The Ethical Clause

Chapter 72: Under Cross-Examination

The usher called her back at two minutes past four.

Emily had spent the morning watching Hallam’s junior take apart the asset schedule line by line, and the afternoon being thanked by her own witness, a former care-home manager who had wept twice and retracted nothing. Now Mr Justice Whitlock leaned back in his chair and let Fell’s barrister stand.

Terence Nunn, KC, was sixty-three and wore his reading glasses on a cord like a man who had never once been rushed. He adjusted the desk lamp. He had, Emily noticed, one sheet of paper and one small card.

‘Ms Hartwell. You are the claimant’s instructing solicitor. You also gave evidence for three hours on day three.’

‘I did.’

‘And you were the person who negotiated the arrangement with Mr Aldridge’s representatives in respect of the foundation’s interim funding, were you not?’

‘I was.’

‘An arrangement dated the twelfth of February.’ He held up the paper. ‘The court has it. Four pages. Clause 2 concerns access to the trust’s live evidence. Clause 3 concerns public statements. And then there is this.’

He lifted the card between two fingers so that the judge could see it, and the first row behind the glass partition could see it, and Emily, eighteen feet away, could see the handwriting.

She had written it herself. In biro, at the kitchen table, on the back of a shopping list.

‘“One word from either of them ends this,”’ Nunn read. ‘“No explanation required.”’

Someone in the well of the court shifted. Emily kept her hands flat on the desk, which Rachel had taught her, and which was the only piece of advice from that night that had survived contact with the day.

‘That is your handwriting?’

‘It is.’

‘And that card sat in the arrangement file for the duration of the matter?’

‘It sat in the working file, yes.’

‘And by it, you meant that the arrangement — the funding that kept your office open, that paid your junior, that paid the copying of the box behind you — could be terminated, without reason, at the whim of either Mr Aldridge or yourself.’

‘It could be terminated without reason. Not at a whim. On a word. There is a difference and the difference is the entire point of the clause.’

Nunn let the smallest pause open, the way a man lets a door swing.

‘You spent this morning telling the court that the residents of Elm House were entitled to be treated as parties to a decision about their own lives. That they should not be managed. That they should not be told one thing in a room and another in an email.’ He turned the card over. ‘And then you drafted this.’

‘I drafted that because when I signed the interim funding, Mr Aldridge’s people had a draft in front of me that said any withdrawal of the arrangement would require fourteen days’ written notice and a stated reason, to be circulated to the trust and to the Charity Commission. And I knew exactly what a stated reason would be used for. It would be used to say Emily Hartwell’s conduct made the arrangement untenable. It would be a lever, and it would be pulled in public, and it would cost my clients their case. So I asked for no reason at all. Because a silence cannot be quoted.’

‘So you removed the protection of the residents, in order to protect—’

‘I removed a public procedure that my clients would never see and could not use. I kept a private one that ran both ways. Mr Aldridge could walk. I could walk. Neither of us had to explain, and neither of us could be made to explain by the other. That is not a leash, Mr Nunn. That is a level floor.’

Whitlock’s pen moved. Emily did not look at the gallery.

‘You say it ran both ways,’ Nunn said. ‘Can you tell the court of a single occasion on which you exercised it.’

‘No. There was none. Our side never needed to. His did, on the nineteenth of June, when the foundation sent a note withdrawing the interim funding, and then reinstated it eight days later by telephone, in respect of which there is no written record, which is precisely what the clause was for.’

‘You are telling me the clause protected your client from being seen to be abandoned by a wealthy donor.’

‘I am telling you the clause meant that when the donor moved, my clients did not have to read about it in the Mail before I could tell them myself. Yes.’

Nunn changed hands on the card. Somewhere behind her Rachel’s chair creaked, which meant Rachel wanted her to stop talking, which she was not going to do.

‘Ms Hartwell. You have told this court that your duty is to your clients’ instructions. If a client came to you tomorrow and said, I want to stop — I want to withdraw, I want to go home to Elm House and take my chances with the new provider — what would you do?’

‘I would ask them twice. Once in the room and once a week later, in writing, because people change their minds and I don’t want a signature they regret. And then I would do what they told me. That is the whole of my practice. There is no other part of it.’

‘Have clients ever told you that?’

‘Six of them, in this matter. Bernard Achebe, on the eleventh of March, by phone at nine at night.’ She kept her voice level. ‘He said he could not be a case any more, and I said that was all right, and he is still my client and he will tell you himself that it is by his own doing. Mrs Oyelaran, in April — she asked to come off the list and then asked to come back on, which I allowed. Geoffrey Bunyard, who wrote to me in June and asked me to stop writing to him, and I stopped, and I have not written to him since, though the file remains open in case he changes his mind. Margaret Dane. Her son, who is not my client and never was, and whom I told the same thing. And one more who has asked me not to be named, and I will honour that here as I honoured it then.’

Nunn was looking at his card, and the card had nothing left on it.

‘You have named five clients and refused to name a sixth.’

‘Yes.’

‘Is there any reason the court should believe the sixth exists?’

‘No. There is no reason at all. You will have to take my word, which is the same word I have given this court for eleven days, and which has so far been checkable every time you have bothered to check it.’

Nunn sat down.

Whitlock looked at the clock and then at Emily, and something in his face was very slightly different, and she could not read it, and she had learned in eleven days not to try.

‘The witness may stand down,’ he said. ‘We will hear the defendant’s remaining evidence tomorrow morning. Mr Fell, I trust that will be brief.’

‘It will, my Lord.’

Emily stepped back from the witness box and her legs held, and Rachel’s hand closed around her elbow at the partition, and she was already reaching for the lever-arch file with tomorrow’s submissions in it before she had sat down.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 72: Under Cross-Examination · The Ethical Clause · Lumen Reads