The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 19: Unsigned Releases

Monday, 8:52 a.m. The gallery's meeting room smelled of fresh paint and burnt coffee. Linh had set out three cups and left. Sophie sat with her coat still on, the Van Hoorn folder squared in front of her like evidence.

Gabriel came in with his sleeves already rolled, a pen behind his ear he would forget about.

"Nine o'clock, he's never early," he said. "Which gives us eight minutes. There's something you need to see first."

He slid a print across the table. A wedding photograph. The bride and groom had been torn down the vertical, the two halves joined with yellowing tape on the back. At the seam, their faces had been cut apart and pressed back a millimeter out of register, so the groom's cheekbone sat slightly too high for the shape of his skull, and the bride's smile had a thin white rupture running through it from lip to chin.

"Bélanger says no," Gabriel said. "It's the third time he's said no. He says victims aren't material."

"And your funder wants it in."

"Van Hoorns want it in. The couple's dead, so nobody complains. That's their argument." He turned the print over. A gallery label. No signature, no release, no date.

"Whose work is it?"

"We don't know the photographer. We know it's from the collection — it came in with the Van Hoorn bequest, so provenance is theirs. That's what they keep telling me." He looked at her. "You're making the face."

"I'm not making a face."

"You made a face." He sat down across from her. "Bélanger's objection goes to the committee Friday. Van Hoorns are the largest funder of the campaign and Henri has already hinted he'd like this resolved in a spirit of generosity."

"Generosity."

"He used the word twice."

Sophie opened her bag. She took out a manila envelope that had been in the bottom drawer of her desk since the second week of the protocol — releases she'd pulled from the New Haven case and the Robitaille file, forms she carried to consultations when clients needed to see what an unsigned one looked like when it landed on a desk with a lawyer's name on it.

She laid out four pages. "These are all unsigned. Different cases, same structural problem. Look at this one." She tapped the second page. "A groom in a hotel lobby, twenty-six years old. You know what he did last March? He sued the photographer, the wedding venue, the magazine that ran the image, and the gallery that sold the print. Not because the photograph was cruel. Because he didn't sign."

"Did he win?"

"He won enough. Two years, discovery, an expert on emotional harm, a client's mother deposed on her son's childhood bedwetting. Settled at two hundred and thirty thousand before trial, which is the same number as a loss and no more satisfying. He doesn't get the image back. The photograph is still on someone's wall. But the photographer doesn't work in Canada anymore."

Gabriel picked up the second page by the corner, as if it might react. "This is your scare tactic."

"This is my Tuesday." She sorted the pages back in order, the groom on top. "You asked me to look at the folder. I looked. There's no release, no photographer, no date. The subject's face is cut in half in a photograph you plan to hang in a publicly funded institution whose expansion depends on a board on which sits the man who wants it hung. You want to know how easily a subject sues? I'll give you the more precise answer. They sue the moment someone tells them who to sue. The question isn't whether the claim is good. Most of them aren't. The question is whether the gallery has eleven hundred dollars an hour and three years of quiet."

"That's not what I asked you here to hear."

"You asked me to look at the folder by Tuesday. It's Monday."

Gabriel put down the page and ran both hands through his hair, leaving it standing. He did that when he was really thinking, and Sophie hated that she knew that.

"Represent us," he said.

"Excuse me."

"The gallery. Informally, or formally, whichever survives contact with your partners. Bélanger wants to fight it and Van Hoorns want it hung and I'm standing between them with a curatorial statement and no lawyer. You did this for eleven years. You know the map."

Sophie sat back. The coffee had gone cold enough that the film on the surface had set. Down the hall someone was dragging a light stand, the wheels rattling on the concrete.

"I can't."

"Why not."

"Because you're the client, Gabriel." She said it flat and even, the way she said it in her office, with the door closed and the tissues within reach. "I've been advising you for five weeks. If the gallery becomes my client, then everything I've told you — the protocol, the Ouellet file, this" — she lifted the folder an inch off the table — "is attorney-client material. Which means I can't be counsel on one side and have a personal stake on the other. Which is a conflict of interest. Which is the one thing I'm not allowed to do, because if it ever surfaces, the whole protocol is poison in every artist's hands, and the man who advised the gallery is the same man who sits three rows back at the funding gala."

"I'm the client."

"You are not the gallery."

"I'm the curator."

"The curator is an employee, and the gallery is an institution, and the institution is where Henri Vachon sits." She let that land. "If you want someone to hold that line, it can't be me."

Gabriel was quiet for a moment. Outside the glass, Linh passed with a stack of catalogues, glanced in, kept going.

"So what do I do," he said. "I mean, that's not a rhetorical question. I took this job to build a room where people would stop flinching. That's what the exhibition is. And now it's a corporate liability and a family foundation's guest list. And the person I trust most on it is telling me she'd be ethically obliged to sit down."

"I didn't say I'd sit down."

"You said you can't."

"I said I can't represent the gallery. There's a difference." She opened her left hand on the table, fingers fanned, as if there were something in it. "If you transfer the file — whoever you retain, I can't be inside it. But before you retain anyone, you need to know what Friday looks like. Bélanger needs a paper reason to say no, not a taste reason. He doesn't have one yet. Van Hoorns have money and a dead couple. You have —" she looked at the torn photograph "— a picture that nobody signed, that no one can defend as work, from a collection that isn't yours, about a marriage that ended badly before it began. I'd write your committee a memo saying the gallery's exposure is not the print, it's the process. That's the sentence. Not 'the artist's intent.' The process."

"Write the memo."

"After nine," she said. "Henri's car is outside."

Gabriel turned. Through the glass, past Linh, past the front desk, the black sedan was parked on the curb, engine running, a driver in sunglasses reading his phone. Henri Vachon stood on the sidewalk with his hands in his coat pockets, looking up at the gallery's facade as if measuring it.

Gabriel stood and reached for the torn print.

Sophie put her hand flat on it, keeping it on the table.

"Not in the meeting," she said. "He hasn't seen this one yet, has he."

"He's seen a proof."

"Do you know that, or did you assume it?"

Gabriel didn't answer.

"That's the memo," Sophie said. "Someone in Van Hoorn's circle has a copy. Which means your provenance file is already public inside the building it will hang in. Keep it here."

"It has to go back to the collection."

"Then it goes back with a receipt and a witness, and not by you, and not until Friday's vote." She slid the folder back into her bag, then took it out again and pushed it to him, keeping only the loose release pages. "Your office, his office, we're not doing either. The artists' storage on the mezzanine, logged as pending review. I'll walk it over myself."

Gabriel looked at the folder. Something in his jaw worked and then settled.

"You're not counsel," he said. "You made that clear."

"I'm not counsel."

"Then what are you, in there." He nodded toward the door, where Henri was now crossing the lobby.

The question sat there. The same question she'd left with him in the stairwell a week ago, and he still hadn't answered it, only made it impossible for her to stop asking it.

"Late," Sophie said. She stood, put the releases back in her bag, and started for the mezzanine stairs as Henri Vachon's reflection reached the meeting-room glass and stopped, one hand raised to the latch.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 19: Unsigned Releases · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads