The elevator in the Griffintown building smelled of fresh paint and old cigarettes, a combination that made Sophie Marchand glad she'd worn a blazer that had already survived worse. She stepped out on the fourth floor, and the doors opened directly into the gallery — no reception desk, no receptionist, just a long white room humming with projector noise and the citrus tang of cleaning solvent.
A man stood with his back to her, adjusting a frame on the far wall. He didn't turn around. "You're the lawyer."
"You're the one who thinks he can publish other people's weddings without asking." She crossed the concrete floor, heels loud in the empty room. "Sophie Marchand. I represent Marisol Vaz."
He turned then. Late twenties, maybe thirty, in a black T-shirt that had seen several wash cycles and jeans dusted with plaster. Dark hair pushed back with one hand, a roller still in the other, like she'd interrupted him mid-sentence with the wall.
"Gabriel Boisvert." He set the roller down on a paint tray and wiped his palm on his thigh before offering it. "Curator. Owner, technically, though I hate the word."
She shook it — dry, warm, brief. "Marisol says you seized a print of hers. From a storage unit she rented."
"Seized is a strong word." He gestured at the far end of the gallery, where a single framed piece hung under a spotlight, the rest of the wall a white void. "Come look before we argue. It's better in person."
"I've seen it."
"You've seen a photograph of it." He was already walking. "You've seen it flattened into a PDF on your phone at eleven at night. Come look at the actual object."
Sophie followed, because she was curious and because curiosity was cheaper than another hour of correspondence. The piece was bigger than she'd expected — a wedding photograph, maybe three feet by four, but torn clean down the middle and reassembled with a visible seam, tape yellowing at the edges. A bride and groom divided. The bride's half crisp, in focus, holding a bouquet. The groom's half overexposed, his face bled to white, as if the sun had eaten him.
"Vaz took this in 2019," Gabriel said. "Her sister's wedding. She sold it to a collector in Toronto two years later. Then the collector sold his holdings, and it ended up in a unit in Saint-Henri. The unit lapsed. I bought the contents at auction."
"So you bought a unit of junk and found a photograph, and now you think you own it."
"I think I possess it." He tilted his head. "There's a difference, and your client knows it, because she stopped returning my emails the moment I asked her a question."
Sophie kept her face still. That detail hadn't been in Marisol's account. "What question?"
"Whether she wanted the piece in the show." He stepped back from the frame, hands in his pockets, studying it the way other men studied cars. "I don't actually want a fight, Ms. Marchand. I want permission. Or a no. A no I can work with."
"Then why auction the man's storage at all? Why not write to her first?"
"Because it was an auction, and it was going to close, and if I didn't buy it somebody would have." He said it without defensiveness, just as fact. "I've done this eleven times. Nine times the artist says yes. The other two, I put the work back in its box and I eat the cost. She's the first one who sent a lawyer."
"I'm not the first lawyer she's sent. I'm just the first one who showed up in person."
That got a small laugh out of him, quick and genuine, gone before it settled. "Fair."
The projector hummed. Sophie walked the perimeter of the room, taking in what was already installed: a wall of letters, scanned and enlarged, a divorce decree with a coffee ring on it, a child's drawing of a house with a scribbled-out sun. All of it curated with a care that unsettled her more than mess would have. This wasn't an accident. This was a thesis.
"What is this exactly?" she asked.
"The working title is *What We Signed*." He picked up a printed sheet from a table and handed it to her. "Fourteen artists. All of them working with the artifacts of family rupture — custody agreements, photos, voice memos, wedding documents. The thesis is that the legal record and the emotional record are the same object seen from two angles."
Sophie read the sheet twice. The language was careful, almost academic, and underneath it something raw. "That's a beautiful idea."
"Thank you."
"It's also four hundred thousand dollars of legal exposure." She set the sheet down. "You've got private medical records in that vitrine by the window. You've got the *Vaz* photo, which she never released for exhibition. You've got—" she scanned the list "—a photograph of a minor child with a visible address on an envelope."
"The child's mother signed a release. The envelope is blurred in the final print."
"Blurred in the final print. So you know exactly what I'm going to say to you."
"I know exactly what you're going to say to me." He leaned against the table, arms crossed. "Say it anyway."
"Every single work in this show needs a signed, specific, informed release from every identifiable person in it. Not a gallery loan form. Not a verbal. Not *the artist wanted it shown.*" She tapped the Vaz photo without touching it. "Marisol doesn't have to give you permission to display her sister's wedding. She has to give you permission not to display it. The default is no. The show is the exception, and you have to earn it piece by piece, and if you can't document it, you take it down."
Gabriel was quiet for a moment. The projector clattered to its next slide.
"That's the whole show," he said. "If I follow that rule to the letter, the show doesn't exist. Half of these works were made in the middle of the wreckage. People show me things they've never shown anyone, and they don't have paperwork, they have *grief*. You want me to ask a woman who just got divorced to notarize her own pain before I'm allowed to hang it."
"I want you to ask her to notarize it *because* it's her pain." Sophie heard her voice go flat and didn't stop it. "I've spent eleven years watching people sign away things they didn't understand they were signing away. You know what the most common sentence in my office is? *I didn't think it would be on the record.* Photos, texts, a voicemail from a bad night. People think their lives are private. They're not. Not once somebody with a scanner decides they're art."
He looked at her differently then — not defensive, not dismissive. Curious.
"You've got skin in this," he said.
"I've got a lot of billable hours in this. Let's keep it professional."
"No." He shook his head. "That was personal. You said *their lives are private* like it cost you something."
Sophie held his gaze for exactly as long as she needed to and then looked at her watch. It was a lie, the watch glance, but it worked. "You have a decision to make, Mr. Boisvert. Take the photo down, or send me a release signed by Marisol Vaz herself, dated, witnessed. You have until Friday, or I file. And if you file-proof the rest of this show the way you've done this one piece, you're going to spend the next year in a courtroom instead of a gallery."
"Gabriel."
"Pardon?"
"Mr. Boisvert sounds like a hospital." He straightened up, reached past her for a paper cup on the table, poured from a thermos that had gone cold hours ago. "Coffee? It's terrible, but I noticed you walked here in heels from the metro, and I've been in this building since seven, so I feel some obligation to—"
"No." It came out faster than she meant.
He paused with the cup half-raised. Not hurt. Just registering.
"I don't drink coffee with opposing counsel," she said, softer, to sand the edge off. "It muddies the record."
"I'm not opposing counsel. I'm a man with a thermos."
"On Friday, you might be opposing counsel." She picked up her bag. "I'll have my office send a formal letter this afternoon. It'll be gentler than I was."
At the door, she stopped. She didn't turn around.
"The show," she said. "If you do it right — if you get every single release, if you take down what you can't document — it might actually be worth showing. I'm not telling you that as your adversary. I'm telling you as someone who'd buy a ticket."
Behind her, the roller scraped lightly against the tray, as if he were deciding whether to pick it back up.
"Friday, then," Gabriel said.
"Friday."
The elevator doors closed on the white room, and Sophie rode down four floors alone, thinking about the bride's half of that photograph — crisp, in focus, holding her bouquet — and how nobody ever tears a picture down the middle of the thing they wanted to keep.