The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 2: The Print in Question

The gallery was cold at nine in the morning, the heating not yet up to the task of the concrete floor and the tall windows facing the Lachine Canal. Sophie kept her coat on.

Gabriel came down the metal staircase from the office, two mugs in hand. He had the same sweater on as yesterday, or one identical to it. She decided not to notice.

“You didn’t have to come in person,” he said, setting a mug near her on the reception desk. Coffee, black, no ceremony.

“I did.” She took out her phone, opened the file. “A JPEG tells me almost nothing about provenance. I need to see the print, the condition, the mounting. If I’m going to threaten your client with a filing, I should know what I’m filing about.”

“He’s not my client,” Gabriel said. “I don’t have clients. I have artists.”

“You have a landlord and a board. You have insurance. Same shape, different names.” She picked up the mug, drank, set it down. “The print.”

He led her through the main room, past the freestanding walls, to the back where the work was stored. The space smelled of gesso and old paper. A flat-file cabinet stood against the wall, and he pulled open the middle drawer and lifted out a museum board folder, then laid it on the worktable under the track lights.

The photograph was under glass in a thin black frame, maybe forty by sixty centimeters. Sophie leaned in.

A bride and groom on a dance floor, mid-turn. The woman’s face was turned toward the camera, laughing at something off-frame, her mouth open. The groom was blurry, caught in motion, his hand on her waist. Behind them, other guests, a buffet, string lights. Ordinary and specific, the kind of image that could only have come from inside someone’s life.

And then, from the bottom edge to somewhere past the bride’s shoulder, the print had been torn. Not cut. Torn, with the soft ragged lip of paper that had been pulled apart by someone in a hurry. The halves were mounted slightly out of register, so the tearline was a fault, a seam, a wound that stayed visible under the glass.

“It’s titled *The Vows*,” Gabriel said. “Anh Trinh, 2019. Digital capture, printed 2021, torn 2022.”

“Torn by whom?”

“She won’t tell me. She says it’s part of the work.”

Sophie straightened. “That’s not an answer. For a release, that’s not an answer.”

“For the art, it is.”

“I don’t practice art law.”

“You practice family law, which is what this is. A family that exploded. You asked me yesterday what the show was about.” He gestured at the print. “That.”

She looked at the tear again. She did not want to look at the bride’s face. She had a face like that somewhere in her own past, laughing at a wedding that had not survived. Everyone did. That was the trap of the piece and she resented it professionally.

“Tell me about Trinh,” she said.

“Vietnamese-Canadian. Forty-one. Shot weddings for a decade before she quit. She told me she photographed two hundred and sixteen weddings and about a third of the couples are divorced now, or separated, or whatever word they use. She wanted to make something honest out of that.”

“Honest for whom.”

“For the people in it.”

“Did she ask them?”

“She says she has releases. She says she kept every one.”

“Says.”

Gabriel spread his hands. “I have not seen them. She moved twice since 2019. There’s a storage unit in Saint-Henri and a hard drive she claims is at her sister’s place in Brossard.”

“And the Vaz print specifically. Marisol Vaz is the woman in the photo?”

“Yes. Marisol Vaz, now Marisol Vaz-Lévesque, though the Lévesque is on the way out, according to Trinh. The groom you can barely see is Simon Vaz.”

“The hotelier.”

“The hotelier.”

Sophie pulled out a chair and sat, which she hadn’t intended to do. She read the wall text card Gabriel had propped against the frame, printed in the graphics he’d mocked up for the show: *What We Signed — Marisol Vaz, 2019. The artist asked a bride to tear her own wedding photograph. She cried. She did it anyway.*

“She tore her own photograph,” Sophie said.

“That’s the claim.”

“That changes things and it doesn’t. If she tore it, she made something. She still has rights in her own image being exhibited. And if she tore it, she has a story the client would rather not have told in a room full of people who know him.”

Gabriel pulled the other chair around and sat across from her, forearms on his knees. “You noticed that too.”

“I notice everything. It’s the job.” She flipped the folder open. Behind the framed print was the paperwork — a loan agreement, two pages, handwritten additions in blue ink at the bottom, three signatures. She read it twice.

“This is between you and Trinh,” she said.

“Yes.”

“It says the artist warrants that all necessary permissions have been obtained and indemnifies the gallery against claims.” She looked up. “That’s a wall, not a shield. If Marisol didn’t sign, the indemnity doesn’t conjure a signature. It just means you can sue Trinh after Marisol sues you.”

“You say that like it’s a comfort.”

“I say it like it’s a fact.” She took photos of each page with her phone, slow and square, the way she’d want them if this ended up in a file. Then she closed the folder. “Who else is in this show?”

Gabriel hesitated, which was what she’d been waiting for.

“How many works,” she said.

“Twenty-two.”

“How many by Trinh?”

“Nine.”

“How many involve identifiable private individuals who are not the artist.”

He didn’t answer fast enough.

“Gabriel.”

“Most.”

Sophie put her phone in her coat pocket. Outside, a cyclist went by on the canal path, wheels hissing on wet pavement. She was aware, suddenly, of how quiet the gallery was, and of the fact that she’d been here forty minutes and billed no one.

“Here’s what I can do,” she said. “I’m not filing today. Today I go back to my office and I write a demand that is two sentences long, and one of those sentences is a deadline. Friday. You produce a signed, dated, witnessed release from Marisol Vaz for the use of her image in *The Vows*, or the piece comes down and goes into storage pending resolution. Not destroyed. Stored. That’s me being reasonable and I want you to notice it.”

“I notice it.”

“Good.” She tapped the loan agreement. “I’m taking a copy of this.”

“It’s the only copy in the building. Trinh has the original.”

“Then I’ll photograph it and take the photographs, and if this goes sideways and you and I end up in a courtroom on opposite sides, I want it on the record that you let me look at it.”

Something moved across his face — not worry. Interest. He got up, went to the office, came back with a white letter folder and a pen. He wrote *COPY — S. Marchand, Nov. 14* on the corner of the folder before he slid the sheet in.

“You write on my evidence,” she said.

“I catalogue everything. It’s the job.”

She almost smiled and stopped it. She stood, buttoned the coat she had never unbuttoned, and took the folder under her arm.

At the door, he said, “Sophie.”

She turned.

“Did you ever tear anything up?”

The canal ticked behind her. A delivery van rolled over the cobbles on William.

“You have until Friday,” she said, and stepped out into the cold.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 2: The Print in Question · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads