking notes.

Emily sat on the bench behind the bar table with Nadia's elbow six inches from hers and the box of documents at her feet, tabbed in green. She had not slept. That was fine. She had slept before the injunctive hearing in 2023 and lost. There was a logic to it.

"You'll want to write down his adjectives," Nadia murmured. "He'll use about nine."

Fell's counsel was a KC called Marcus Ashworth, silk at fifty-two, whose entire manner was that of a man who had never once been asked to explain himself. He stood, adjusted his gown, and began.

"Sir, this is a simple case dressed up as a moral one. The claimant's foundation—"

"The Foundation," Emily said, to no one.

"—the Foundation, my client, has for forty years funded residential care, almshouses and legal advice in four boroughs. The defendant, Miss Hartwell, has brought proceedings alleging that the trustees approved a transfer of assets to a private company, Ashwell Estates, on terms that were not at arm's length." He let that sit. "We do not deny the transfer occurred. We say it was disclosed, authorised, and properly valued at the time, and that the valuations were signed off by a firm of chartered surveyors whose reputation, unlike the defendant's, has never required defending in a newspaper."

The judge, Mrs Justice Okonjo, looked up. "Mr Ashworth, I'd rather you kept the advocacy for closing. What are you asking me to hold at this stage?"

"Of course. I'm asking the court to keep in mind, when it assesses the evidence, precisely what kind of case this is. The defendant is a lawyer who found publicity easier than clients."

Emily's pen stopped. Nadia's hand closed on her wrist, brief and hard, the same grip she'd used in the taxi on the way to the Mail's offices four months ago.

"She told the High Court, in her own skeleton argument, that her practice had been 'almost entirely' funded by this litigation. She has attended three television studios in the last year. She has given an interview to a podcast called *The Trial of the Week* in which she referred to my client's family by their first names." Ashworth turned a page with one finger. "One might ask, and the court will ask, whether the allegations in this claim were constructed for the benefit of the people she says she represents, or for the benefit of Emily Hartwell."

"Miss Hartwell," Mrs Justice Okonjo said, "are you conducting this yourself?"

"I am, ma'am."

"Then when you come to address me on the evidence, address me on the evidence. But you'll be cross-examined, and you know the rules."

"Yes, ma'am."

"There's an application before me from Mr Ashworth's instructing solicitors regarding an item published in the Daily Mail on the twelfth. I intend to hear it after the claimant's witness. Let's get on. Call the claimant."

Emily stood. The room did the thing rooms do when a person in a suit stands up and everyone has to decide, all at once, whether she is a professional or a defendant. She walked to the box, took the affirmation because the oath in that room felt like a costume, and gave her full name.

Ashworth was up before she had her hands flat on the rail.

"Miss Hartwell. You're a solicitor of fifteen years' standing."

"I was admitted in 2011. Fifteen years."

"And in those fifteen years, how many tenants have you evicted a landlord for?"

"Four hundred and eleven." She lifted a hand toward the files. "Fourth tab. Schedule A, with the claim numbers and the orders."

There was a pause. Ashworth's junior wrote something.

"I wasn't expecting a schedule."

"Fourth tab," Emily said. "It's indexed."

He recovered. "Very well. You're also, are you not, the sole director of a company called Hartwell Public Interest Law Limited, incorporated in July 2022?"

"I am."

"And that company's accounts for the year ending 2024 show a turnover of one hundred and six thousand pounds, of which—"

"Ninety-four thousand three hundred was fees paid by the Aldridge Foundation in the capacity of a litigation funder, and twelve thousand two hundred was a grant from Trust for London. The cost of my office in Southwark has, since February, been met from my own savings and a loan from my co-founding partner, who resigned in June." She paused half a beat. "Fifth tab, if you'd like the management accounts, which I filed as an exhibit voluntarily."

"That'll do," Ashworth said, and the flatness in his voice told her the first swing had missed.

He tried the finances for forty minutes. He tried the podcast, and she produced the broadcast transcript and the fact-check email. He tried the phrase "almost entirely funded by this litigation," and she produced the funding agreement, clause 14, which specified that no funder could direct the conduct of the case, and clause 15, which specified that no funder's name would appear on any pleadings, and she read both aloud in the register you use for contract terms—unadorned, uninflected, one word after another.

"Your tone is very measured," Ashworth said.

"I've had nine weeks to prepare for you."

"Did you prepare a document for that too?"

"Tab nine. My witness statement, paragraph 84."

Someone in the public benches coughed a laugh. Mrs Justice Okonjo did not look up, but the corner of her mouth moved.

He changed tack at half past three. "Miss Hartwell, you've described my client's trustees in the press as 'a family who treated a charity like a wallet.' Do you stand by that?"

"I described a transfer. I said the documents showed a family treating the foundation's property as an account they could draw on. I didn't name any individual. The quote ran under a headline I didn't write."

"You didn't correct it."

"I gave a follow-up statement to the same paper, which they didn't print. Tab twelve."

"You seem to have a document for everything."

"I have a document for everything that's true," Emily said. "That's the difference between us."

Ashworth's eyebrows went up a millimetre. "Is that a comment on my client's honesty?"

"No. It's a comment on my filing."

"Let's move on. You say you never sought publicity. But you called a press conference outside these courts on the fourteenth of March. Was that not publicity?"

"That was a statement to the tenants of Ashwell Court, delivered where they could hear it, because the trustees had locked the building's lobby to anyone who wasn't on a list." She kept her eyes on the judge. "There were eleven journalists present. There were sixty-two residents. Four seats were for the residents."

"And how many of the sixty-two had signed your retainer?"

"Forty-eight."

"And the other fourteen?"

"Were waiting to see whether I'd survive the application to strike out the claim. Nine of them have since signed." She paused. "Tab six."

By four o'clock Ashworth had gone through her professional conduct, her funding, her press, her podcast, her flat, her parents' council house in Croydon, her Cambridge scholarship, the fact that she had changed her name spelling at nineteen. He had not, she noticed, gone near the accounts. Not once. Not the valuations, not the surveyors, not Ashwell Estates' register of members.

Nadia would see it too. You could read it in the set of her shoulders: the KC had come at the woman for six hours and had not yet touched the money.

"One last matter, Miss Hartwell." Ashworth picked up a thin folder. "Do you recognise this?"

She looked. She didn't need to. "It's a card index card."

"It is. Will you read it aloud?"

"I'd like to know what it is first."

"It was taken from a file held at your office, disclosed on Friday under paragraph 14 of the order of the twenty-second. The file is labelled 'Arrangement.' Counsel has an application to make about this document, and I'd rather the court heard you read it."

Mrs Justice Okonjo looked at Emily over her glasses. "Miss Hartwell, if you don't know the document, say so. If you do, read it."

"I know it," Emily said.

She looked at the card. Two years old. Oliver's handwriting in blue-black ink, and hers underneath in pencil, added at his insistence, because he had said *put it in writing, you always put things in writing*, and she had, and it had gone into the file, and the file had been disclosed, and now Marcus Ashworth was standing there in his silk with the card in his hand, smiling the way you smile when the case changes shape in front of you.

She picked it up. The room was very quiet.

"Read it," Ashworth said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 71: The First Day Of Trial · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads